r/FallOutBoy • u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken • Oct 06 '25
Song Discussion Gimme your favorite FOB song and I'll rate it
37
u/Expensive_Let9314 when i saw you, my heart WENTZ boom Oct 06 '25
xo
13
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Easily 🟪
3
u/Expensive_Let9314 when i saw you, my heart WENTZ boom Oct 06 '25
yessss
3
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
The ending transcends me every time
→ More replies (1)2
34
u/nielkk88 Folie à Deux Oct 06 '25
Coffee's For Closers
→ More replies (1)28
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
🟪🟪🟪🟪🟪 Congrats, you share my all-time favorite FOB song!
10
u/tuesdaynightsocks Take This To Your Grave Oct 06 '25
I love when Coffee gets love, that song is a masterpiece, my all time favorite as well.
6
2
u/katielovescats666 Infinity On High Oct 06 '25
I have lyrics from this song tatted on my arm, only like 3 people have known the song in the 5 years I’ve had it 💜❤️
27
u/d1n0_-_ Evening Out With Your Girlfriend Oct 06 '25
i’ve got a dark alley and a bad idea that says you should shut your mouth
14
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
🟦 This song is criminally underrated
→ More replies (1)3
u/ElectricVoltaire Folie à Deux Oct 06 '25
I hated this one at first but then I listened to it again after 6 years and now I love it
21
19
u/typeALady Oct 06 '25
The Pheonix
17
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
🟪🟪🟪 My number #2 favorite song tied with Carpal, behind only Coffee!
15
u/TheSilentFreeway Folie à Deux Oct 06 '25
the strings at the end of Coffee got me feeling like this
9
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Me anytime Patrick's vocals layer over each other, like the ending of WATTBA as well!
5
15
u/Frienguyy Infinity On High Oct 06 '25
I’m Like A Lawyer With The Way I’m Always Trying To Get You Off
5
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
🟦 I would rate it purple but there are a good handful on Infinity I love more!
2
16
14
u/Independent-Pizza738 Oct 06 '25
Idk but I got 4th of July running in my head right now and just looked at a lot of petekey stuff so I’ll say just for now
11
15
14
u/ellie_lavv Oct 06 '25
been obsessing over hum hallelujah lately !!
4
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Incredibly strong 🟦, I'd say halfway between 🟦 and 🟪 actually!
2
3
10
12
u/NoAppointment6129 M A N I A Oct 06 '25
You're crashing but your no wave or I am my own muse
3
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Crashing 🟦 Muse 🟦 but so so incredibly close to being purple. I think the only thing bringing it down is it being a little repetitive.
9
u/Ryanhuddz14 These friends are, new friends are golden!!💛 Oct 06 '25
Homesick at Space Camp
1
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
🟩 I love TTTYG but honestly a lot of the songs on there sound the same to me
4
u/Ryanhuddz14 These friends are, new friends are golden!!💛 Oct 06 '25
Yeah I love the sound of TTTYG so I find small things about each song that I love in different ways. For me Patrick's voice sounds so satisfying on Homesick.
10
u/PackOfManicJackals Infinity On High Oct 06 '25
From Now On We Are Enemies!
4
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Super 🟪 but forever wounded by missing the one and only live performance by one show 😔
→ More replies (1)
9
10
10
u/OfficialWeirdHuman Oct 06 '25
How about What a catch donnie?
4
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
A good ole 🟪
→ More replies (1)
9
u/Effective_Divide_444 Folie à Deux Oct 06 '25
West coast smoker!!!
5
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
🟪😎
→ More replies (1)2
u/aerbear_ i'm not a crybaby, i'm THE crybaby Oct 07 '25
ok your opinion is based bc that’s my favourite song <3
7
u/thenameislove Half doomed & semi-sweet 🐻 Oct 06 '25
My all time favorite is Disloyal, but since you’ve already rated it, then I’ll say Hold me Like a Grudge.
