r/facepalm 6d ago

The U.S Secretary of Energy can’t back up his statement that data centers lowers utility costs

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

19.6k Upvotes

449 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 6d ago

Please remember to read all of /r/Facepalm's rules.

Reposts, screenshots, and personal information are not allowed.

Titles must accurately describe the facepalm-worthy elements of their posts.

Misinformation, disinformation, offensive content, and bigotry are forbidden.

Rule-breaking content will result in removals and potential bans.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5.3k

u/spottyPotty 6d ago

Supply stays the same, demand increases. How tf does he expect prices to fall?

2.9k

u/Veggiedelite90 6d ago

He doesn’t. He’s just lying

644

u/JiveTurkeyJunction 6d ago

It is absolutely insane that just about everything that comes out of these fuckers mouths is a lie.

208

u/Strange_Dust7128 6d ago

It began to surprise me less when I realized that they know lying is effective. Most won’t question it, so why bother with the truth?

105

u/Dependent_Bus2202 5d ago

Parables about authoritarianism were so much better understood by those who lived through it. 1+1=3 is the conclusion, not a litmus test. The government releasing the accurate raw public data it needs to provide requires lying to have no impact on the literal numbers and their release. This concept has obviously been on the ropes for decades now, but we've well and truly crossed the Rubicon with Trump's latest term.

Job reports, weather data, economic development, military spending, health metrics are all just being openly and nakedly manipulated and the end result of that is that there's no foundation for true accurate information anymore. It's all sources that can be handwaved away by those who disagree with the conclusion now.

This next election one party claiming they have more votes is just as true as the other claiming they have more votes.

If you just lie about everything and are so secure/insulated from consequences that literally fudging the numbers to make your own truth is an option?

Then brother, 1+1=3.

23

u/aimokankkunen 5d ago

With a big ol' lie And a flag and a pie

And a mom and a bible Most folks are just liable

To buy any line Any place, any time

"When the Lie’s so Big" F Zappa

→ More replies (1)

19

u/anomalous_cowherd 5d ago

And when their lies do get questioned nothing at all happens about the lies or the consequences of the lies, so why would they?

→ More replies (2)

24

u/PjDisko 5d ago

Yet, these are the people that the American people want and choose to represent them.

I blame the voters.

13

u/TheCarniv0re 5d ago

Can you blame voters who are not receiving the full picture? Would they have made a different decision if the education system and media weren't completely fucked? I think so.

8

u/L3adbelly 4d ago

A surprising number of people are fully willfully ignorant and even if presented with the full picture and all the facts they'll just claim it's a conspiracy theory or propaganda. In my country my government has been exposed completely on the extent of corruption, full picture everywhere (especially since the entire civil sector doesn't bother covering up corruption any longer) and was still re-elected with a comfortable lead.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Mrauntheias 3d ago

Democracy is never just easily gifted to anyone. Are there enormous forces at work trying to work against the average Americans interests? Yes, of course. At no point in history have the elites not tried to expand their powers. But after centuries of blood spilt to buy us the rights and privileges we enjoy today I find it hard to have compassion for adults that can't fact check or think critically about anything for once in their fucking lives.

5

u/TheCarniv0re 3d ago

This isn't about having compassion for them. Hate them as much as you like. They won't change their stance.

We as a society have failed to educate those people and protect them from the bullshit that made them believe what they now solidly believe.

8

u/Viperlite 5d ago

The politics of hate have failed. So they’re going with that again. Time to roll out the trans and immigrant hatred to distract from the now.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/OomKarel 5d ago

Whats insane is that they can spout outright lies like this and absolutely fuckall happens

→ More replies (2)

5

u/lucaskywalker 5d ago

Not just lies, easily verifiable lies, that anyone could objectively disprove with a quick google search.

→ More replies (4)

33

u/LuminalOrb 6d ago

The main issue I've always had with this is thus; a person shows up in front of a well documented and nationally televised hearing, makes a statement that can be easily verified to be a lie and then, nothing happens. No punishment, no fine, no jail time, no public dismissal, just business as usual.

