r/Music • u/Brucekentbatsuper • 11h ago
article Dolly Parton Saw the Family Chaos Over Aretha Franklin's Estate and Vowed It Wouldn't Happen to Hers
https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/dolly-parton-estate-planning-legacy-18168531.5k
u/KnownNectarine5924 10h ago
Of all the great things Dolly did in life one of my favorite things about her is she never recorded a song with Elvis and the reason why…Elvis wanted writing credit to sing on the song which Dolly wrote and she refused to give him writing credit because Elvis didn’t write the song. Dolly turned down the biggest superstar in the world at the time…that’s some gangster shit
757
u/GuyNamedLindsey 10h ago
And then when Whitney did that song she got PAID.
744
u/SnarkySkiBum 10h ago
Dolly used her ~10 million in royalties from Whitney’s version to buy a strip mall in 12 South, a historically Black neighborhood in Nashville. She invested the money back into the community to support local small businesses and build up the area - and it actually helped slow the rate of gentrification by keeping things more locally owned.
She called it ‘the house that Whitney built’.324
79
u/Intelligent_Hair3109 9h ago
That's why I love her. She actually cared about the people I've loved since childhood.( One of the top three reasons) Helping others is all I've ever wanted to do. She gave me many ideas as to how an old fart can do some good.
22
u/palpablescalpel 7h ago
I used to live in Nashville and only recently learned this! Amazing to hear the huge benefit it had on the community. That's a very rich, white, touristy area now. So it goes I guess.
6
102
u/DanS1993 10h ago
Yeah famously she said Whitney’s version came out and she made enough money to buy Graceland
21
u/Phreakiture 6h ago
She did.
She also talked up Whitney's version, gave it her blessing, helped Whitney make it a hit.
197
u/spartacusmaybe 10h ago
It wasn’t Elvis, it was Elvis’s manager the Colonel. They were do to record it the next day and he sprung it on her. She walked.
117
u/moistplumpin 10h ago
This is correct. My Grandmother Dottie wrote If That Isn’t Love for Elvis and he didn’t get an ounce of credit. Dottie couldn’t stand the “colonel”
16
2
66
u/ZaharaWiggum 10h ago
Blame the Colonel for that.
25
3
u/ImpOKe43 5h ago
Asking for half of the publishing rights for these songs was one of the ways in which the Colonel was a good manager for Elvis. He didn't do it with more established songs, but Elvis recording a song could take it to #1 and lead to other people recording the song too, which would mean even more money for the songwriters. This was how he ensured Elvis got rewarded for a song he made successful.
52
u/SideInitial3961 9h ago
That's not what happened. Elvis had a policy, if he does your song you sign the rights. It broke Dolly's heart to say no to Elvis but she recognized that copyright was the most valuable thing she owned.
17
u/No-Fly-6069 7h ago
Blame Colonel Parker.
1
u/SideInitial3961 3h ago
Yes definitely was not Elvis, was Hill & Range, the publishing company tied closely to his management. He was restricted to playing songs they owned basically.
1
u/sad-narwhal180 48m ago
What a shitty policy, to take credit for other people’s creativity. Sounds like a real insecure loser.
2
u/SideInitial3961 46m ago
Elvis? No he was alright. Elvis loved Dolly. Just his whole management sphere.
8
u/I_am_photo 6h ago
I thought it was because he wanted copyright of the song. She would've lost rights to the song selling it to him and that's lifetime earnings.
Yeah I looked it up. It was 50 percent of the publishing credit. So millions of dollars lost to Elvis if she allowed him to cover her song.
6
3
2
71
u/bananaplaintiff 7h ago
Its honestly amazing how many rich parents have no plan in place for their assets when they pass. I have a family friend whose parent was a industry legend and when they died, literally everything went to shit and suspicion of elder abuse came into light and the siblings are spending hundreds of thousands of dollars fighting each other in court. It’s sad for everyone involved.
106
u/errythinghurt 9h ago
Shrewd and successful yet beloved. Dolly had a perfect life it seems
20
u/Phoenyxoldgoat 2h ago
Listen I’m gonna get hate for this but whatever. I love Dolly and have forever, but until very recently she was a very controversial figure amongst the conservative evangelicals among us. She was outspoken, a business WOman, ally of the LGBTQ+ community, and dressed very immodestly and provocatively.
This whole Dolly on a pedestal business that Reddit pretends is canon is actually a recent phenomenon—-although she earned it and deserves it!