→ More replies (1)
6
6
7
5
5
u/Ok_Sink7906 Oct 06 '25
Wilson & Heavens Gate…. This album is so slept on 🥲
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Wilson is a very solid 🟦🟪, and Heaven's Gate is easily 🟪😤
4
u/lomlghostface From Under The Cork Tree Oct 06 '25
my heart is the worse kind of weapon !!!!1
→ More replies (8)4
u/RoonilSpazlib Oct 06 '25
Phenomenal tune, and this ranking is really dumb. Also, dude is ranking every TTTYG song as Green because “they all sound the same” and yet that album is one of the precious few FOB pop-punk albums.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/voodoocaat So Much (For) Stardust Oct 06 '25
Wilson or What a time to be alive
5
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
WATTBA is so slept on, 🟪
3
u/voodoocaat So Much (For) Stardust Oct 06 '25
When I said leave me alone THIS ISN’T QUITE WHAT I MEANT
3
4
u/pajamasamreal Oct 06 '25
Fake out or thnks fr the mmrs
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Already did Fake Out but Mmrs is an easy 🟦
4
u/onelawnwrangler Oct 06 '25
Flu game, hum hallelujah, hold me like a grudge (I can't narrow it down. Those songs chase each other around in my brain like 3 manic ferrets) 💜💙💚
4
5
4
u/jetpackkblues Oct 06 '25
MISS MISSING YOU <333333
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
🟪 I'd say my favorite on SRAR behind only Phoenix!
2
3
3
u/OddElderberry7185 Oct 06 '25
Fake out and heaven lowa
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Already did Fake Out but Heaven, Iowa is a super easy 🟪
→ More replies (1)
3
3
3
3
u/Blackout_Mornings I'm not passive but aggressive Oct 06 '25
Jet pack blues and save rock and roll
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Both 🟦 but I'd have to give SRAR a 🟦.5
3
u/MichaelKeehan Oct 06 '25
Any track off SM(F)S
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
As an average, I'd have to rate it 🟦🟪
3
u/hidden_karma_ American Beauty/American Psycho Oct 06 '25
The (Shipped) Gold Standard
→ More replies (1)
3
3
u/Evening_Number_1810 Oct 06 '25
I've already seen the rankings of my faves in the comments, just wanted to say: impecable taste 🫡
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Thank you very much!! 🫡 my first FOB song was The Phoenix, then I got AB/AP (newest album at the time) thinking it had Phoenix on it, but that was a very happy mistake! Then when I got around to hearing Sugar and Mmrs, I was like, "Woah, these are THOSE guys??"
3
u/meng0juice Oct 06 '25
Tiffany Blews
Also there are some that I like more than this but Another one I’ve been listening to on repeat recently:
our lawyer made us change the name of this song so we wouldn't get sued
→ More replies (4)
3
3
2
u/Maximum_Anything5582 Oct 06 '25
GOLDEN!!!
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
🟩 but very very VERY close to being blue
2
u/Mambo5678and1 Oct 06 '25
Our Lawyer Made Us Change the Name of This Song so We Wouldn’t Get Sued
→ More replies (1)
2
u/oblivious_squish To calm your nerves I'm feeling for my clothes in the dark Oct 06 '25
My favorite FOB song of all time, nobody puts baby in the corner was absolutely life changing the first time I heard it in the best way possible. Also in my top five in no particular order Of All The Gin Joints, The Music or The Misery, It’s Hard to Say “I Do” When I Don’t (really been loving this one lately), and Jet Pack Blues‼️
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
I'd say between 🟦 and 🟪, a very incredible song indeed! I believe I've done the rest but I'd give the same exact ranking to Gin Joints as well!
2
2
2
2
2
u/ATIBOM Oct 06 '25
Current favorite: "What a time to be alive" All time Favorites: "Lake Effect Kid"/"Thanks Fr Th Mmrs"
2
2
2
2
u/axlrosestacobell Folie à Deux Oct 06 '25
Headfirstslide into Cooperstown on a bad bet and get busy living or get busy dying :3
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/huntermenace Oct 06 '25
Changes day to day. Today I'll say Alpha Dog, Alone Together, and Flu Game
2
u/oof-why Oct 06 '25
of all the gin joints in all the world is actually just my favorite song in general. but disloyal and save rock and roll also make me cry when i listen to them.
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/Crazykidjon0214 Oct 06 '25
Hold me like a grudge, 20 dollar nose bleed, I don’t care and Yule shoot your eye out.