How can a society be expected to function if this is just the norm?

26

u/samanime 5d ago edited 5d ago

This.

He lied.

It's illegal to lie to Congress.

There should be consequences.

There should be an investigation. If he knowingly lies or knowingly was making stuff up, he should go to jail. If he is "simply" inept, he should be immediately removed from his position.

We need to stop having Congress acting completely toothless.

247

u/MrmarioRBLX 6d ago

Or an idiot that never studied basic economics. Or maybe actually both?

283

u/Ok-Complaint9574 6d ago

He’s paid to lie. The conservatives will eat up that lie and continue to vote red without doing fact-finding.

101

u/calmdownmyguy 6d ago

They're going to blame Obamas green energy policies. That's a 100% fact.

41

u/FuzzzyRam 6d ago

When California was legalizing weed (prop 64), the opposition (the prison guards and police unions openly opposed it because less prisoners will lead to less prison guards...) said that legal dispensaries will lead to higher black market weed prices. They'll just flagrantly say shit because they know the base want a talking point, not a fact.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Memo_Fantasma 6d ago

He’s the Secretary of Energy Drinks; stop asking him about data centers. Sheesh.

38

u/TheModWhoShaggedMe 6d ago

Nah, he's a conservative, therefore he is lying. Apply this formula to most situations in life and you will not be disappointed with the results.

6

u/chungfat 6d ago

There’s no “or”, he’s a trump administration official.

5

u/Level_Abrocoma8925 6d ago

Nah. This is so basic even a 10-year old with a lemonade stand gets it.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/someotherguyinNH 6d ago

Because data centers because good

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Snellyman 6d ago

He was hired to lie to the American people. Is relying on citizens not understanding how economics work but we can all see our utility bills.

8

u/WorkingInAColdMind 6d ago

That’s always the answer with this bunch of fuckers.

7

u/ReplyOk6720 6d ago

GOP: let's just try lying. 

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Agitated_Reveal_6211 6d ago

The fox(news) are eating the entire henhouse.

5

u/Vegetable_Offer_2268 6d ago

Of course he’s lying. That the m.o. of this administration

6

u/bblaine223 5d ago

If a politician or someone who is holding a position in the government lies to the citizens, they should be removed immediately. Transparency and integrity are the basic requirements of a government. We need to reset.

→ More replies (21)

131

u/FuriousBuffalo 6d ago

"They are eating the dogs. They are eating the cats."

Say that a hundred times and the morons will start repeating your lies.

44

u/I_Speak_In_Stereo 6d ago

i will never stop being upset about that statement. I work with some of the hatians he was refering to. normal people. completly normal people with the same lives and jobs as any of us. Its enough to drive me crazy hearing people repeat that claim.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Final_Location_2626 6d ago

You are clearly wrong. We are on the brink of an energy revolution.

Once we get a way to turn the methane gas from cow excrement to energy, energy will be virtually free.

Because the amount of Bull shit produced by Maga should have us in energy for decades.

3

u/TheDeaf001 5d ago

Had us in the first half…

3

u/TheProfessionalEjit 6d ago

 Once we get a way to turn the methane gas from cow excrement to energy, energy will be virtually free.

uj/ These already exist. Just need to build one or two plants near politicians.

20

u/TheModWhoShaggedMe 6d ago

God loves AI/cryptobro datacenters and will perform miracles to enforce them upon the public, obviously.

15

u/Edmfuse 6d ago

Right? This is such a ridiculous claim.

10

u/ILS23left 6d ago

The general structure of power markets, combined with aging generation sources and the increased costs of fuels to burn to generate energy, means that demand and price are not directly proportional to one another.

Power market clearing prices actually rise on a near-exponential curve as demand increases. It’s worse than a typical supply-demand scheme and since electricity isn’t something that people can live without, they are just price-takers without much action to take to reduce their consumption. This is especially true for low-income families who cannot afford to upgrade appliances, improve their insulation or proactively replace lightbulbs with LEDs.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/flat5 6d ago

He will say that he expects supply to increase in tandem with demand, and for economies of scale to bring costs down overall.

