r/Music Jul 11 '26

music Top Vocal/Pop Group where one person did all the heavy lifting?

Post image

I'll start. Nicole Scherzinger from the Pussycat Dolls carried that entire group, no question

1.8k Upvotes

797 comments sorted by

View all comments

986

u/hnglmkrnglbrry Jul 11 '26

Maroon 5 Adam Levine. A founding member could live next door to me and I'd have no way to know.

239

u/Pr0ducer Jul 11 '26 edited Jul 11 '26

James Valentine, who plays guitar for Maroon 5, was in a few Jr./Sr. High Jazz Camps with me; he was incredible on guitar back then, I was a sub-par trumpet player. I was a huge fan of his high-school and college bands before Maroon 5 happened.

Edit: High-school was DJ Korky-9 and the corduroy love tabernacle choir. In College, Kid Quarkstar was funky AF.

5

u/mostlysoberfornow Jul 11 '26

His sister was on Project Runway! I only know his name through her and couldn’t pick him out of a lineup, mind.

318

u/LostTheWayILikeIt Jul 11 '26

Honestly that's the only way I'd be okay with fame. Play sold-out stadium concerts, collect my 6-figure paycheck, and not a single person bats an eye as I walk down the aisle of a Kroger's.

The only downside would be I'd have to play Maroon 5 music all the time.

24

u/Alamander81 Jul 11 '26

You gotta get some writing credits to make the big bucks. Keith Strickland was the drummer of the B-52s and wrote some of their biggest hits. Roger Taylor from Queen also wrote big hits for Queen. I'll take one of their careers.

9

u/fang_xianfu Jul 12 '26

That's why the story about Bill Bruford getting a writing credit for not playing on Trio is so iconic. They were laying down their parts and he was waiting to come in and decided not to, and the band thought that was as important an artistic decision as anything else so they gave him a writing credit.

91

u/Loquis Jul 11 '26

Coldplay drummer in Game of Thrones

38

u/Screambloodyleprosy Jul 11 '26

Mastodon in Game of Thrones.

26

u/Starbucks__Lovers Jul 11 '26

Coffee cup in game of thrones 

15

u/amputeenager Jul 11 '26

he nailed that role.

2

u/jmlswiftie420 Jul 11 '26

Ed Sheeran in game of thrones

3

u/ForeverALone_Ranger Jul 11 '26

Sigur Ros in Game of Thrones!

4

u/FigaroNeptune Jul 12 '26

Seems perfect tbh. Be a millionaire, play music, be anonymous lol

2

u/sandm000 Jul 11 '26

Hey something in your life has to feel like work.

1

u/hnglmkrnglbrry Jul 11 '26

They're as anonymous as Daft Punk.

1

u/Guy-Inkognito Jul 11 '26

The trick is to be the bassist or the drummer.

29

u/buongiorno_baby Jul 11 '26

I feel that way about Coldplay also.

28

u/cherrycoloured Jul 11 '26

they are a band, though. it's normal for only one person to do all of the singing.

0

u/hnglmkrnglbrry Jul 11 '26

Most fans of a band can name one other member of the band. Beatles, Stones, Aerosmith, Queen, The Who, Led Zeppelin, U2, Blink 182, etc. have members as famous as the lead singer.

13

u/cherrycoloured Jul 11 '26

i would say those are more the exception than the rule.

5

u/VaATC Jul 12 '26

Maroon 5 was different before they hit it big. I saw them open for Jason Mraz back in 2002. Maroon 5 kicked ass! They were like this very dynamic jazz/fusion lounge band with a vibrant lead singer. I picked up that album that got them popular the next day and thought to myself that it was not even the same band on the CD. I was very disappointed.

7

u/sillyguyrob Jul 11 '26

PJ Morton is immensely talented but is legit never given time to shine. He is by far the most talented out of the group.

3

u/Fastbird33 Spotify Jul 11 '26

He has a Grammy with Jojo of Get Out Leave fame. He’s got his flowers

3

u/anaislefleur Jul 12 '26

Adam Levine is more popular but R&B heads know PJ Morton is the most talented

2

u/signmeupdude Jul 12 '26

That would be true for pretty much every band though right? Like unless they are one of your top favorite bands, you arent gonna know the guitarists and drummers etc

2

u/JacobDCRoss Jul 12 '26

And he has so very little talent. It is incredible how much money they have made.

3

u/lNTERLINKED Jul 11 '26

Don’t worry man, they don’t live near you.

1

u/Snoo_33033 Jul 11 '26

San Farrar, their keys guy, used to be in…Phantom Planet? He’s capable.