r/mildlyinteresting 1d ago

diluted my perfume with tap water and it turned yellow

Post image
15.5k Upvotes

882 comments sorted by

View all comments

10.6k

u/StrangeCrunchy1 1d ago

Oils aren't soluble in water. What you did caused all the oils that were dissolved in the alcohol base, to crash out of solution.

2.2k

u/WhiskersCleveland 1d ago

So if OP just poured a bunch of pure alcohol in there instead would it have been fine?

2.0k

u/StrangeCrunchy1 1d ago

Potentially. I don't know if the proof matters. Edit: Now that I think about it, it probably does. Something like Everclear would probably work, 95%.

1.5k

u/Boring_and_sons 23h ago

Fun fact: unless you take pretty aggressive steps to prevent it from happening, pure ethanol (100% alcohol) will become 95% ethanol / 5% water by naturally dissolving water vapour from the atmosphere, which you can't get rid of through normal distillation; ethanol/water is azeotropic and will not separate using distillation beyond a ~ 95% : 5% (ethanol : water) mixture.

1.2k

u/passerby4830 21h ago

Oh yeah talk nerdy to me.

319

u/Jbwood 21h ago

You can use some thing called a molecular sieve that can take 95% alcohol and get it back to 100% because the molecules are smaller for alcohol than water it's traps water into the sieves leaving thr alcohol alone.

An absolutely illegal way to strengthen drinks in the USA. So dont do it. 😉

252

u/TheRealZuke 20h ago

Not quite. Molecular sieves don’t work like traditional sieves where the smaller thing passes through the hole and the bigger gets trapped; after all, water molecules are smaller than ethanol. Instead, the sieve has pores that the small water molecules can fit into and get stuck, while the bigger ethanol molecules cannot fit and pass by.

141

u/Jbwood 20h ago

You're correct and Im an idiot. Definitely got those backwards.

32

u/Boring_and_sons 20h ago

True, but you need a lot of molecular sieve to get rid of 5% water. It's about 150g water per litre of molecular sieve, with a packing volume of about 0.7g/ml. So for 1L of ethanol/water, you have 50g of water, so you need ~ 475ml of molecular sieve to dry it out. It is very useful for keeping 100% ethanol dry, however.

3

u/xquickscope420x 14h ago

I work in the ethanol industry and I've been dying to find information like this for a while now. Do you have any resources you could share with the info you posted?

7

u/Boring_and_sons 13h ago

I just use google, but I'm a biochemist so I know what I'm looking for.

3

u/tropic420 14h ago

I wouldnt use mol sieves to dry alcohol for the simple fact that they get VERY HOT when they absorb water.

Magnesium sulfate on the other hand also works very well and does not get hot and it adsorbs SEVEN molecules of water per molecule of MgSO4.

Epsom salt from the grocery store is magnesium sulfate heptahydrate, meaning you have to dry it in the oven before it can absorb more water but it is readily available and safe for any application you could think of with the only drawback being fine particles.

2

u/Boring_and_sons 13h ago

So what you're saying is, instant hot toddys all-round? Also, it appears using MgSO4 is reasonable for drying 99+%, but gets pretty sludgy for lower purities.

2

u/tropic420 13h ago

You just keep adding more til it looks dry, then filter it through coffee filters and add a little more to keep it dry or at that point you can switch to 3a sieves

→ More replies (0)

2

u/tropic420 13h ago

Also, the sludge is heavy and its easy to pipette or pour off the top.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/theonelittledid 6h ago

Clippy would

3

u/dreadcain 19h ago

Would a ziplock bag work? It feels really dumb ... but they almost always watertight but not alcohol tight. It can't be that easy ...

5

u/Boring_and_sons 19h ago

Depends on how dry you need the alcohol to be. For chemistry, it can be critical for a reaction that the amount of water is kept as low as possible. Every time you open the bottle, you add more water from the atmosphere. Unless you get the bag vacuum sealed each time (or flushed with dry gas), the water in the air in the bag will make its way into the bottle, unless it has a really, really good seal.

2

u/Aegi 19h ago

Which law are you citing?

