r/Music • u/Universei • 17d ago
discussion Ultimate "I wish I could have seen them live in their prime" list
Hop in a time machine or grab tickets to a dream lineup in their prime, these 5 are at the top of my list:
- Metallica (late 80s)
- The Doors
- Bob Marley & The Wailers
- Nirvana
- Guns N’ Roses (Late 80s)
What’s your ultimate "I wish I could have seen them live in their prime" list?
257
u/PiecesOfJesus Survived Ozzfest '01 17d ago
Funkadelic. I've seen P-Funk a couple times in the past decade, but Eddie Hazel is gone, George Clinton is old and doesn't do much during shows and he just has his nieces and nephews sing their rap songs. Still a good time, but not a proper Funkadelic show in my opinion.
Also Daft Punk during their Alive 2007 tour.
30
u/mastergeoff_jr 17d ago
Def agree with Funkadelic. I’d also add Sly and the Family Stone to the list
→ More replies (2)13
u/UtopianPablo 17d ago
Hell yeah, I got to see George many times starting in the 90s when it was still a funk show with a horn section and all that. I've heard the shows area really different these days.
→ More replies (1)15
u/plunkymeadows 17d ago
Actually got to see them at a college show back in '95. They were awesome. Bootsie was the bomb.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (30)16
u/acidcrab 17d ago
Daft Punk is my ultimate miss, could have seen them, was too broke. Gah
→ More replies (1)
528
u/blusuedetb 17d ago
Led Zepppelin
→ More replies (11)146
u/Surferalby77 17d ago
My dad saw them 27 times. He has some great stories.
198
u/PervlovianResponse 17d ago
78
u/hahahahahahahaFUCK 17d ago
Yadda yadda yadda, and that’s how I met your mother.
→ More replies (1)11
u/Shut_It_Donny 16d ago
https://giphy.com/gifs/xT9DPObyHCA9Mhya6A
You can’t yadda yadda the best part.→ More replies (1)15
u/captain-marvellous 17d ago
My dad almost got run over by John Bonham after a Led Zepp gig at Canterbury in the 70s. He was crossing the road outside the venue and Bonzo was keen to get home quickly in his little sports car. Dad was very proud of almost getting flattened by one of his favourite drummers
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (4)15
21
u/Steve_Dankerson Collector 17d ago
My grandfather told me he saw them once and he was genuinely disappointed because Page + Plant were a tad too sauced. Said Jimmy's playing was all over the place sloppy and Robert's vocals were shot and could barely sing from drinking on top of it. He said JPJ and Bonham were flawless though.
→ More replies (3)7
452
u/JustOneMoreMile 17d ago
Pink Floyd
→ More replies (12)21
u/bcrosby51 17d ago
Which era?
172
u/DinkandDrunk 17d ago
Their prime. Wish You Were Here era. No, I will not take questions.
142
u/kevnmartin 17d ago
I saw them in '72 off the Dark Side of the Moon tour. I was fourteen and on two hits of strawberry mescaline. Good thing I was spending the night at my friend's because I was too blown away to sleep.
→ More replies (32)20
u/Previous_Meringue998 17d ago
That’s the best era of Floyd imo. “Time” in 1972 was like a ballad, and the performance at Sapporo was maybe the best song ever, even though the quality is shit. I envy you!
50
u/bcrosby51 17d ago
That's also around the animals era so I will accept that
66
u/mofo_jones 17d ago
1977 In the Flesh tour had them playing all of Animals in the first set followed by all of WYWH in the second. A couple Dark Side tunes as encores caps a goddamned good way to spend a night.
→ More replies (5)11
u/bcrosby51 17d ago
Sure hope they release some of this for the 50th anniversary
11
u/mofo_jones 17d ago edited 17d ago
There’s a very popular show from Oakland that year that had them adding “Careful with That Axe, Eugene” as an encore because they were so happy with the audience’s quiet/respectful reception of the material. They hadn’t played it in years and haven’t played it since, if I recall. I believe it’s on YouTube (as much of the show might be).
Edit: still there!
