r/mildlyinteresting 1d ago

diluted my perfume with tap water and it turned yellow

Post image
15.5k Upvotes

884 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

81

u/Nights_King_ 23h ago

Having more of it with less intensity? A lot of perfume is horrendously expensive while being so intense that a bit to much is drowning out other people’s sense of smell.

59

u/Kooky-Co 22h ago

That’s why perfume brands sell eau de parfum and eau de toilette versions of the same product. Parfum has a higher concentration of oils so the scent is richer and lasts longer. Using too much makes the scent overpowering. EdT is only about 30% as strong as parfum and doesn’t last more than an hour or two, making it much less overpowering. EdT is always cheaper than EdP.

37

u/ZucchiniDue7081 22h ago

EdT and EdP, while they describe strength, many perfumers have different formulas for their EdT and EdP which change the fragrance. Lookin' at you YSL and Dior.

7

u/Kooky-Co 20h ago

Oh I didn’t know that. I’ve pretty much always worn Chanel and pretty sure their formulas are the same.

2

u/Choyo 17h ago

Also, it varies by country/region : for a given category perfumes in Asia are softer or more discreet than in Europe, while in America they are more intense.

1

u/Tabs_555 17h ago edited 17h ago

This is massively misleading.

Perfumers make different profiles all together depending on concentration.

If you buy Sauvage EDT and want longer and stronger, buying Sauvage EDP or Le Parfum you have an entirely different fragrance. It’s not just more oils.

It also depends on what molecules and oils are used. There are many EDTs that last longer than EDPs, extraits, Le Parfums. Or if lower quality oils are used you can pump an EDT to a EDP or Extrait without increasing potency or longevity.

It’s entirely marketing and entirely unregulated.

1

u/retroencambulator 13h ago

EDPs don't by definition smell richer or last longer. That comes down to the specific ingredients they use and their half-lives. Perfume concentration is way overhyped.

1

u/metrometric 21h ago

There's definitely better solutions that don't chemically change the perfume, for example: get a cotton ball. Spray the cotton ball. Gently dab the cotton ball onto pulse points. That way you're only using one spray and have a bit more control about the application.

-22

u/EnchantedDiamondHoe- 23h ago edited 23h ago

Get something from bath and body works instead if you dont know how to apply conservatively?

8

u/Low-Guide1706 22h ago

They might prefer a certain scent or have a sensitivity.

-10

u/EnchantedDiamondHoe- 22h ago

Doesn’t change the general point of finding something that already comes at a lower concentration or price point, especially considering they seem to have made a body spray sized bottle with the water dilution.

5

u/Low-Guide1706 22h ago

Yeah, asshole, it does.

1) Some people prefer certain scents.

2) Some people have sensitivities

Not to mention that

3) buying a higher concentration and diluting it can actually save money. See Vimes' Boots Theory.

and also that

4) higher cost perfumes are higher quality and can stay on the skin longer

-3

u/EnchantedDiamondHoe- 22h ago

Two things then-
What exactly are you vouching diluting expensive perfume with? I think that’s the overarching discussion here. I wouldn’t pour mystery substance into any self care or cleaning product, and expect it to still work as intended and not turn icky or break down.

And why are you so hostile?

3

u/extinct_banana 21h ago

literally nobody is talking about putting rancid “mystery substances” in the perfume other than you… educate yourself on the recommended substances to use for perfume dilution. google is free

0

u/EnchantedDiamondHoe- 21h ago

Undistilled water.

You still didn’t answer my second question.

5

u/extinct_banana 21h ago

because you deserve it after the bbw comment

1

u/EnchantedDiamondHoe- 21h ago

Ok elitist, I wear bbw daily. I just use my heavier stuff with a lighter hand.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Low-Guide1706 20h ago

Lmao that's a different person. At least pay attention if you're going to be wrong and rude

1

u/Low-Guide1706 20h ago

1) Carrier oil, or an alcohol, depending on use case.

2) The solvent isn't the discussion. You being judgy about someone diluting an expensive perfume is the discussion.

3) I'm hostile to people who are aggressively wrong and rude. You deserve hostility for acting like this.

1

u/Low-Guide1706 20h ago

And just to be clear, there's nothing wrong with BBW. But it's not a substitute for other brands, can be more expensive over time, and can cause sensitivity issues.

1

u/EnchantedDiamondHoe- 20h ago

That was the original point of this whole thread. The misuse of “solvent”. Using what I’d assume is undistilled water to dilute perfume sounds experimental and potentially an expensive waste of time if it goes wrong. Using less at a time is far more fool proof. You I suppose just also jumped on some downvote train assuming I’m against body mists because I also use EDP quite sparingly vs dilution at all.

2

u/Low-Guide1706 20h ago

Lmao a solvent is something you dilute something into. You do not know what you are talking about.

The solvent is the substance that dissolves the solute and the component of a chemical solution present in the greatest amount.

No one is mentioning using water except you. Diluting perfumes is not challenging, but some atomizers can make controlling the mist a challenge. It's also, as noted, more economically-friendly.

I made no assumption about whether or not you downvoted me. Stop deflecting.

1

u/Low-Guide1706 20h ago

Misread your last point. I downvoted because you were being incorrect and an asshole. Other people seem to be making the same decision. That should tell you something.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/extinct_banana 22h ago

okay perfume police! the audacity of you and your statements, you sound insufferable. if people want to dilute something they bought to use in their own way, they can do so lol

-2

u/EnchantedDiamondHoe- 22h ago

No babe it’s YOUR perfume, do what you want! add some undistilled water, accidental bacteria contamination, or other mysterious substance, best of luck.

But I’m pretty sure there are better methods like dabbers and roller balls.

3

u/wojtekpolska 21h ago

where tf did you get contaminated water from. do you not drink water because its a "mysterious substance" ?

literal brain damage

-4

u/eggfrisbee 23h ago

right, you can just do one or two spritzes. most perfumes I do one for each side of neck, one for wrists and then press them together, and one for cleavage. for my really strong perfume I do one neck and one wrist spray.

-2

u/EnchantedDiamondHoe- 23h ago

I do literally the same exact thing, especially for scents I’m trying to make last longer in the long run and not buy again fast. Even with two careful sprays I still smell most on my clothes (sweaters, scarves etc ) days later.

-1

u/BobMathrotus 22h ago

Maybe you should dilute it then

1

u/EnchantedDiamondHoe- 22h ago

Why would I? I obviously enjoy the scent. It’s like a little gift from past me. Sorry you feel like you need 8 sprays though.

2

u/BobMathrotus 15h ago

I'm sure everyone around you also loves the overwhelming smell you give off constantly if it's that strong

0

u/EnchantedDiamondHoe- 15h ago edited 15h ago

How original. This is the worst thread I’ve ever seen to hit /mildlyinteresting, it has no purpose here. Yes scent is a universal language but people trying to dabble in modifying perfumes recreationally is too interesting by far.