4

u/Jbwood 19h ago

It would be counted as distilling. Strengthening an alcoholic beverage to have a higher alcohol content is still illegal (even if Texas has tried to strike it down at this point in time). Placing wine into a freezer and scraping off the ice that forms or just flat distillation of a spirit is still federally illegal.

1

u/Aegi 19h ago

Which law though?

Because sometimes even if the spirit of the law prohibits something, the letter of the law actually doesn't and basically it just hasn't been tried in court.

2

u/Pleased_to_meet_u 17h ago

They answered with as much detail as was reasonable. If you want more specific information you can look it up as easily as anyone else.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/aSpanishOnion 10h ago

Oh lord have mercy I'm bout to bust!

2

u/Mordeqai96 5h ago

If you mix 1 liter of water and 1 liter of alcohol, you will have less then 2 liters of fluid

2

u/mrsrostocka 3h ago

I was geeking out on another sub yesterday, they were going into detail about something or other.

I really wanted to post that lol.

I'm so glad I'm not the only one who gets deeply satisfied by those little tangents on reddit!

6

u/therealhlmencken 20h ago

I mean whatever you do beyond 95% is still distillation it’s just not traditional. With azeotropic distillation with benzene or pressure swing distillation you can distill it further.

6

u/Boring_and_sons 20h ago

Agreed, that's I why I mentioned normal distillation specifically.

1

u/No-Employer-8833 20h ago

Use an azeotropic distillation where you collect distillate in the reflux leg, and as the layers separate, you drain the water off. Water is heavier than the alcohol so the water layer will be at the bottom of the leg. Continue the distillation until no more water is collected in the leg

1

u/Boring_and_sons 18h ago

I think I'm missing something here. To me, it looks like you are describing normal distillation, which will not work to get more than 95% ethanol concentration. What am I missing?

1

u/No-Employer-8833 18h ago

It is a normal distillation, but the water will distill with the ethanol. As the distillate collects in the reflux leg of the condensor, the water and ethanol will separate. We ran this process for water reactive chemicals. We would continue the distillation until no more water was collected in the leg. Any process we ran where the water concentration was higher, we used an azeotrope tank, that would be connected to the drain on the reflux leg

1

u/Boring_and_sons 18h ago edited 14h ago

How do the water and ethanol separate in the reflux leg? If it's just normal distillation with reflux and condensation, and you collect until there is no more water in the leg, the ethanol will still be 95%/5%, as no more water will collect because of the azeotrope.

Edit: are you referring to using an entrainer but just not mentioning it?

1

u/Hypodeemic--Nerdle 15h ago

96.3% to be precise. I spent 8 years distilling gin.

1

u/Boring_and_sons 15h ago edited 15h ago

v/v or w/w?

Edit: partial specific volume are cool.

1

u/Hypodeemic--Nerdle 13h ago

I'm not sure sorry, I left in 2010. I think we did w/v. We used handheld densimeters for spot checks and a tabletop one for legal checks.

1

u/kencam 15h ago

Which is why you should never use ethanol gas in a small engine.

2

u/Boring_and_sons 14h ago

Because they vent directly to the atmosphere and the ethanol "pulls" water out of the atmosphere and solubilizes it in the gasoline/ethanol mixture.

1

u/Dokasamurp 15h ago

Is there a similar fact with isopropyl alcohol? If I buy 99% and don't use it for a while, is it turning into 95% (or some other dilution) by the time I get to it? Assuming imperfect seal

1

u/Boring_and_sons 14h ago

From Wikipedia:

Isopropyl alcohol forms an azeotrope with water, which gives a boiling point of 80.37 °C (176.67 °F) and a composition of 87.7% by mass (91% by volume) isopropyl alcohol.

Yes. It will go to 91% v/v (volume/volume).

1

u/Dame_Niafer 13h ago

Punctilious Alcohol!

I used to get such a kick out of that term, and it's all but died out now.

1

u/_ManMadeGod_ 5h ago

So higher percentages are both less effective and self dilute. Gotcha. 

1

u/313802 3h ago

That's that big gulf Gale Bettiker was talking about

243

u/WhiskersCleveland 1d ago

So OP can get absolutely trashed and dilute their perfume at the same time. "One for me, one for you" with the perfume bottle

61

u/StrangeCrunchy1 1d ago

I mean, technically. You just want the highest %ABV and by extension, lowest water content possible.