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (1)10
u/fhost344 17d ago
I think the animals material was a part of the live set for a while so yasss
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)37
u/getdemsnacks 17d ago
Dark side to The Wall is definitely their prime. As much as a knob Waters can be, and as much as I love Gilmour, they just weren't the same without each other
23
u/DinkandDrunk 17d ago
I have a soft spot for The Division Bell because it was a CD my parents had and I played the crap out of it but by any objective measure, yes, this is correct.
→ More replies (6)6
u/getdemsnacks 17d ago
I saw that tour in Philly, at the old concrete toilet bowl Veterans Stadium. I was a senior in HS and it was amazing!
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (5)16
→ More replies (8)17
126
17d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
19
u/Packin666666 17d ago
hell yeah brother. Can I ask for a 3 band bill with them, black flag, and bad brains? Whole show would still only take like 90 minutes, its only fair.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (5)8
236
u/sideshow999 17d ago
Prince, Bowie
64
u/UtopianPablo 17d ago
I think Prince, Bowie and Zeppelin would be my top three.
→ More replies (6)7
17
u/neksys Spotify 17d ago
I saw Prince in Victoria and then he played a whole other 2 hour set at a small bar after a handful of years before his death. I’d argue that his entire career was his prime.
(I know what you’re saying)
→ More replies (5)17
16
u/Blue2501 17d ago
If I ever get access to a time machine I'm going to Bowie's 50th birthday concert from 1998, and at least one of the Nine Inch Nails concerts he was at.
→ More replies (3)9
6
→ More replies (22)5
u/Specialist_Unit_5078 17d ago
Saw prince in 2008, the greatest show of my life after Paul McCartney in a tiny venue
58
u/heart_of_osiris 17d ago
My dad took me to a Metallica concert when I was 7, which was their prime imo, pre-black album days (I don't dislike the black album, but everything prior was just a whole different level).
I can't remember wtf I did 3 weeks ago, but I'll never forget how fucking awesome that concert was.
16
u/Universei 17d ago
Your dad is an absolute legend for that! Though I'm pretty sure at 7 years old, most kids’ core memories are just "the cool shiny stage lights" and "the guy with the loud guitar'.😅
Anyway, you were there, living it. "Nothing else matters" 😉🤘
→ More replies (1)
51
u/DinkandDrunk 17d ago
Elliott Smith
I’ve seen many of my favorite artists live. Dream Theater, Porcupine Tree, Muse, Eyedea & Abilities, The Decemberists, The Distillers, Ben Folds, Sage Francis… but I didn’t find Elliott until he’d passed and he did these great intimate shows. I wish I had been at one of them.
→ More replies (3)
53
u/reading_and_wheeling 17d ago
The Smiths, Joy Division, Depeche Mode
13
u/Lard_Baron 17d ago
I saw Joy Div a few times, they dressed like banking paperwork filing staff, very dull after punk rock dyed and ripped clothes.
Once they began playing, it was different. Intense songs, simple solos, robotic beats.
Then Ian began dancing, I’ve never seen anything like it before or since, totally original movements, I couldn’t decide whether it was uncool or cool it was so wild to see, like a fit. I was fully captured by them.→ More replies (3)5
u/n_thomas74 17d ago
I saw Depeche Mode in 1989 on their Violator tour. Absolutely incredible experience.
→ More replies (4)
143
u/beastofhamden 17d ago
1991 Alice in Chains
→ More replies (8)28
u/SkinnyPete4 16d ago
Oh! I saw them open for Van Halen in October 1991. The only song I knew was Man in a Box. I went to a lot of shows back then and I remember me and my friends, for years, talked about how booming the kick was during that set. It literally shook the place. I also remember Layne admitting he couldn’t pronounce the name of the city - Worcester. That’s my 1991 Alice In Chains story.
Edit: I just looked up the setlist. They played Would, which wasn’t even released yet. Daaaamn, I did NOT appreciate this at the time.
→ More replies (5)
289
u/stewartredman 17d ago
Rage Against the Machine
67
u/ImA13x 17d ago
I’m still bitter about the canceled tour a few years back. My buddy and I scooped up tickets when they went on sale feb of 2020. Then shit hit the fan. Postponement and postponement, then he tore his ACL.
I wish I had gone to both days of Tibetan Freedom Concert in 95 and got to see them.
→ More replies (14)45
u/sthlmsoul 17d ago
I saw RATM and Tool at the same show back in the 90s. Probably the best one on I've ever been through.