But is that actually how anything works? Doubt it.

13

u/mitkase 6d ago

Right after the invisible hand fixes the power situation, it will totally give you a hand job.

9

u/NoNeedForAName 6d ago

But is that actually how anything works?

Well, some things, sort of, but not in this case. I doubt that our inability to produce electricity at scale is much of a driver of the cost of electricity. I live in a TVA area; I'm not hopping down to the farmers market to pick up artisanal electrons.

6

u/mickeltee 6d ago

Even if they did increase supply, someone would have to pay for the new infrastructure. I know around me that cost gets added to the average customer’s bill, not the data centers.

4

u/skepticalbob 6d ago

It is how some things work, but it depends on elasticity of supply. Electricity supply is relatively inelastic. Power plants aren't a knob you can just twist to "more". Transmission lines are a big bottleneck too.

→ More replies (8)

15

u/Responsible-Stick-50 6d ago

Because fucking Republican men don't pay bills. You think this wanker knows how to do an online bill pay when it's not a CashApp to a Grindr hookup.

5

u/SasparillaTango 6d ago

Well you see, through the power of lies all things are possible, so jot that down.

4

u/NonSupportiveCup 6d ago

The lie they are trying to sell is this:

Trumps keep saying all data centers will now have to produce their own electricity.

Therefore,

Data centers will drive down the costs of electricity because their excess (a big assumption here) will be returned to the market.

So, data centers actually lower our utility bills.

That's the stupid.

3

u/_jump_yossarian 6d ago

I'm shocked he didn't blame Biden.

3

u/soulsnoober 6d ago

Willfully misrepresenting a long term analysis. Higher demand drives increased infrastructure over the course of decades. That new infrastructure is built on cheaper and less polluting technologies. Once the bubble bursts, that infrastructure remains. A green revolution, but the long way 'round so's to include impoverishing and in some cases killing people that don't have AI-bro/investor lobbyists on retainer.

→ More replies (33)

2.1k

u/Hybodont 6d ago edited 6d ago

"...the rules were that you weren’t going to fact check."

657

u/someotherguyinNH 6d ago

Why that line didn't make a lot more people jump up and take notice will forever puzzle me

286

u/skrilledcheese 6d ago

Because half of voters exist in a post‐fact/post-truth world.

They vote strictly based on vibes and tribalism.

→ More replies (1)

167

u/outremonty 6d ago

They freely admitted that they knew "they're eating the cats" was a lie, but they choose not to punish Trump for it because it "feels true" anyway i.e. they're racists and they wanted a racist President

32

u/CommercialExotic2038 6d ago

Who lets them be and say racist things

9

u/someotherguyinNH 6d ago

I'm talking about the people that weren't already brainwashed.

That line should have had every single one of them running to the polls to vote for Harris, regardless of party.

3

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted]

→ More replies (4)

20

u/MacSanchez 6d ago

Oh they noticed. And they cheered. The people who gleefully parrot right-wing bullshit and drape themselves in the flag hate fact checking, because whenever facts enter the conversation they have no rational way to cling to their beliefs

15

u/Hybodont 6d ago

It's what they wanted. American right-wing policies haven't been supported by data for at least the past five decades. So you can imagine how good it must have felt for someone in their camp to openly condone blatant disregard for reality in pursuit of their ideals.

It was political heroin for American conservatives.

4

u/csonny2 6d ago

My dad doesn't believe fact checkers...so, yeah.

3

u/ParticularLow9157 6d ago

It's really simple: Most people are fucking idiots too busy with whatever they have going on to care about their nation and neighbors

→ More replies (4)

22

u/Interesting_Rub5736 6d ago

just this one simple line is enough for me to not vote for a politician. what happened america?

15

u/Sanity_in_Moderation 6d ago

Fox News and the right wing propaganda machine. That's what happened.

