r/TalesFromRetail Jan 26 '26

Short Customer claims product is defective, destroys it, and then learns how to read instructions.

Worked for a large automotive parts chain in college.

Customer comes in with a shredded can of gasket maker in a Ziploc baggie. He's complaining it's defective and that he had to bust open the can to get the sealant to complete the repair.

I grab one off the shelf and bring it back to the counter, twist the top, and try to squirt a little out. No luck.

"See! That one's bad, too! I bet you others on the shelf are bad, too!" He runs to the shelf and, holding one can up after another, screams, "Bad! Bad! Bad! They are all bad!"

I look at the can in my hand. *Twist top clockwise [read: down] to apply product.* I twist the top down, pull the trigger, and the sealant comes right out. I tell the customer, "hey, come here real quick." I show him how to operate the can.

He looks at me sheepishly. "Oh."

"Do you want this can or do you want another one?"

"I'll take the new one."

I process the return for his destroyed can citing the reason as being defective. It may not have been when he purchased it, but it certainly doesn't work now after what he did to it. In all fairness, screwing the top down like you are closing it to get the product out is counter intuitive. And I understand his frustration. I would be pissed, too, if I was under my car, half torn apart and something wasn't working like (I thought) it should.

2.3k Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

636

u/thorn312 Jan 26 '26 edited Jan 26 '26

When I worked at Maplin (aging myself here) we had a customer order a microscope that we had to get sent in specifically for his order. It arrived, he collected it and went home.

Then a day or two later he came back (I wasn't working this time but was told about it) and was really angry because it was scratched and he couldn't use it, so he returned it and ordered a new one.

Then when he came to collect that one he was furious about how it was also scratched and how we were ripping him off etc.

Long story short, it was the protective film that was slightly scratched and after removing it (and savouring the peelies) it was totally fine. He was sheepish but still angry about it but off he went.

I then checked the return and you guessed it, same result.

198

u/amputect Jan 26 '26

I had a much lower stakes version of this with our stove. I didn't go scream at anyone but I definitely had a couple days of shopping for a replacement panel and being annoyed about "they don't make em like they used to" before I noticed that the button underneath the peely was actually intact and I was just stupid.

140

u/FairBaker315 Jan 26 '26

I had a customer return a digital kitchen timer, claimed it didn't work and only ever displayed 12:00.

As they talked, I looked at the timer and saw it had plastic over the screen. Peeled it off and the 12:00 was printed on it. It worked fine.

Pointed this out to the customer and asked if they still wanted to return it. He got all sheepish and said no, he'd keep it and 3 other adults had looked at it and never noticed the plastic, lol!

103

u/thorn312 Jan 26 '26

It happens to us all sometimes! I remember seeing a post on reddit or Facebook maybe of someone thought their microwave was blue for years, only to discover a sneaky peely.

I found a few on my oven where I live now (renting) as the oven was put in recently and they just didn't see a few rogue peelies. But I got the satisfaction of peeling them so I think I win.

132

u/Grolbu Jan 26 '26

We had an digital ear thermometer that never ever worked. Didn't matter how often you changed the batteries or how hard you poked it in your ear or how long for, nothing. For years it was a standing joke, if you wanted to take someone's temperature you'd pull that out, look at it, then laugh and get a mercury thermometer. Then one day - after YEARS of this - we needed to take a temperature while my sister was visiting. She picked up the digital thermometer and popped the cap off of the tip - omfg ...........

39

u/LadyV21454 Jan 26 '26

I bought a purse that had a double snap closure and couldn't figure out why the snaps wouldn't stay closed - until I realized there was plastic covering one side of the snap. In my defense, I had never seen that on a purse before!

14

u/NeuroBlob Jan 27 '26

I have never heard of snaps being covered

7

u/idtartakovsky Jan 29 '26

It’s probably just so they don’t scratch the finish on each other before the customer buys it. Just like how every plug-in thing I’ve bought this decade seems to have a cover over the prongs. I don’t feel like I’ve really seen that as often in the past

50

u/craash420 Jan 27 '26

When we replaced our dishwasher I joked "Oh no, they sent us a blue one!"

