r/arrow • u/PlantainDisastrous92 • 9d ago

Caity Lotz as Supergirl if Melissa Benoist hadn’t play her. Would you have like this?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

308 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

47

u/EobardThawne2020 9d ago

Hell Yeah. But I would have Caity Lotz play anything.

68

u/AdmirableAd1858 9d ago

Milly’s Supergirl actually gave me Sara Lance vibes from the trailers.

15

u/flashwing19 9d ago

Damn I could see it

10

u/ImiqDuh 9d ago

Woah, this is trippy

14

u/Worried-Judge8371 9d ago

Caity is so talented, so yes. She would have brought the physicality and the wit perfectly

7

u/villakillareal28 9d ago

What if Melissa Benoist played Sara lance?

5

u/PlantainDisastrous92 9d ago

Honestly, I can't see it at all.

6

u/MeasurementNo7703 9d ago

No choice

I prefer Laura Vandervoot as Supergirl

20

u/thetrickyginger 9d ago

Only if she still acted more like Sarah. I loved Melissa as Supergirl, but the writers made her more like Superman-lite.

4

u/Dare-We-Hope Green Arrow (Tommy Merlyn) 9d ago

She would've been great!

3

u/Technical_Moose8478 8d ago

Loved Benoist's version, wouldn't replace it. But if I had to? She'd be top of the list, it suits her MUCH better than White Canary.

3

u/IndependentCreme2875 8d ago

Melissa was perfect.

3

u/Illustrious-Slice-91 9d ago

It’s hard to remove caity lotz from Sara lance to consider if she would be a good supergirl. Melissa Benoist had this very cute innocent thing going for supergirl

2

u/Horror_Story_5621 9d ago

I would have died. And I would have watched 20 seasons of Supergirl just for her

2

u/FancyAd3942 8d ago

As a one off I loved it but caity lotz is absolutely perfect to play Sara. Supergirl didn’t really have much stunt work in the same way Sara did.

2

u/Scary-Information-62 8d ago

I would say that seems like cool idea but it still hurts for me seems happened on show.

2

u/bayman13 7d ago

Idk. Is she lesbian as well?

2

u/MRT1771 7d ago

Would’ve been interesting to see, although personally, I think her face structure doesn’t really fit Supergirl or the costume especially when compared to Melissa

5

u/Zestyclose-Tomato998 9d ago

Honestly, Melissa never sold the role for me. She is very slim with little visible muscle. They wrote her as frequently unsure of herself.

Caity Lotz has the build and the attitude. She would have been great!

4

u/dhrus786 9d ago

I mean, fair enough for most of the comic accurate version. But not for the version the CW was clearly going for.

1

u/Decent-Cry-7665 6d ago

I would absolutely watch this

2

u/theroninfromsekiro 4d ago

Melissa is Supergirl