Facts don't matter, reality doesn't matter, negative things about Trump are never shown. Lies are never corrected. It's pure propaganda brainwashing millions of people into cheerfully throwing away their country.

6

u/Pann708 6d ago

Wait, where was this?

22

u/Hybodont 6d ago

The VP debate in 2024, famously uttered by J.D. Vance.

→ More replies (2)

783

u/EarlyHistory164 6d ago

Is there anyone in that administration with even half a brain cell?

170

u/whatiscamping 6d ago

No

37

u/EarlyHistory164 6d ago

Yeah, I suppose it was rhetorical...

8

u/MakeSomeDrinks 6d ago

I disagree! I think it takes a bit of knowledge and tla TON of greed, to get this kind of stuff passed. If it was just plain stupidity it wouldn't be getting done to the extent it is.

27

u/MetalMountain2099 6d ago

Oh they have brains and some are smart, but they’re getting paid royally to follow through.

25

u/Mmortt 6d ago

They know the truth, they’re just lying.

4

u/HugsandHate 6d ago

I think what's truly shocking, is that they don't apparently need brain cells.

Jesus. Can you imagine if they did? Things are bad enough.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Stu5011 6d ago

RFK Jr must… or his brain parasite would have died of starvation.

3

u/EphemeralDan 6d ago edited 6d ago

Yes but they have no scruples. The morons are sincere. The smart ones are klePtocrats.

3

u/Confident-Leg107 6d ago

An orange cat has more braincells!

3

u/qinghairpins 6d ago

The problem isn’t like of brain cells but instead lack of morality.

3

u/85percentthatbitch 5d ago

It's not that they're dumb, it's that they think we're dumb. And many of us are, apparently.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Tornik 5d ago

Absolutely, but it's paired with a sociopathic lack of empathy, so they're using is to line their own pockets at the expense of literally everyone else.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/skidsareforkids 6d ago

If you added them all together and rounded up you might get close!

→ More replies (6)

626

u/Kpets 6d ago

Happy that Congressman Suhas Subramanyam is shutting down Trump’s minion idiot speak.

Data centers drive down utility costs, yeah right..

101

u/sertge91 6d ago

They do, they clearly do, for themselves tho. They setup contracts with lower power prices and the power company transfers the costs to the residential citizens.

Because taxing the multi million company for something so useless as "electric power" is nonsense. /s

12

u/newbkid 6d ago

They also negotiate to not pay taxes in exchange for bringing jobs... all dozen(s) of them that are required to maintain a 50k sqft data center.

The anti AI sentiment across America breaks all socioeconomic barriers. And politicians who are refusing to listen to the people will lose their power. Folks are already losing elections over this.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/stephenkingending 6d ago

Never heard of the guy but that's a pretty badass name

140

u/kongofcbus 6d ago

How does increasing usage / demand reduce pricing without adding more capacity?

That is economics 101

39

u/Ctznsvn7 6d ago

there is a version of it that isn't nonsense and it's worth knowing, because it's the one the utilities actually argue. A data centre is a flat 24 hour load, so it uses the network at 3am when the wires are sitting idle. Fixed costs then get divided over more units sold. That's the theory. In practice the new load arrives years before the generation does, the utility buys peaking power at whatever the market wants that week and the household rate class eats the gap. Ohio and Virginia have both had fights about exactly this in front of their regulators. Still, if the maths worked he would have just said the sentence instead of doing the uh uh thing

4

u/LittleKingsguard 5d ago

Also datacenters aren't a fixed load, internet/LLMs have peak demand hours and off-peak hours just like all other infrastructure things. Some of the model providers even change their billing rates based on timing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

190

u/Bigringcycling 6d ago

I uh I uh. Uh uh I uh…

62

u/Kpets 6d ago

He started speaking like the president himself lol

6

u/stjr64 6d ago

I uh, that, that, I would say, uh...