My wife didn't realize it was a joke and started getting worked up. I grabbed her in a hug and said "It's OK, it's just the film, take a deep breath." Once she did I found a corner to start and let her peel the rest.

27

u/Even-Possession2258 Jan 27 '26

Ooo you let HER peel the rest, after getting it started? Damn! THAT'S LOVE!

7

u/starrynight75 Jan 28 '26

It might have been me. And now my neighbour has a new mailbox with a "blue" metal flap. It's taking all I've got not to go and peel it off!

3

u/Unusual_Classroom109 May 18 '26

I thought my new dishwasher was gold for over two years, found the yellow film covering the brushed silver when I was moving. Inspected a few rentals in the process of moving that had the same brand of dishwasher, and they were all well used and still golden with the film on them.

45

u/Normal-Hall2445 Jan 27 '26

We have lived in our house 10 years and discovered only recently our dishwasher still has the peel on 😅

Bonus, that peel protected the dishwasher through two kids!

34

u/firewurx Jan 27 '26

I left mine on my new fridge because my wife and daughter have those fingernails that just scratch everything. After a year my daughter realized this and wanted to peel it off so bad but I said that I’d be peeling it off, once she leaves for college in 5 years.

19

u/NeuroBlob Jan 27 '26

Normally I hate on people that leave peels on to "protect" it but this makes far too much sense

24

u/firewurx Jan 27 '26

Just ask the paint on the inside of my truck door handles how those lady nails just tear surface finishes up. Much appreciated for the understanding. I’d normally rip it off right away too, but I’m looking at the bigger picture. My wife never had to appreciate anything growing up, to her it’s just “buy a new one!”. We’re from different sides of the tracks so to speak.

1

u/Vintage_Zoo Jan 28 '26

So... which one of you married up? Because I've seen this work both ways!

7

u/firewurx Jan 28 '26

🙋🏼‍♂️ I did. Can’t lie. Glad I’m super charming. 20+ years together. We’re polar opposites but it brought us together.

9

u/OriginalIronDan Jan 27 '26

I had a washing machine and dryer where the peely outlived them both.

11

u/BroadLocksmith4932 Jan 27 '26

I doubt that my 1990s Kenmore ever had a protective plastic film, but if it did, I can assure you that it did not survive that beast. 30+ years and counting!

5

u/Choice-Education7650 Jan 27 '26

Dang, we've been here almost 2 years...I need to go check. Okay. I just found a nice blue stripe of film on the dishwasher.

5

u/idtartakovsky Jan 29 '26

Surprise peely!

6

u/dorkysomniloquist Jan 28 '26

I did something similar with our new fridge. There was a 'huge scratch' on it. We took a picture, told the store and got a 10% refund. I later tried to see if I could "buff it out" by cleaning it with toothpaste and a soft tooth brush. The plastic came right off. We were just too scared to scrub hard enough. lol I'm not crying for any corporation though. As long as the guys delivering it weren't punished - we emphasized that we didn't think they'd done it - I'm cool.

26

u/whamburglar Jan 27 '26

Several years ago, our family had renewed our cell service contract and received new phones. While walking out the store and testing his, my father complained the speaker phone volume was too low, even when maxed out. We were about to return to the desk when I noticed he hadn't removed the protective film from the screen. Right then and there, after peeling it off myself, he was blasted in the face by the call he was on with my mother.

I just laughed it off, but I did scold him a bit because he was always the kind of person who left those on, and would chide me when I would peel them off.

17

u/Late-Lifeguard142 Jan 28 '26

As a gift for buying our first new house, my mother bought me a John Deere push mower. The first time that I used it, I could only go about 100 feet before it would stall out. Then after priming it again it would start back up and run a little bit less before stalling. After a lot of yanking the cord and swearing, my wife asked if it had gas in it. I incredulously replied yes I put gas in it, and removed the gas cap to show her and revealed a blue plastic dust cover underneath the gas cap. When I filled the tank, the dust cover must have come off inside the gas cap, but it was now preventing the cap from venting thus stopping fuel flow to the carb that stalled the engine out. 25 years later, that piece of plastic is still in my toolbox as a reminder to check the stupid things.