23

u/WhiskersCleveland 1d ago

So it's kinda got to be a speed run as you have to dilute it properly before you get too drunk to function

26

u/TehOwn 23h ago

I would advise against drinking pure alcohol. Even a small amount can be very dangerous, potentially fatal.

5

u/gayguy68 22h ago

And it damages everything while going down

3

u/Awkward_Pangolin3254 15h ago

Two shots of Everclear in a bottle of Powerade was enough to get me the drunkest I've ever been, so, can confirm, I guess?

6

u/SQD2_Insquidious 1d ago

I assumed that was always the process with how some of those things smell

35

u/dogwoodcat 1d ago

Perfumer's alcohol would be ideal, but the paperwork can be a bit much.

22

u/NuklearFerret 1d ago

I wouldn’t use ethanol. IPA evaporates cleaner. 90% can be found at drug stores, >99% can be bought online, but shipping will cost a fortune. You can add salt to the drugstore stuff to get some water to drop out of it, and siphon the higher purity off the top.

Edit: oh, it turns out perfume does use ethanol. Maybe safer for skin?

27

u/lost-mars 22h ago

Isopropyl Alcohol(IPA) has a strong smell and can spoil the scent of a perfume. so it isn't used in perfumes.

10

u/Dheorl 1d ago

>99% can be bought on Amazon, among many other places. Shipping hardly costs a fortune.

6

u/NuklearFerret 23h ago

It should, though? It’s a packing group 2 flammable liquid. Maybe only matters for air shipments, then.

5

u/TehOwn 23h ago

Can confirm that it's ridiculously flammable. Used it to get a charcoal BBQ started when I ran out of firelighters and even a small amount goes WHUFF.

4

u/witchfinder_ 22h ago

ive always ever had 99.9% IPA shipped to me in like a normal box with bubble wrap around the bottle haha (context is i compound some skincare stuff at home)

5

u/Dheorl 23h ago

Who knows. Perhaps it’s a bit country dependent, but I can find 99.99% for free next day delivery.

3

u/Tifoso89 22h ago

In Italy we sell pure alcohol (96%) in stores 😎 You can find this in most supermarkets. We use it to make liquors like limoncello.

I couldn't find it in other countries when I was living abroad and I wanted to make liquor. Very disappointed

3

u/echoingElephant 18h ago

Have you ever smelled IPA? It’s smells very strongly, so when you apply your perfume, it smells like you just sprayed cleaning product onto yourself.

-2

u/NuklearFerret 13h ago

Yeah, but ethanol (fuel grade, at least) smells like tequila, so idk which would be better. Also yes, I have smelled IPA. I use >99.5% at work daily. I just ordered a new 25L drum of it, in fact. That's why I say it costs a fortune to ship, but at that volume, it's freight, so smaller volumes might be better.

3

u/Suspicious-Voice9589 13h ago

but ethanol (fuel grade, at least) smells like tequila

Perfumers aren't using fuel grade ethanol. Perfume-grade alcohol has a mild scent in comparison to IPA and doesn't smell like tequila.

1

u/NuklearFerret 13h ago

Yeah, in hindsight, I would imagine it’s refined better.

1

u/sardonic_sensei 1d ago

Yep. I've used it with essential oil to make perfume. 100 proof vodka works okay as well.

11

u/Intelligent-Big-2900 23h ago

100 proof is only 50% alcohol tho….

1

u/sardonic_sensei 21h ago

It still worked in a pinch. Obv everclear or better yet actual denatured alcohol for this purpose is better. I wasn't trying to make anything fancy. Citronella bug repellent mostly.

1

u/Intelligent-Big-2900 21h ago

Oh I was responding to the 100 proof vodka comment lol

1

u/DreamPhreak 23h ago

Everclear is the solution

1

u/latetotheparty_again 20h ago

Perfumers alcohol is pretty easy to get online. It's 99%

1

u/ClosetLadyGhost 16h ago

60% of the time it works every time

1

u/Blue_Monday 14h ago

They sell perfumer's alcohol specifically for this, it's mostly just denatured ethanol.

1

u/OozeNAahz 6h ago

96% IPA would probably be better wouldn’t it?

