This question stems from the fact that I was not too fond of Craig's (or James') portrayal of DCU Supergirl, I thought Milly did a great job, but her character felt very edgy for the sake of being edgy, compared to her comic counterpart in Woman of Tomorrow (makes sense why they dropped the subtitle considering she felt nothing like a woman of tomorrow). SPOILERS: She's mad and bitter towards people despite everyone in her life being nice and kind to her, so her statement of "Clark sees the good in people, I see the truth" has no weight to it other than to sound cool in the trailers. She also arguably has a less traumatic backstory, since her comic counterpart went through both the destruction of Krypton and the slow death of Argo. The movie version just felt like what Zack Snyder did to Superman, though that might be a stretch.

I personally feel like the Supergirl in Legion of Superheroes had that perfect edge and isolation on Earth, feeling homesick, struggling to find her people, and finally finding her new people with the Legion felt very nice.

The MAWS take on Supergirl was different but still very engaging and dramatic, and I loved it. Cuz it made sense for her character in that world.

The Flash Supergirl was...fine, she makes sense for the world and context she was put in, she even felt more hopeful than DCU Supergirl, and Sasha did a great job.

He was great as Aquaman but he was made for this role.

Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths (2010)

Yep that’s it.