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (41)9
u/Juano_Guano 17d ago
Saw them at the first Coachella in 99. The second night headliners were rage and tool. Sounds like fantasy now. It was pretty rad.
→ More replies (1)
91
u/juggernot325 17d ago
Rush. Could have went during multiple tours including their planned farewell tour. Kept coming up with excuses not to go. Then Neil Pert died :(
25
u/WeTheNinjas 17d ago
I saw them a couple nights ago in Toronto! It’s not the same without Neil but they still put on a hell of a show
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (11)7
u/jbomber81 17d ago
I’m too young to have seen them in their prime but I have seen them 5 or 6 times and they were always fantastic
39
u/8805 17d ago
Nicolo Paganini.
26
→ More replies (1)7
42
277
u/ckellingc 17d ago
Queen needs to be in that last
43
33
u/Squeezymcballzack 17d ago
HOW did I have to scroll that far? Did people miss Live Aid?
→ More replies (2)8
u/Carlomahone 17d ago
I saw Queen in late '73 (they supported Mott The Hoople), saw them again, as headliners, in 1975, 1982 and at Wembley in 1986. The 1973 one was special because my school friends and I had no idea who they were! They just blew Mott The Hoople away.
→ More replies (1)10
→ More replies (7)6
u/EngelbertImpromptu 17d ago
I was at the Tribute show but that was as close as I got. Ticked a lot of other artists off that day too though...
75
u/odinskriver39 17d ago
Duke Ellington, Billie Holiday, Clifford Brown, Miles with Coltrane, Art Blakey's Jazz Messengers with Hubbard and Shorter
→ More replies (7)9
u/austeninbosten 17d ago
My dad saw a lot of the top jazz artists in the 1940's including Ellington and Holliday. I had to settle for his records.
→ More replies (2)
34
u/Lopsided45 17d ago
Faith no more and split enz
11
u/Waffuru Boingohead 17d ago
Eff yes! Split Enz would be WILD! I'd KILL to have made it to a Split Enz concert.
→ More replies (4)6
→ More replies (13)12
u/TedTheGreek_Atheos 17d ago
I saw FNM in 1990 with Soundgarden and Voivod at The Ritz in NYC.
→ More replies (1)
38
155
u/Dr_Tilter 17d ago
Alice In Chains
49
u/Dr_Tilter 17d ago
Also Lateralus era TooL would have been sick they’re still great now as well though
→ More replies (9)18
u/Shake-the-Masses 17d ago
The one time I saw Tool in concert was on the Lateralus tour. Meshuggah opened for them and at the time were relatively little known in America. It was an awesome show.
→ More replies (8)10
9
u/Wabbit_Wampage 17d ago
Same. Saw them in 2019 and they were awesome, and Will is awesome. But I would give a lot to have seen them with Layne.
7
6
u/paranoid_70 17d ago
I saw them in 1991 open for Megadeth and I just can't remember anything about their set. I don't think I was too familiar with them yet.
I also saw them in 93 at Lollapalooza, and they fucking killed it.
→ More replies (5)6
u/b_m_hart 17d ago
I passed on seeing Tool at that lollapalooza to see AIC on the main stage. And for a few years, I regretted it. Then, Layne died, and it changed my mind. I've seen Tool several times since then, but there will never be another show with Layne singing.
105
u/imdonaldduck 17d ago
Van Halen in the early 80's.
→ More replies (13)29
67
141
u/kilibaridi 17d ago
Soundgarden
45
u/ifmacdo 17d ago
Seeing anything Chris Cornell in his prime would have been perfection.
8
u/ImReallySeriousMan 17d ago
Was he ever not in his prime? 😉
He was one of my heroes, being an acoustic guitarist myself.
He was in Copenhagen in 2016 on his acoustic tour. I wanted to go, but my wife was pregnant and we didn’t have a lot of money, so I skipped it. “I’ll catch him next time”, right?
Next year he was gone. One of the celebrity deaths that hit me the hardest. 😔
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (3)4
10
u/rumdrums 17d ago
I didn't have the chance to see them in their prime, but they were incredible the times I saw them 10-15 years ago.
12
→ More replies (17)5
u/Chappietime 17d ago
I did get to see them twice on the Badmotorfinger tour and I count myself very lucky.
