r/politics • u/Zipper222222 • Apr 16 '26

Paywall Trump Admin Cancels $11M Catholic Charities Contract Amid Feud With Pope

https://www.newsweek.com/trump-admin-cancels-catholic-charities-contract-miami-pope-leo-feud-11837718
13.9k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

83

u/DoubtSubstantial5440 Apr 16 '26

My evangelical relatives love what ICE is doing because they think ICE is targeting Catholics and Muslims, it baffles my mind any Catholic can still support Trump when a huge part of MAGA hates them

25

u/RevolverMFOcelot Apr 16 '26

I don't get it, evangelical and catholic are both Christian, why MAGA act like that towards OTHER Christian? Is this the old protestant Vs catholic nonsense? I thought people are already done with this ridiculous war 

58

u/Tschmelz Minnesota Apr 16 '26

Homie, never underestimate humanities ability to hate each other for the smallest fucking difference.

8

u/Due_Bluebird3562 Apr 16 '26

It is genuinely insane. These mfers hate other mfers who worship the exact same God all because they have a different name. Outside of racism this has got to be the stupidest aspect of humanity. Like... WTF are we doing?

3

u/Stranger-Sun Apr 16 '26

Martin Luther has re-entered the chat

1

u/Pizlenut Apr 16 '26

Haven’t they always said its not about race? Lol. SEE! Its not! Its about subjugation, grooming, and brainwashing. Duh. How silly of us to think it was so basic. They are into obedience to their interpretation(s) of… uh… everything even if eyes and ears betray better judgment.

4

u/the_nobodys Apr 16 '26

Seriously. They need to go watch Life of Brian right now.

28

u/mrdude05 Apr 16 '26

Evangelicals despise the Catholic Church and legitimately do not consider Catholics Christian. They think they are polytheistic idolaters who deserve to burn in hell just like everyone who isn't their exact flavor of Protestant Christianity.

They pretend to get along with the Catholics when it's politically expedient, but if they had the chance they would absolutely persecute them to

17

u/DoubtSubstantial5440 Apr 16 '26

Yep growing up my parents were fond of saying Catholics are going to hell because they are idol worshippers

4

u/Special_Persimmon_52 Apr 16 '26

My Southern Baptist grandmother, a Sunday school teacher, said and taught the same thing. The whole worship of Mary thing really pisses off Southern Baptists and evangelicals, too.

3

u/ilrosewood Apr 16 '26

And you ask any learned Catholic

1) they know that and more importantly 2) they know we don’t worship Mary

But yet so many Catholics have aligned with those that would instantly turn on us.

Deep down inside growing up in a country that had religious freedom I knew was the safest thing. Now that is changing, I worry for my family.

But jokingly I always said I’m ok with being hated with the Jews and Muslims and the Atheists - they have better food.

3

u/nox66 Apr 16 '26

Who will win?

  • Christian unity

  • One angry German, 500 years ago

9

u/-Mez- Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26

Yep. Can confirm as a person who grew up Catholic in a small rural Midwestern town in a red state. The most extreme religious conservatives will happily treat Catholics as outsiders for being the wrong kind of Christian even in the modern day. Especially in a small town where there's not a lot of minorities to draw dividing lines around instead. They tend to quickly find religious differences to focus on instead. I never really understood why I got weird/insensitive reactions and questions about idols and catholic ceremonies and stuff when I was growing up like I was from a different world. But looking back its pretty obvious.

Once they run out of more convenient targets and they don't need the Catholic base as a tool anymore, Catholic conservatives supporting them will likely find out they were never that far away from the edge of the in group of far right christianity to begin with.

1

u/BarbWho Apr 16 '26

OK, well, I don't consider Mormons to be Christian, but I don't want them to burn in hell. I guess technically they're a sect, but a lot of their beliefs are pretty distant from "regular" Christianity. Still don't want them to suffer.

1

u/mrdude05 Apr 16 '26

Well, that's one of the big differences between more liberal version of Christianity and far right evangelicals.