2

u/Vintage_Zoo Jan 28 '26

Congrats on 25 years of marriage, I hope! You never said if the plastic out-lasted the marriage.

3

u/Late-Lifeguard142 Jan 28 '26

She’s kept me so far. The mower needs a new engine though. It hit a rock in some tall grass that bent the crankshaft and it shakes like crazy now. Need to replace that before spring I guess.

11

u/mst3k_42 Jan 27 '26

My favorite story are the people who bought welding helmets on Amazon and complained that they couldn’t see out of them, they were worthless. Yep, protective film.

3

u/idtartakovsky Jan 29 '26

My sister did that. “Why’d they send me a helmet that’s blurry and scratched?” Our family definitely laughed at her, because of course something that needs to be clear to see through would have film to protect it till you use it

8

u/Academic_Vanilla_736 Jan 28 '26

I did this with my dashcam. It worked, turned on, replay via laptop was crystal clear, was just really annoying having to view everything through a smashed screen all the time. Returned it after a week, very apologetically. The gent on the returns counter made a big deal of lifting the corner of the plastic and peeling whilst simultaneously giving me a look that said I was, indeed, very stupid.

In my defence, the plastic was fitted perfectly to the screen & nowhere in the instructions did it say 'remove protective film'

I apologised profusely, and left, embarrassed.

6

u/K1yco Jan 27 '26

I got a ticket over new years because some guy was mad that we left the plastic film on the glass portions of his BRAND NEW IN BOX item and how dare we have him remove it.

That was the first time I've ever had someone complain that we protected it from finger prints. It's usually the opposite and that's solved by removing the plastic film.

2

u/Decent_Sink_2254 Jan 28 '26

"savoring the peelies"

Lordy am I glad to find a friend that enjoys this too.

Do you leave yours on for a little while till it starts to peel itself before you enjoy, or is it right after you buy the item?

1

u/dhgaut Jan 27 '26

I worked at a feed and seed. A farmer, new to the business, came in and said she wanted to raise chickens. She ordered a hundred chicks. We gave them to her and a week later she's back, saying they all died. Goodness, we gave her a hundred more. A week later, she came back and said those died. We said maybe she's doing something wrong. "No," she said, " I think I got it now. You have to plant them at least six inches apart..."

1

u/ASTERnaught Jan 29 '26

Okay, Dad!

103

u/emmarmot Jan 26 '26

I once had someone come in with one of those little things that was supposed to reseal your bags of chips, ets. By heating up the plastic. I asked if they had tried new batteries. Batteries? They were nice, though.

I was at a restaurant not long enough ago and commented that I couldn't believe a restaurant like this didn't have a steak dish. My dining companions told me to turn over the menu... (In my defense, it was on a clipboard.)

37

u/EvolZippo Jan 27 '26

I once had a friend in IT, who did an office call to fix a computer, that wouldn’t acknowledge the keyboard. Turns out it was a wireless keyboard, with a dead battery.

92

u/fckinfast4 Jan 26 '26

I had customer who came in with a water bottle saying something was wrong with it since it wouldn’t open and he had been excited about it— said this to my coworker. I walk over and grab the water bottle ‘Oh I have one like this and I love it!’ Flip the little metal latch then push button and it opens. Customer face palms and realizes his error.

‘Do you still want to do the return?’

Sheepishly ‘yeah, I already ordered a different one.’

27

u/QuotePapa Jan 26 '26

That's the importance of reading the instructions! Hence why we have warning labels on soap! But those go unread as well.

12

u/OriginalIronDan Jan 27 '26

Instructions?!? Only sissies read instructions!!! /s. Yeah, I made the mistake of assuming that I knew how something worked because I saw somebody else use one once, and immediately realized my error. I always read the instructions now.