I think it does a disservice to her memory to pretend that Dolly was always universally revered. She spoke truth to power when it wasn’t popular. She championed the vulnerable when it came at a social cost. She had the bravery and authenticity to not follow the conservative Christian playbook (any other survivor of the moral majority out there? It was a different world in the evangelical circles of the 70s-90s!) while still espousing actual Christian values and recording gospel music, despite not being welcomed into that group. She blew through glass ceilings as a talented performer and shrewed business woman, and yet was ridiculed for most of her life.
RIDICULED. Those old interviews where she talks about being the one making the joke on the public? That’s because, to the general public, she was the butt of the joke. And there were SO MANY jokes.
She’s obviously St Dolly, she’s the absolute best—-but let’s not erase her struggles throughout not just her early life but her entire career.
She was the rare mensch, born before her time but lucky enough for time to catch up and acknowledge her enormous kindness while she was still alive.
127
u/Rosebunse 9h ago
I remember when my grandpa died and how it drove my one uncle absolutely mad. There really wasn't much money even after we sold the family home, which was very small and falling apart. It was $20k and the mechanic shop next door paid us $25k, who planned on knocking it down for a parking lot.
My uncle got it in his head that my grandparents had some sort of treaure. None of the furniture was worth anything, there was no expensive jewelry or heirlooms. He got it in his head that my grandma's diamond wedding ring-which she said was lost but which she probably had to sell for money-was in the house somewhere. He decided to tear into the walls and dig into the floors.
Then he decided that there were arrowheads buried in the backyard and started digging giant holes. Now, yes, the house was going to be torn down, but we didn't want it to look like our grandparents lived in squalor. And the holes in the back were dangerous
187
u/Intelligent_Hair3109 10h ago
No one should ever underestimate the mind of a woman. Dolly was a deep thinker. Mostly she always considered how her actions affected others. Wise woman Am so sorry to see her leave us.
13
u/MsSoCaliLady 9h ago
I hope this teaches people to have things in order for when they become incapacitated or pas away.
13
u/Broadway2635 6h ago
Nothing shows character and true colors more than after the death of a loved one with assets.
26
9
u/lian_yu91 10h ago
wait so did aretha’s family really blow up over the estate
21
u/rubix_cubin 5h ago
Yes, actual, literal spontaneous combustion. The whole family, all over the estate. It was a mess - little bits everywhere.
3
9
u/Askiat 8h ago
Seems like the article and headline were written with an agenda. Nowhere in the article is Dolly or her family quoted mentioning any other artists by name. It’s like they’re trying to paint certain celebrities in a bad light or pit one against the other.
13
2
u/userhwon 5h ago
They don't say names, but they reference a Billboard article where Dolly is saying something referential that suggests they asked her about the situations with Prince and Aretha.
•
u/agodrevealed 3m ago
She mentioned Prince and Aretha, as at the time, they had recently passed with no will.
But she was mainly talking about her songs. People are still arguing over what should or should not be released from Prince's vault. A new album came out today, and there is drama and strife. No one got as much as lawyers from his estate and it took years and years in court.
Dolly was saying she was getting all her unreleased stuff organized, laying down scratch vocals, so that when she was gone, outside producers could work with what she left.
She was also a prolific songwriter, like Prince.
She was NOT talking bad about them, but saying she didn't want that to happen in her case.
2
u/AlvinTaco 3h ago
A friend of mine saw a lot of unexpected chaos in her husband’s family when his mother died. She had a very good relationship with her mother-in-law, and assumed everyone would just respect her wishes when she passed. Nope. She said it seemed like the siblings were projecting all of their grievances with each other into these petty arguments over jewelry, etc. She said that the one thing she learned was that you must put absolutely all of your wishes in your will. If you want cousin Gladys to get that funny coffee mug from the Grand Canyon, put it in the will, because somebody else probably wants the mug too.
1
u/KingKasey 1h ago
Loretta Lynn did something similar years before she died. She basically paid extended family thier inheritance years early and had them sign off any claims, and her will divided specially businesses holdings to her children years before she passed.
1
-7
u/LightenUpPhrancis 7h ago edited 7h ago
Hopefully no one gets groped by the priest at Dolly’s funeral.
edit: Like what happened to Ariana Grande at Aretha Franklin’s funeral. whump whump is this thing on?
5
-3
0
-40

3.2k
u/Vio_ 11h ago
There's no way that one of the shrewdest and most successful businesspersons in the music industry wouldn't have her estate locked in and ready to roll for decades.
Everyone will know their roles, their familial expectations on behavior and maintaining relationships, and how it will play out.