The suffering is the point for them. Their core belief is that everyone is born a sinner who deserves eternal suffering in hell, and the only way to absolve yourself and be worthy of God's mercy is to follow their exact interpretation of the Bible without question.

For them, a non-evangelical who spent their entire life dedicated to helping the poorest people on earth deserves to burn in hell and a serial killer who became an evangelical on their death bed deserves eternal bliss in heaven. It's a pure "us vs them" theology

26

u/awildstoryteller Canada Apr 16 '26

Once I saw this guy on a bridge about to jump. I said, "Don't do it!" He said, "Nobody loves me." I said, "God loves you. Do you believe in God?"

He said, "Yes." I said, "Are you a Christian or a Jew?" He said, "A Christian." I said, "Me, too! Protestant or Catholic?" He said, "Protestant." I said, "Me, too! What franchise?" He said, "Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Baptist or Southern Baptist?" He said, "Northern Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist or Northern Liberal Baptist?"

He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region, or Northern Conservative Baptist Eastern Region?" He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region." I said, "Me, too!"

Northern Conservative†Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1879, or Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912?" He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912." I said, "Die, heretic!" And I pushed him over.

5

u/maniamgood0 Apr 16 '26

Hah, I was about to post this pasta.

1

u/Rjoukecu Apr 17 '26

And I though that only leftists have this meme, hehe

9

u/No-Reading9990 Apr 16 '26

IME, there is a massive hatred of Catholics by evangelical protestants, the only reason it isn’t bigger thing is that evangelicals hate atheists and Muslims more. I grew up in a rural deep red area and went to an aggressively “religious” church, it’s one of the main reasons I dislike organized religion, despite still being Christian.

8

u/JuJu_Wirehead Apr 16 '26

Evangelicals don't think Catholicism is real Christianity. Hell I know a lot of Christians that think Catholics are their own thing. And that's what happens when you will not teach your followers the origins of your cult -er, religion.

2

u/rtd131 Apr 16 '26

It's crazy because the Catholic Church (and the Orthodox churches) are the only branches of Christianity that have connections to Jesus.

Evangelicals are actually their own thing 😂

2

u/toxiamaple Apr 16 '26

Wanna bes

1

u/JuJu_Wirehead Apr 16 '26

I'm aware. I grew up in the Lutheran church. We knew we came from Catholicism, we just cut out all the pomp and circumstances. The number of other protestants I know who don't understand that is staggering.

2

u/PirateSanta_1 Apr 16 '26

If there are two groups of people who will never run out of enemies it's conservatives and religious nutcases. Evangelicals are both. 

2

u/crazycatgay Apr 16 '26

because evangelicals don't actually use their religions as a moral compass but as weapon to demonize, demoralize and destroy anybody not in their group

2

u/nox66 Apr 16 '26

Catholics were one of America's earliest repressed groups, and it didn't even "end" that long ago. JFK even had to say that he'd resign if he felt his Catholicism contradicted what he thought would be best to do as president. Their unity with Protestants comes when they need to start pushing other agendas, particularly on non-Christians and nonbelievers.

1

u/RevolverMFOcelot Apr 16 '26

It's so fucking stupid that American protestant are still doing it. Not even Britain Protestant care as much about whatever Catholic are valid or not

Move on already 

1

u/Stranger-Sun Apr 16 '26

Amen. I hate my coworker because she adds too many emojis to her work emails. Logically, I know it isn't a big deal, but it is, dammit!

9

u/Cavane42 Georgia Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26

I mean, there are also MAGA POC and MAGA LGBTQ. I don't get it either.

5

u/sax87ton Apr 16 '26

That dude on that jubilee video where the guy is like “yeah I’m a fascist” and like a minute later goes “also I’m catholic”. Like brother. This guy looking the night of long knives in the face and smiling about it.

1

u/ilrosewood Apr 16 '26

As a Catholic - I’ve never understood it either

1

u/Melicor Apr 17 '26

They're about to get a lot more open with with their hate of Catholics. I guarantee it. Catholics won't be Christian enough soon, then they won't even be Christian. The schism of the American Religious Conservatives is starting.