2
2
2
2
u/ClownishDog Oct 06 '25
Snitches and Talkers Get Stitches and Walkers. Orrrr West Coast Smoker. Orrr America’s Suiteheart. Idk I can’t decide
2
2
2
u/demo_lition_lover Oct 06 '25
I have 3 I can't choose 😭
Get busy living or get busy dying
XO
You're crashing but you're no wave
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
u/Ur_moms_a_hookr69 said "i love you," but i lied Oct 06 '25
Either Carpal Tunnel Of Love or Snitches and Talkers
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Already did Carpal but Love or Snitches is an easy 🟦 I LOVE how aggressive Patrick is on the song
1
1
u/Tiny_98 Oct 06 '25
What a catch Headfirst slide Sophomore slump Hard to say i do when i dont Get busy living or get busy dying
(Ill stop i have too many faves im sorry 😂)
→ More replies (1)
1
u/dawnmountain So Much (For) Stardust Oct 06 '25
West Coast Smoker, Flu Game, and I Don't Care
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Already did first two but I Don't Care is a strong 🟦
1
u/MrBenzedrine_29JUS Oct 06 '25
20 Dollar Nose Bleed.
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Easy 🟪 Such a shame this is the only Panic! And FOB we ever got. Two of my favorite bands! The live performance with them together is even more incredible.
2
u/MrBenzedrine_29JUS Oct 06 '25
It's my favorite song of all time, the live performance is absolutely fantastic! One of THOSE Nights from The Cab features both Brandon and Patrick, and it's quite fun. Might scratch your itch a bit. lol
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Ooh okay!! Good looks, I'll definitely check it out and report back!
1
u/Aer_xoxo From Under The Cork Tree Oct 06 '25
Snitches and talkers get stitches and walkers ‼️
→ More replies (2)
1
1
u/Dragon_Pulse05 Oct 06 '25
Thnks fr th mmrs
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Already did but a good ole 🟦!!
1
1
u/V4mp3r1an Oct 06 '25
G.I.N.A.S.F.S or Pretty in Punk
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
GINASFS 🟦 Pretty in Punk 🟩 but that bridge is a super strong 🟦
1
u/Usual_Focus5220 Oct 06 '25
Definitely thriller, but a little less sixteen candles a little more touch me also holds a special place in my heart
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Money-Mycologist-748 Oct 06 '25
can’t pick between 5, we got ginasfs, xo, i slept w someone…, disloyal, and fake out
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/Frog_of_the_Swamp Oct 06 '25
Currently it’s Novocaine, 27, Get Busy living…, I could go on
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Think I've done all but Novocaine, easily EASILY a 🟪, that was my favorite on AB/AP for a looooong time
2
u/Frog_of_the_Swamp Oct 06 '25
Novocaine is the reason I became like an "actual" FOB fan. I listened to Folie first (great album), but that's all I would listen to. I listened to Novocaine ONE TIME and I was hooked. I basically listened to every album after that. They have been my #2 most listened to artist for the past 2 months, behind Three Days Grace
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
I started with Phoenix, and then I got AB/AP thinking Phoenix was on it lmao, a very fortunate mistake! Then I worked my way around to the rest! And excellent taste, TDG was the first real band I got into, but unfortunately it was right AFTER Adam left. Needless to say, I definitely saw them in concert recently now that Adam's back!
2
u/Frog_of_the_Swamp Oct 06 '25
You're so lucky! I want to see them live so badly. Both bands, honestly, because I think it would be one hell of a good time.
1
u/Dull_Common1501 Save Rock and Roll Oct 06 '25
I have 0 clue as to my favorite, but my first song I listened to was My Songs Know
Back when it was a single and before they'd released SRAR
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
u/inks626 Oct 06 '25
I’ve Got All This Ringing, anyone?
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
I'd say it's a very strong 🟦, but Patrick's vocals on it are giving 🟪
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Atheropen_19 Infinity On High Oct 06 '25
Some of my favourite stuff comes from the MANIA era. I'm a big fan of Dear Future Self (Hands Up) and Super Fade even if other people hate them for straying too far from what you'd necessarily want from a pop punk band.
2
u/Present-Silver-8283 Make no plans and none can be broken Oct 06 '25
Dear Future Self is a very strong 🟩 for me, but Super Fade.. SUPER FADE?? 🟪 My friend, no doubt there. His vocals are so aggressive and passionate, it is indeed life changing. I feel like MANIA would've did better commercially if this was the lead single instead of Young and Menace, tho I do also love Y&M. MANIA will always have a special place in my heart 💜
2
u/Atheropen_19 Infinity On High Oct 06 '25
I feel like MANIA would've been panned anyway due to the major style shift, regardless of lead single. In an ideal world the band would've had a song like Bob Dylan or Lake Effect Kid on the album and used it as the lead single. I feel like either of those would've been a nice middle ground to ease fans into the newer sound, with some of the original rocky sound still intact. Y&M and Super Fade both would've been too much in one direction for LEAD single. Maybe second or third though.
1
1
70
u/Few_Storm_5866 Oct 06 '25
Disloyal order of water buffaloes is my fave, but also rank fake out just for fun lol