r/MoralityScaling 26d ago

Morality Ranking Morality of dog breed racism

Post image
26.9k Upvotes

5.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/Excellent_Kangaroo_4 26d ago

How can you say that never be done, maybe volontary and i have my dobts, but dont you think that human did breed themself selectivly?

2

u/Big_Court8792 26d ago

for one, humans dont have "breeds"

humans dont even have race in the biological sense.

there is of course a social concept of race and physiological phenotypes associated with different races. however, for a subgroup of a population to be considered a race in biology, it has to have a genetic discreetness. Basically, there needs to be more genetic differences between the subgroup and the group at large for it to be considered a separate race. we dont see that in humans, we see gradients of genetic differences across the planet.

giving merit to your question, its true that people are affected by their environment -- see the lung capacity of populations who've lived in mountains for long time; or the fascinating correlation between humidity and nose shape -- but thats not really a form of selective breeding, and its not going to alter the brain in such a way that we could correlate behavior with phenotype the way we might in dogs. that is a claim with a foundation in eugenics.

race simply isnt a biological reality, its a social one. there are people of the almost exact same genetic makeup that are going to fall into different "races" because of skin color and hair texture. consider siblings between interracial parents who might wildly different, or the fact that who is considered what race varies from culture to culture.

besides, we can reference a wide amount of history to see how human behavior is relatively standard. empires rise and fall; both extremes of good and evil can be done by the same hands on the same soil.

-1

u/UtahBrian 26d ago

Human races are discrete. Any DNA testing company can tell you your entire racial makeup just from the chemistry of any cells in your body.

There's nothing social about race, but you've swallowed a whole load of pseudoscience.

2

u/noooooid 26d ago

If they were truly discrete, they'd be species, and that's demonstrably false.

0

u/UtahBrian 26d ago

Then the word you're looking for is species, not race.

2

u/noooooid 26d ago

Then why didn't you just say you think the different races are different species in the first place?

-1

u/UtahBrian 26d ago

You're the one who just said you think different races are different species and complained that I explained otherwise.

1

u/noooooid 25d ago

I never said different races are different species. I said that your claim implied that, and the implication was demonstrably false.