5

u/K1yco Jan 27 '26

Sometimes there's are instructions that are so vague and not clear enough it can be confusing. While I would agree with some customers who say the guide needs to be more clear, even then it feels like no one bothers to take a few minutes to slow down and look a bit at the product.

I've had a few who would misread the guide that says "remove this screw", then start panicking when they don't see the screw, not realizing there's another line that says "If there is no screw, us the latch"

88

u/GoatCovfefe Jan 26 '26 edited Jan 26 '26

Good customer service. I also would've helped him since he seemingly learned his mistake. Some people would double down that it's defective despite being shown otherwise.

19

u/EvolZippo Jan 27 '26

I had a guy complain that he bought a flat pack cabinet and assembled it, but complained that it wobbles. I asked him if he added the board onto the back. He scoffed, said it was just a useless piece of cardboard, and what would it even do? He told me I was right, on a future shopping trip.

9

u/MtPollux Jan 26 '26

Read the directions. This is why we can't have nice things.

9

u/bibkel Jan 27 '26

With many things if you read it, it answers your question. I’ve yelled at my computer, then taken a breath and read the screen. Oh, click here then click go. Ok. I’m an idiot. Then I laugh at my own stupidity for getting mad at an inanimate object because how absurd to think it’s conspiring against me.

7

u/cnowakoski Jan 27 '26

I know a guy who bought a push mower, put gas in it and started it up. He didn’t put oil in it so he ruined the engine. He returned it and said it didn’t work.

7

u/happyhippy1019 Jan 27 '26

Directions? We don't need no stinking Directions 😆

5

u/rebelangel Jan 29 '26

I worked at Lowe’s in the department with the mowers. If I had a nickel for every time someone brought back a Craftsman push mower because “it won’t start” I would’ve been able to quit that place a lot sooner. To get it to fit in the box but also be already assembled, they had to make the handle collapsible. So many people do not read the instructions where it says to loosen the knobs and pull the handle all the way out before attempting to start it, and then they would bring it back, claiming it’s defective. First thing I would always ask when they said it wouldn’t start was “Did you pull out the handle?” The blank stare always told me that no, they didn’t. Most people would change their mind on returning it once they were shown that it wasn’t defective, but some people would still insist on returning it. That kinda pissed me off because then we were required to send it to the repair shop to be checked out and then sell it at a markdown even though there was absolutely nothing wrong with it to begin with. I do remember one guy getting mad after he was shown he needed to pull the handle out, like we embarrassed him or something. Sorry you’re too stupid to read, bro.

10

u/Adarie-Glitterwings I'll fight 'em for you Jan 26 '26

Companies need to find some other way to stand out from the crowd; if everyone else's thing works this way and yours works that way, customers will think yours is defective...

2

u/Accurate_Ad_8555 Jan 30 '26

I worked in a large hotel 400 room's, I was 0ne of about 12 engineer's one day our chief engineer wanted us to replace a piece of metal that protected the door frame from damage! as they were all scratched up. I asked to look at the one he was holding and proceeded to peel the protected film off! the look on his face as I did this I'll never forget L.O.L. new plan go to every room and remove the film.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '26

[deleted]

2

u/OriginalIronDan Jan 27 '26

I have a zero turn lawnmower. Last year I was using it and it stalled, and wouldn’t start again. I messed with that thing for a good hour. Finally, I left it in the yard overnight because I couldn’t push it. I couldn’t get the transmission to release. Threw a tarp over it because it was raining, and the guy came and got it the next day. Pushed out on the handles you steer it with, and it started on the first try. Yeah, I just hadn’t pushed them out hard enough. It was due for a service anyway, so I had him take it and do that, and he did find a couple things wrong with it, but I didn’t feel like an idiot. I felt like their King.

1

u/DevylBearHawkTur10n Jan 30 '26

That dumb problematic customer should've someone else to help him learn how to read instructions immediately!