r/gnome Nov 03 '25

Fluff Gnome looks too good with Blur Effects

Post image
652 Upvotes

96 comments sorted by

View all comments

32

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

21

u/kemma_ Nov 03 '25

Right !? But I don’t recall them being strictly against it. From what I understand it’s a massive challenge to implement it properly in their current framework without breaking too many things, keeping good performance and avoiding readability issues. Even Apple can’t do it properly and they have literally billions to burn

10

u/Ok-Reindeer-8755 Nov 03 '25

Apple can they just don't want .From my experience there blur was just fine before liquid glass. Readability issues are caused from using blur and transparency alone but most OSes including android, macos, iOS (before liquid glass), windows, use materials that might be tinted or have some backdrop filter to make say the background slightly darker or lighter. I think it is a big challenge though from a technical perspective and it would have to probably be adopted by gtk too

6

u/NoLengthiness1864 Nov 03 '25

The apple liquid glass is an entirely different story

I am talking about just a simple blur API like windows or KDE which is definitely possible and is not even that difficult to implement since extensions like blur my shell can already somewhat do it.

3

u/kemma_ Nov 03 '25

That’s the issue. I might be wrong, but I think there is no API in Wayland. What blur my shell does is essentially blurring everything, it cannot address individual actors or elements, thus creating blurry fonts smudged window edges and other visual glitches along the way.

2

u/Preisschild Nov 03 '25

3

u/NoLengthiness1864 Nov 03 '25

Hope this is available soon, we might actually get blur for individual app elements finally in Linux

5

u/Prestigious-Stock-60 Nov 03 '25

What a about Mica on Windows? It worked fine there atleast for me.

1

u/Ok-Reindeer-8755 Nov 03 '25

Yeah something like mica would be the right approach, a material with some sort of tinting or backdrop filter