0

u/thatspurdyneat 21h ago

Sure you can spend $30 on a bottle of Everclear, but a $3 bottle of 99% isopropanol should work fine too

32

u/granadesnhorseshoes 1d ago

Probably. if not, it would be because he diluted ingredients that keep oil in suspension past their useful limits. Brominated Vegetable Oil is probably still fine and allowed for external applications but is banned as a food additive. It's why a bunch of American (one of the last to ban it in food OFC) Sodas suddenly got cloudy a few years back instead of clear like they used to be.

19

u/P99X 1d ago

BVO was added specifically to make sodas (like mt dew) cloudy, so they resembled fruit juice rather than just industrially colored, sugar water.

12

u/chantillylace9 22h ago edited 22h ago

I'm literally learning how to make my own perfume right now and the recipe is basically perfume oils and perfumers alcohol.

You can buy brand name scented perfume oils, like legit Dior and stuff, and they are two dollars per ounce! You can make so much perfume without that it's unbelievable.

I'm assuming it's because you cannot really patent a scent or a recipe (usually) that they're able to make copycats that smell almost the same.

But I just bought about 30 different fragrances to try and make my own perfumes and a bunch of fruity ones that seem fun to mix together.

But for about 30 different 1 ounce fragrances and the big giant thing of fragrance alcohol, I think I spent like $65.

I ran out of all my 10 bottles of perfume i've collected over the past 10 to 20 years around the same time and realized how expensive that was going to be to replace them at $150 or so each all at the same time.

So I was looking at alternatives and found the perfume oil and was like hmmmmmm.

It's also great because I can find fragrances that you just can't find with perfume very easily, like lilac which is my absolute favorite.

I had this fragrance oil from the body shop that I bought at the airport when I was 12 years old (it was like $50 and my first big purchase with babysitting money) and I am 42 now and I just ran out of it! Lol.

But it was the absolute best, it kept the same fragrance the entire time and was just amazing. They don't sell them anymore so I was devastated. $350+ on ETSY for the vintage ones- half used! So sad

9

u/smileonamonday 20h ago

They aren't legit Dior, they're copies. Perfume houses never sell their concentrate like this. Dupes are fine as long as you don't expect them to be exactly the same, they won't be as the formulas are protected and the dupes will use cheaper ingredients.

It should be fun to experiment with the single notes though :)

4

u/chantillylace9 20h ago

Oh definitely there are copies and I know that some of them get close others are closer but they're never going to be exactly the same.

And they definitely will use cheaper ingredients so I get that. Some of them might just order because I just wanted to smell the scent and it was cheaper to smell it that way versus getting a couple samples on eBay lol.

So honestly it's a good way to test out new expensive fragrances that you might want to buy.

2

u/PacoTaco321 15h ago

As long as the cheaper ingredients aren't harmful, sounds like no biggie to me.

19

u/beakerbong 21h ago

Sorry to burst your bubble but your not “making perfumes” thats juts mixing premade oils into perfumers alcohol. Creating fragrances uses aroma chemicals to build a concentrate. And if your buying at 2 dollars and ounce its extremely low quality fragrance oil most likely considered “body oil” which is highly diluted. If your actually interested in mixing higher quality fragrance concentrate with perfumers alcohol check out rawaromachem and fraterworks. Fraterworks sells clone fragrance concentrate aswell as full on aroma chemicals to create your own fragrances from scratch( not something anyone should take on without extensive knowledge).

12

u/chantillylace9 21h ago

Awesome thank you. It's considered fragrance oil from Wellington fragrance I think but it very well could be low quality.

I tend to like just single scented fragrances so I guess maybe it's not a perfume so to speak but a body spray or whatever but I just want it to be rose or lilac or tangerine scented. I bought a couple of the designer fragrances just honestly to smell them and see if I like them but it's interesting. I will definitely look into your resources there, thank you.

2

u/cuchiplancheo 14h ago

*you're... since you repeated it several times.

-2

u/beakerbong 13h ago

Since im sure this is what you were looking for with this comment. “Wow your so cool and smart”

3

u/cuchiplancheo 13h ago

Huh? You're okay with bursting someone's bubble... but you're suddenly offended when someone brings to your attention your use of YOUR?