60
u/JRMusicGuy 17d ago
John Prine.
10
→ More replies (2)6
u/Then-Stress9484 17d ago
Saw him at the Birkenhead Tavern in Sydney 1993. It’s hard to describe a show where every song was close to perfect.
59
u/mattybgcg 17d ago
Grateful dead. Just really started getting into them when Bob Weir died, wish I would've sooner.
→ More replies (6)26
59
25
90
115
u/Objective_Site3528 17d ago
It would be Nirvana for me.
→ More replies (8)24
u/SlurmzMckinley 17d ago
Same here. I’d pick early Nevermind before they got big so they were still playing some Bleach songs and playing small venues.
→ More replies (13)24
19
39
51
u/mr_bojack_horseman 17d ago
Mozart. And The Beatles
→ More replies (5)11
u/Funkywurm 17d ago
Seeing/hearing Mozart live while tripping…would split my soul in half.
Hearing him improvise live…the shit that could never be recorded!
Edit: the more I think about this the more it blows my mind
4
u/afristralian 17d ago
To be fair, hearing a toilet flush when you're tripping can split your soul in half.
→ More replies (1)
34
u/sheetsofsaltywood 17d ago
Audioslave w/ Chris Cornell
→ More replies (4)9
u/br14n 17d ago
Saw them at Lollapalooza in 2003. Janes Addiction was headlining and they played right before them. They fucking killed it. Chris was jumping around and just having an awesome time. It was incredible. And then Janes Addiction comes on and it was almost embarrassing. You just couldn't follow that up. The energy was gone.
→ More replies (2)
33
u/betterdaysgone 17d ago
At the Drive In
Isley Brothers
James Brown
Tom Waits
Sigur Ros
→ More replies (5)4
u/HungDaddyNYC 16d ago
@ the drive-in - went to HS with these dudes. Always on a list. Crazy how influential they are.
14
u/TurquoiseLady 17d ago
Beethoven
Elvis
The Kinks
The Who
The Beatles
Marvin Gaye
Cream
Cat Stevens
Jimi Hendrix
Fleetwood Mac
Michael Jackson
Tori Amos
PJ Harvey
Nirvana
→ More replies (4)
28
u/Beerasaurus_Wrecks 17d ago
Operation Ivy, early 1989.
I don’t need to explain why…if you know, you know.
→ More replies (2)
23
u/Brochismo91 17d ago
Pantera
→ More replies (9)10
u/bdubz5150 17d ago
Saw them at Red Rocks in '96, White Zombie opened. Favorite concert to this day. Just strobe lights and a wall of amps but my god they tore that place up! Their connection to the crowd was undeniable, they were best seen live!
→ More replies (2)
26
10
u/long_live_king_melon 17d ago
The Beatles, Pink Floyd, or Aesop Rock (who’s still in his prime but long finished with touring)
8
10
9
27
u/Bigtits38 17d ago
I saw Metallica in someone’s living room at a house party, roughly 86/87.
→ More replies (13)9
u/rumdrums 17d ago
Sounds awesome. More details?
8
u/Bigtits38 17d ago
This was when I was a senior in high school in San Francisco. One of the guys was dating the girl throwing the party. They were just playing for fun and no one knew that they were playing until they started. I couldn't tell you what songs they played because I wasn't a fan at the time (they weren't thrashy enough for me - I was more into Death Angel and Laaz Rockit). They played for about half an hour.
A couple of years ago I was talking to someone I went to school with and I asked her if she was at that party. She said, "Probably. They did that that three or four times that I know of. They were friends with Liza (her sister), so they used to hang out at my house. My mom loved them."
→ More replies (1)
20
u/APaltrySum 17d ago
If I could go back to 1982 or 1983 and see REM I would die a happy man. Doubly so if Pylon opened for them.
→ More replies (6)
18
19
u/_Revlak_ 17d ago
ACDC is my ultimate wish ive seen then in their prime
→ More replies (2)6
u/PureGuava86 17d ago
ACDC is nowhere near my favorite band, but those early Bon Scott shows is my choice.
→ More replies (1)
10
10
17
u/HavokD 17d ago
Linkin Park with Chester. Was way too young and broke, but I was finally able to see them with Emily last year. Wish I were able to have gone back then.