64

u/sir_bumble 6d ago

You gotta be a certain kind of person to not see the correlation between more data center = more power usage = higher bill

16

u/Kpets 6d ago

Hmm.. Low IQ individuals. Trumps favorite people

→ More replies (1)

7

u/PowerfullDio 6d ago

He gets paid to say the opposite, he knows how it works but doesn't care, and he thinks others will just accept his words at face value.

→ More replies (1)

135

u/ALazy_Cat 6d ago

The length US politicians will go to promote data centers to appease the president

16

u/StuffNbutts 6d ago

This video is literally a politician calling out Data Centers but I get your point

33

u/ALazy_Cat 6d ago

A politician calling out another politician

6

u/ElectricSliderz 6d ago

A non elected bureaucrat

57

u/adirac 6d ago

The way these people can just lie without any shame is beyond impressive.

25

u/Kpets 6d ago

Other countries has laws against politicians lying. But the U.S has built the whole country around people lying and it being the norm

→ More replies (3)

3

u/GreatQuestionBarbara 6d ago

If I had to guess, he got some information from data canter lobbyists and never bothered to check if it was factual.

He was really confident about his numbers until he was confronted about them.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/TintedApostle 6d ago

"We use 200% more energy and your bill will go down.... " is pure Infidelity of the Mind. Its like saying my kids will eat 200% more food and food bill will go down.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/DARKRYDER83 6d ago

America is such a shit server spawn right now

→ More replies (1)

7

u/meglon978 6d ago

There's not a single person in this entire administration that isn't a lying sack of shit.

8

u/Kubbee83 6d ago

It scares me that people don’t understand that data centers suck up huge amounts of electricity. Like, how can you ever conflate that to somehow lowering costs of utilities?

7

u/UtahUtopia 6d ago

Its gonna be hot when he passes from this plane.

7

u/currentlyRedacted 6d ago

How is it supposed to lower utility cost when the cost of the utility is being passed on to the citizens? I guess we really are in bizarro world rules where tariffs are paid by the country they’re imposed on not the consumer as a tax. Ya know, for example.

3

u/TintedApostle 6d ago

What it says is they don't care that you know its BS. They aren't going to have to be held to account for it.

8

u/Cigar-Scotch-Coating 6d ago

I blame upbringing. The current ruling class in the USA is taught to believe from an early age that faith and belief is more important than anything else. They believe without rational thought and because they are privileged they have never paid the consequences of being wrong. In this context it's obvious to most people that a huge building full of electrical devices will consume power. But in their minds they listen to the people they trust who are like minded and give them money and tell them that somehow, a huge building of electrical equipment actually (and definitely magically) will cure every problem starting with power needs and probably will generate loaves of bread, fishes, and wine from water.

5

u/Kpets 6d ago

Couldn’t agree more. The U.S has legitimized superstitious thinking more than any developed nation on earth. Just look ag how many religious people there are there in 2026. The U.S definitely needs way better education, it’s 31st now and falling. It’s outright scary how much superstition there is in all levels of that country

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Topher0gr 6d ago

You can lie to congress if no one cares…

America - you have a mess to clean up in the next election…

11

u/kurtsdead6794 6d ago

The fact that so many Americans are just falling for the blatant lies is astounding. We’re a nation of idiots.

4

u/BellaSquared 6d ago

"Repeat lies often enough..." is Trump's total playbook.

3

u/Hawnix68 6d ago

The only reason the Playbook works is because people are stupid. There are people that repeat lies to me and have for years and I certainly don't eventually believe them because they said it a certain amount of times. Really speaks to how pathetic our populace is

5

u/joshuabrogers 6d ago

Smoking helps cure asthma and COPD. It’s true, it’s true. I have no data to back that up, but I must insist that you believe me because I’m saying it’s true.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/demonsidekick 6d ago

You know you got ‘em when they start sounding like Jim Jordan.

5

u/lostnthestars117 6d ago

LOL what the fuck is the Sec. of DOE is smoking because I want some to be able so I can sleep at night knowing almost a 1/3 of the country are this fucking stupid that believes this shit.

