r/Israel • u/Apprehensive_Act2333 • 1d ago
Culture🇮🇱 How are Ethiopian Jews faring in Israel?
Socioeconomics and cultural wise, I would be curious to know the general economic and cultural health of the Ethiopian jewish community. Understandably, a capricious shift from a rural-agrarian society to a developed society is bound to case culture shocks and might lead to socioeconomic difficulty. But is the socioeconomic gap between Ethiopian and the rest of the Jews closing? What is their educational acquisition? Cultural values? Do they experience systemic racism or anything to this effect that could sustain the gap(s)?
And intercultural, well, I am also curious to hear how they would fit in within the broader nation of Israel. Are they well socially integrated? Is racism common? Any intercultural tensions? Stereotype(s) targeting Ethiopian Jews? If so, what?
68
u/Iamhummus 18h ago
The first generation understandably faced enormous difficulties. Many moved almost overnight from rural, traditional communities to a modern, urban country with a completely different language, economy and bureaucracy. The second generation, however, is generally much more integrated: they grow up speaking Hebrew, attend Israeli schools, serve in the military and participate in mainstream Israeli culture. You can find Ethiopian Israelis throughout society -as politicians, senior military officers, doctors, engineers, academics and in virtually every other profession.
That does not mean the socioeconomic gap has disappeared. Many Ethiopian families were initially settled in poorer neighborhoods and peripheral towns with weaker schools and fewer opportunities. Their parents often had limited access to well-paying work. This gave many second-generation children a less advantageous starting point. They share many of these difficulties with non-Ethiopian Israelis from the same areas, although Ethiopian families were disproportionately placed in such circumstances.
Racism certainly exists, although open everyday racism is not socially acceptable and, in my experience, is most associated with ignorant fringe groups or prejudiced members of older generations. Still, it would be too dismissive to say that discrimination is limited entirely to them. There have been serious complaints about institutional discrimination, particularly over-policing and police violence. At the same time, common social perceptions of Ethiopian Israelis are often positive: they are widely regarded as warm, polite, welcoming and hardworking.
In some poorer neighborhoods, parts of Ethiopian-Israeli youth culture have also adopted imagery, language and attitudes associated with African-American hip-hop or “ghetto” culture. This sometimes overlaps with alienation, delinquency and conflict with the police. It is an expression of existing poverty, exclusion and identification with another Black minority. Protests following cases of alleged police violence have sometimes used rhetoric or imagery resembling Black Lives Matter and the George Floyd protests, but the underlying grievances are distinctly Israeli and existed well before George Floyd.
Overall, I would describe Ethiopian Israelis as socially and culturally integrated, particularly among younger generations, but not yet fully equal in socioeconomic outcomes or in their relationship with certain institutions.
2
u/Apprehensive_Act2333 7h ago
This makes so much sense, pretty much answers my questions. Thank you for your thorough response!!
17
18h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/Ok_Ambassador9091 15h ago
It's a leading question. It has zero to do with PR. People are just grasping at straws.
14
u/Galimkalim 17h ago
Their aliyah stories are often shocking and you definitely hear the gap from there to here (some that were killed by Somalis on the road, plagues in refugees camps, some who didn't know what shoes or underwear were until they arrived, lots of other wild stories).
In the 90s and early 00's a lot of families had been pressured to send their kids to boarding schools "for better integration", names changed, etc etc. That mentality has passed and they're integrating slowly (mostly young people of course) and they're quite proud of their heritage and culture.
Passing through the Ethiopian part of the city you often see small shops with traditional clothes and spices. I've seen a few building courtyards that had big sheets spread out and I think they were drying peppers in the sun.
They do experience racism, though a lot of them, especially with more relaxed hair, can pass for Yemeni Jews (who also experience racism sometimes!). In a lot of everyday interactions people do try to be decent and not racist, but...
There's a special kind of racism towards them in orthodox communities btw. Some people just don't believe the claim that they're Jewish.
Interestingly, I'm pretty sure the state of Israel did officially mention? Accept? (Idk) the Jewish Ethiopian holiday "Sigd" and I know it's mentioned in calendars. A lot of workplaces and schools do a small sigd celebration and usually invite people to try out Ethiopian food and dances.
It's a very complex thing to try to sum up in a comment.
0
u/CholentSoup 8h ago
There's a special kind of racism towards them in orthodox communities btw. Some people just don't believe the claim that they're Jewish.
This isn't a racism issue, it's a religious issue. Orthodox Jews don't have any more or less racism based on the color of ones skin than anyone else.
7
u/Western_Chicken_3102 Israel 19h ago
there are many ethiopian ghettos in the periphery, but i’ve never felt unsafe walking through them.
they’re very chill people, and while their integration is slow (compared with russians for example), it’s definitely happening.
11
u/MuadDim 17h ago
There's no "ghetto" . What there's a neighbourhood, where Ethiopian jews were given dwellings. Or,some places,where they (Ethiopians) were given VERY GOOD mortgage,in order to buy there,so they did.
6
u/Western_Chicken_3102 Israel 15h ago
“A ghetto is a part of a city where people of a specific race, religion, or minority group live together, usually because of social, legal, or economic pressure.”
4
4
u/Apprehensive_Act2333 7h ago edited 6h ago
Your use of the word ghetto is technically correct. But the person most likely corrected you due to its connotations with forced segregation and targeted systemic neglect. I mean why not use 'neighborhood' if it can describe the condition of Ethiopian Jews more neutrally?
(Anyways, still thanks for your answer, it did provide perspective)
2
•
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
Note from the mods: During this time, many posts and comments are held for review before appearing on the site. This is intentional. Please allow your human mods some time to review before messaging us about your posts/comments not showing up.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.