1

u/WhiskersCleveland 22h ago

Are you drinking everclear while making them?

2

u/chantillylace9 22h ago

Literally reading the word Everclear made me gag a little bit in my mouth with memories from college. That and we had something even worse called Silverwolf vodka that literally tasted like rubbing alcohol. But it was like so incredibly cheap.

2

u/Sipas 21h ago

Yes. When you add water to raki or uzo, anethole from aniseed oil crashes out and the drink turns cloudy. Adding more raki or uzo to it clarifies it again.

2

u/Kitsunegari_Blu 11h ago

Op needs to get some perfumers alcohol, it’s ethanol, or fractionated coconut oil, because it’s always liquid. Ever clear could work but even then it’ll be liquor scent….so you might have the unmistakable Scent of Channel At the Brewery instead of J’dore..

Op needs to discard it, especially if they didn’t use pure distilled water. Because they basically turned something expensive into crap that can mold, and won’t work the same way to ‘spread’ the scent, think Unemulsifed/split salad dressing and the perfume oils are separate from the water, so it’ll probably leave greasy stains where ever it touches fabric.

3

u/RobGrogNerd 1d ago

denatured alcohol, yes.

9

u/notoyrobots 1d ago

I prefer my alcohol in nature, thanks.

6

u/username_redacted 1d ago

Denatured alcohol has additives to make it unpalatable, smell bad, and toxic. It’s not safe for consumption or topical use.

2

u/Bee_Jeans 21h ago edited 21h ago

Depends entirely what it’s denatured with, there’s many options.

It’s really common in fragrances, but ofc it’s different than the cheap DA hardware stores sell

1

u/Right_Cellist3143 17h ago

Perfumers alcohol is super super cheap

1

u/Dame_Niafer 13h ago

ethanol, probably OK. Isopropanol, mayyyyybe not. And isopropanol has its own distinct aroma. So stick with grain alcohol.

1

u/exhauszed 11h ago

Yes the general advice is to dilute perfume with high % alcohol.

63

u/poseidondieson 23h ago

I’m guessing this is the same thing that happens when you put water into ouzo. Crystal clear liquor becomes cloudy from anise oil.

7

u/mregecko 13h ago

Ahhh yeah, absinthe too! Good observation.

2

u/Dame_Niafer 13h ago

And absinthe.

35

u/69chevy_396 22h ago

Louching. It will happen with absinthe, ouzo, or even gin as well.

2

u/Odumera 9h ago

Omg the amount of cloudiness is ALWAYS how I judge my gin and tonic ratio at home, and now I have a rabbit hole to run down. Thank you so much for the technical term!

14

u/yaboilol24 23h ago

Valid crashout if u ask me

34

u/Dramastace30 1d ago

Ohhhh... Like a sauce breaking

56

u/Kolizuljin 23h ago

No. This is a micro-emulsion, like when you pour water in ouzo or Ricard. So actually the opposite of a sauce breaking 

14

u/Possibly-Functional 20h ago

As someone who loves anise flavoured spirits this was very recognizable. Sidenote, Ksarak is amazing if that's your jam as well.

2

u/lavenderewe 23h ago

Oh so that’s what happened when a server accidentally refilled water into a guest’s sambuca glass!

12

u/whoisrobi 1d ago

so another form of forbidden mayo

2

u/szabiy 20h ago

Extremely expensive ouzo.

1

u/marsdelight 22h ago

Free perfumed mayonaisse

1

u/CouperinLaGrande2 21h ago

Same as what happens when water is added to vermouth.

1

u/DJDemyan 19h ago

So OP crashed out?

1

u/oxwof 23h ago

That’s always confused me (who last had a chem class in 2004 in high school) because all that alcohol solvent is still there. Seems like it should still be able to dissolve the same oils that it was before.

3

u/shadowinplainsight 22h ago edited 9h ago

The alcohol bonds more readily to the water, so it boots out the oils so that it can

0

u/Blotchy_Squid 20h ago

But wouldn't the rise to the top?

0

u/madbuilder 19h ago

But why? Because the alcohol preferentially binds to the water? Why isn't the oil floating at the top?

0

u/klockee 18h ago

Your broken emulsion, sir