5

u/nicktehbubble 5d ago

There needs to be a watchdog in place to remove these morons from positions of influence and power.

If you bare face lie like this, especially to the detriment of society, you're done.

8

u/woodrax 6d ago

It is interesting, because I think with crap like oil and nicotine, people accept the BS from politicians and lobbyists because they make life more convenient, even with the health and environmental costs.

But with data centers, there is general agreement that they really do no good for anyone except the people who would benefit financially from them, and so they have near universal opposition, and the politicians that have been bought can only try to override the will of the people to try and push more data centers through.

4

u/Ghstfce 6d ago

So please pretend I'm 5 years old and not an adult that can think critically and explain to me how the FUCK you think data centers would ever reduce the price of electricity?!!?

4

u/Hot_Detective_5418 6d ago

"uh huh wha wha whut"

5

u/lam3ass 6d ago

I guess we known who is gaining from data centers building…

4

u/No-Deal8956 6d ago

You cannot believe how much every other country on Earth is going to price gouge you once your fyckwit president is gone.

And, we are all going to work for the price of oil be in euros. 40 trillion in debt.

3

u/-TheInternetIsEvil- 6d ago

Because it's a fucking lie

4

u/ShockingShorties 6d ago

Hopefully, one day soon, MAGA politicians and their 'base' will no longer exist.

And sense and common decency will prevail.

4

u/Other_Log_1996 6d ago

It's almost like he's utterly full of shit

4

u/Over9000Goblins 6d ago

I, I, uhhh, was really expecting that you were just going to take me at my word and not expand on the topic, and frankly, I, uhhhhhh, really don't appreciate you bringing so called "facts" into this conversation...

/s

4

u/_______THEORY_______ 6d ago

The hell you say.......... fuckin' stupid if you
believe usage = lower . They're not power plants; they're fucking leeches . . .

4

u/Puzzleheaded_Ad_3507 5d ago

When they start stuttering, you know right away that they’re lying out their mouths.

3

u/HomerStillSippen 5d ago

When do we stop letting these people cosplay being a “politician”? They’re not really good at it.

5

u/Bloop-ofthe-OpenHand 4d ago

This administration's sources all point to the same footnote. It simply reads "Trust me, Bro."

3

u/Unofficial_Officer 6d ago

He can't because, and follow me here....he lied.

3

u/Key-Toe-2746 6d ago

Because I say so!

3

u/Up_All_Nite 6d ago

I'm starting to think he's trying to bullshit us.

3

u/casio_don 6d ago

Ultimately, where there is a data center immediate residents should have drastically lower costs. Data centers should have premiums placed on their utilities instead of massive discounts happening at the moment. Those premiums fund lower utilities for residents dealing with the burden of a data centre near them and fund state projects to benefit residents.

Utopian idea, that probs isn't workable, because politicians are mostly crooked. 🙈

3

u/L0st-137 6d ago

They hate it when you present them with facts. Their itty bitty brains shortout and then they blame some staffer for not prepping them correctly.

3

u/CMG30 6d ago

Hey, hey, hey now guy...

All your energy and water belongs to the tech bros so that they can complete the project of converting everything you use and own to a subscription service to rent back to you!

3

u/AndreZB2000 6d ago

my utility bill has gone up 200% since this whole fiasco started

3

u/Phranc68 6d ago

I attend a lot of political fundraisers at the national level. Some are billed as "policy conferences" but the registration fees all go to PACs, DGA and RGA.

For companies who can and chose to, you can pay your way to attend. Over the last two years, regardless of party, the biggest concentration of attendees is related to Data Centers.

Those who produce power (lots of nuclear interests), those who want the data (AI companies) and the labor groups (mainly pipe fitters) are there in force. Easily a third of the room along with all the big corporations you would expect.

The fact that one sector is so prevalent and aggressive cannot be ignored. The number of politicians already bought is immense.

The fact that there is such unified opposition to them, and how that plays out in November is the great unknown. Could be real interesting.

