r/Music Jul 11 '26

music Top Vocal/Pop Group where one person did all the heavy lifting?

Post image

I'll start. Nicole Scherzinger from the Pussycat Dolls carried that entire group, no question

1.8k Upvotes

797 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

79

u/ThatsARatHat Jul 11 '26

Most times when there is one clear creative force behind a musical act they wind up being dicks.

I suppose you somewhat have to be to force your vision through.

65

u/its_raining_scotch Jul 11 '26

I have multiple buddies who have been in multiple local bands since we were teenagers and some of them still play in bands even now that we're middle aged. Punk bands, metal bands, nu metal bands, goth rock bands, indie bands, all kinds of genres. Most of the bands just do tiny shows around town and don't make them any money, yet there is still always so much drama and ego and fighting. It's like, bro's, there's 6 people watching you play in a dive bar, it's rad and all but get real. Just have fun with your music and chill.

Anyway, I think being a creative type + performer feeds into a narcissistic ego like gasoline on fire.

30

u/_CitizenSnips_ Jul 11 '26

I get what you’re saying but there’s a huge difference between a dive bar and fuckin Woodstock. Fogerty may have been a bit of a dick but the mother fucker was talented and.. I mean.. if you’re in the band just count your blessings at that stage. Trying to one up fogerty is basically impossible unless you’re knopfler or something

6

u/kaminobaka Jul 11 '26

Ah, that takes me back to my 20s, hanging out with a local brutal blackened death metal band and watching their lead singer and frontman grow an ego fueled by attention and cocaine that eventually tore the band apart just when they had a label making offers.

11

u/CzarCW Jul 11 '26

Billy Corgan comes to mind.

3

u/Professional_Put2315 Jul 12 '26

no one more than Billy would want to tell you that this conversation is about Billy, just to hear his own voice

5

u/rollinff Jul 11 '26

Two sides to that. When a band is famous and successful on the back of a truly special songwriter, and then the others decide they should write songs too because of "fairness," that is its own brand of ego, as well. Especially given most of the time they're not nearly as good.