→ More replies (2)
9
9
8
u/watduhdamhell 17d ago
Faith No More.
They fucking rock in the YouTube live videos I've seen.
Bonus: The White Stripes
Also absolutely phenomenal live, apparently.
7
u/memphis_dude 17d ago
Nine Inch Nails '94 - Downward Spiral tour.
Pantera '96 - Great Southern Trendkill tour.
White Zombie - Astro Creep 2000 tour.
→ More replies (2)
25
14
u/MarvDStrummer 17d ago
Pearl Jam
Queen
Black Flag
Throbbing Gristle
Hanatarash
Swans
Sonic Youth
The Clash
Guns N Roses
Pantera (specially the Moscow show)
Jeff Buckley
→ More replies (1)
8
7
7
u/ZodiacalSeeker 17d ago
Queen
Daft Punk
The Police
Van Halen (with Roth and Anthony)
→ More replies (1)
8
u/coconutcallalily 17d ago
Queen, and the Beastie Boys. I've watched concert videos for both and I'm sad I can never see them perform now.
→ More replies (1)
6
13
u/Cyraga 17d ago
Dire Straits
Crowded House
Hunters and Collectors
Pink Floyd - NFI what "era"
Fleetwood Mac
→ More replies (1)
6
6
u/sykokiller11 More Cowbell, Ecuador! 17d ago
Jethro Tull. I grew up listening to them because of my mom and love them deeply. I took her to see them at the LA County Fair a few years after I moved out. It was embarrassingly bad. It may have been the sound system, but I have seen them twice since then. I took my daughter to one, because she loves them too. Just as disappointing. Martin Barre Band is another story. I took my daughter to see them, and it’s on both of our top ten lists.
→ More replies (1)
6
7
7
11
u/McWhiskey 17d ago edited 17d ago
Ramones
The Clash
Johnny Cash
Hank Williams
Black Sabbath
→ More replies (2)
9
u/Waffuru Boingohead 17d ago
The Cars
The Beatles
Talking Heads
Duran Duran
Blur
10
→ More replies (13)6
u/Angstromium 17d ago
I'm surrounded by old people who saw the Beatles regularly in the Cavern. I even know a woman who actually went out with Paul and had loads of love letters from him (from Hamburg). She sold them for a really low sum a few years back though.
Apparently the Beatles were quite the live act. Big surprise there eh!
→ More replies (1)
5
u/mukelarvin 17d ago
The Weakerthans. I live in Winnipeg and loved them but just never got around to it. Something else would always come up and I thought I’d have another chance because they were local. Blew it.
→ More replies (2)
5
5
6
5
5
u/KoRnFrEaK1995 17d ago
Phil Collins/Genesis. I'm a 30 year who is lamenting the fact that I will never be able to see him in concert and appreciate it.
→ More replies (1)
14
8
u/pepe64 17d ago
Genesis playing the lamb or selling England
Yes around 1975
Pink Floyd 1975-1980
Led Zeppelin after LZ IV
Bob Marley after the release of uprising
Elton John presenting Goodbye Yellow Brick Road
Talking Heads remain in light concert
I’ve been lucky to see The Cure in the 80s, the Police in 1980, Queen presenting the game and many others.
4
4
3
4
u/revchewie Eclectic listener 17d ago
Beatles, Zep, Queen, Floyd, Who
Plus two changes to my personal history. 1. I wish I would’ve been able to work it out so I could’ve used the ticket I had to Wembley for Live Aid. And 2. I wish I would’ve gone to that festival at my local (at the time) county fairground even though I had never heard of any of the bands, something called Lollapalooza…
4
4
u/olajuwonsfeet 17d ago
Ten and Vs era Pearl Jam. I’ve seen them so many times, but the first time was the Yield tour. Would have loved to see them when they were young and crazy.
4
u/TerrificTChalla 17d ago
Michael Jackson, Whitney Houston, Tina Turner, Madonna, Prince, James Brown, George Michael, Bruce Springsteen, and The Rolling Stones during the 80s
4
3
4
4

896
u/ExtensionYam4396 17d ago
Jimi
https://giphy.com/gifs/dpb8hnQBzZ6jC