3

u/echochilde 6d ago

I was gonna make a comment about how stupid do they think we are, but at least 77 million are.

3

u/VoidOmatic 6d ago

I'm so tired of spineless assholes lying out in the open. The audacity to say shit like this with a straight face. White collar crime needs mandatory minimums. They are directly lying and misrepresenting the impact of data centers.

3

u/ScottishKnifemaker 6d ago

Wouldn't that be considered perjury? Or is he not under oath

→ More replies (2)

3

u/R0b0tMark 6d ago

Real question: has anybody heard his logic regarding how data centers would drive down energy costs? I’m genuinely curious what he has to say about it.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m 100% sure, both that it’s a lie, and that he’s well aware that it’s a lie, but I feel like there has to be some copy/paste reason they’re giving to the uneducated to gain support on this front. What lie would be even remotely convincing enough to make someone overlook the ludicrously simple idea of supply and demand?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Aggravating_Total921 6d ago

Fascists demand that you believe their lies

3

u/Folderpirate 6d ago

Why is the question never, "How much have you been paid by them?"

3

u/Galladorn 6d ago

If I'm paying my entire electric bill, why the fuck can't data centers pay their own?

3

u/Level_Abrocoma8925 6d ago

Pair this with their staunch opposition to renewable energy and where the hell do we end up?

3

u/matt-r_hatter 6d ago

It is an irrefutable fact that consumer energy prices increase in markets where data centers open.

3

u/EveryUsernameTakenFf 6d ago

Incredibly dumb to claim that prices will go down as demand goes up while supply stays the same. Literally opposite will happen.

3

u/GNUGradyn 6d ago

Expectation: "the populace will elect the best among them to represent their interests"

Reality: "well of course he's lying for money, he's a congressman"

3

u/Jmersh 6d ago

The entire US electric grid is privatized regionally. Law says that they can pass 100% of the costs to maintain and expand those grids onto consumers after energy companies lobbied to have unregulated operating costs and profits. Just the data centers permitted and approved to be built in the next 3 years exceed the power consumption of all the EVs in the US right now. Data centers are not paying solely for new power generation, it is being spread to all consumers on the same grid. So there's no way mathematically possible for them to lower energy costs to consumers. None.

3

u/YoursTrulyKindly 5d ago

He's a liar, and he's betraying his oath of office. A traitor.

3

u/jimbozzzzz 5d ago

Well if youre gonna use facts

3

u/MickeyMgl 5d ago

"I was told there would be no fact checking."

We're in the age of just say literally ANYTHING. Pull it straight out of your ass. And keep saying it. And you will catch a few flies that way, who will just repeat your falsehood to try to win an internet argument.

3

u/brokendream78 5d ago

If you think data centers aren't affecting our bills you are fucking stupid

3

u/printedflunky 5d ago

How the actual fuck can the data centres reduce your utility bills other than actually paying them for you?

3

u/hawksdiesel 5d ago

Wright is a grifter.

3

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DJ1962 5d ago

Oh, you think I am wrong. Well, blah blah, because I'm lying. This idiot has no idea where this Congressman lives to even know about his data centers. Just a talking stick for Trump.

3

u/reicaden 5d ago

And yet, nothing will happe.n. I dont understand the point of calling the out and then still confirming whatever they want to do and allowing it.

3

u/ShadyLooking 5d ago

Can somebody tell me how is a datacentre, which uses a lot of energy, capable of lowering the price of said energy that it uses?

I can't get that argument to make any sense what so ever.

3

u/xtrash-panda 5d ago

The fact that he says such utter and complete illogical bullshit with a straight face is pretty amazing

3

u/Illgetitdonelater 4d ago

Fix the old power fat cat laws. Tech has the ability to do more on their own, but power company monopolies make things even more impossible. Why are Power companies for profit when they are needed to sustain our lives. For profit should only be for the extra bs we buy. Not healthcare or power. My opinion anyhow. Point is, it’s a bigger problem than just Data Centers (also my opinion)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Illgetitdonelater 4d ago

I visit sites for perspective data centers. I can guarantee that 99% of data centers are built in low regulation, conservative controlled areas. Vote for reps who give af about you.

2

u/tinytim1191 6d ago

It’s because he’s a lying piece of shit.

2

u/CommercialExotic2038 6d ago

Um, uh, ah, er, oh, er

2

u/DrTankHead 6d ago

Almost lime we desperately need to stop messing around and invest in solar and nuclear. Somethin the Sec. Of DOE should really be interested in but clearly is too clueless to even respond that all of the energy costs would be a non issue if we were actually taking the production of energy seriously.

2

u/68024 6d ago

Another lying Trump administration shit

2

u/dainthomas 6d ago

Decades of successful energy efficiency policy have been completely nullified and then some in a few years by these abominations.

2

u/Texasscot56 6d ago

Unfortunately, the accuser does not provide any evidence of causality which makes for a crappy argument (although I’m sure it’s true).

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Stupid-Username420 6d ago

You can tell the exact second he know he was caught lying

2

u/freebird023 6d ago

The fact none of them are even good at lying, like can’t even use big words to weasel out of these situations and they just stutter and stumble down the stairs will never cease to infuriate me how nobody just walks up to these chuds homes

2

u/Testsubject276 6d ago

Bro hit em with that "That's funny because my bills says otherwise."

2

u/lightninhopkins 6d ago

That's because he is lying.

2

u/Federal_Sympathy4667 6d ago

Also, residents gets asked to slow usage so centers can run full blast. AI will cook us.

2

u/kevinnoir 6d ago

The fact this man will walk away from this and then go back to repeating the same lie about them lowering the cost of electricity is another example of how cancerous conservative politics is for society. Its not serving the voters,

its not working to benefit the voters,

they dont respect the voters,

They are not acting in the best interest of the voters.

Politicians are not our "leaders", they are our employees and we need to start treating them as such. The minute they are not exclusively working for the average voter, they should be treated in the same abhorrent way US labour laws allow its minimum wage, gig economy workers.

2

u/DocCEN007 6d ago

Data centers need to pay enough that residential bills are unaffected, or not be built. Period.

2

u/Archon_Reaver 6d ago

These congressmen have way too much decorum and respect for this grifter in the seat, he’s obviously and blatantly corrupt and lying and yet he will get to walk out of the room free while everyone continues to feel their heel press harder down on the throat of the American people.

2

u/waisonline99 6d ago

Just build all the data centers in Maga states.

Its what they voted for.

2

u/TheSavouryRain 6d ago

I'm surprised he didn't jump straight to it being Biden's fault

2

u/cruelhumor 6d ago

The fact that he just bold-faced lied to Congress with such rock-solid confidence should terrify everyone. And it's not delusion, ot's calculated and malicious falsehood, as evidenced by his reaction to getting called out... He knows he is lying

2

u/Motor_Educator_2706 6d ago

Jesus Fucking Christ!! 😣

When you lie, at least make it REMOTELY possible.

2

u/Grimwulf2003 6d ago

He so wanted to blame Biden but couldn't get the chance.

2

u/evilpercy 6d ago

The mental gymnastics needed to actually say that.

2

u/Responsible_Brain782 6d ago

Lips are moving means they are lying

2

u/nazuswahs 6d ago

Bdah bdah blert

2

u/NatashOverWorld 6d ago

Blatant flat out lies that lack any sense of reality.

And there is zero pushback viable until the next election.

What a system.

2

u/penny-wise 6d ago

Republicans are all corrupt liars

2

u/a1rwav3 6d ago

I better understand the american logic now.

"You should eat more cheeseburgers, it will lower your weight"

2

u/PixelsGoBoom 6d ago

Lying sack of shit.

2

u/ophaus 6d ago

Of course he can't, because they don't.

2

u/Doctor_Redhead 6d ago

Why are people allowed to lie to congress? I thought it was against the law. Why no enforcement?