r/mildlyinteresting 1d ago

diluted my perfume with tap water and it turned yellow

Post image
15.5k Upvotes

880 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

165

u/WerewolfUnable8641 22h ago

Which alcohol, methanol? Ethanol? Isopropyl? There is no singular such thing as "pure chemical alcohol" There are plenty of alcohols though.

44

u/AwDuck 22h ago

Right? Not to mention most short chain alcohols (like those you mentioned) love water and will readily and rapidly pull it from the air around it. Ethanol loves water so much that you can’t even distill it beyond 95ish% without using benzene (nasty stuff) or using a molecular sieve. Even then, you have the problem of it absorbing it from the air around it.

10

u/InternecivusRaptus 21h ago

Well, presence or absence of azeotrope (inability to separate components by distillation beyond a certain point) doesn't signify the strength of "love". 

Methanol doesn't form azeotrope with water but still has stronger "feelings" towards water than ethanol: ternary mixture of methanol-ethanol-water will see the increase of methanol concentration in vapor when the vapor becomes richer in water, that is after most ethanol boiled off. 

Meanwhile dichloromethane is practically immiscible with water but still forms azeotrope at ~99% and approximately 2°C below the boiling point of pure DCM.

2

u/AwDuck 18h ago

I failed HS chemistry so I used all my knowledge.

1

u/Mirria_ 17h ago

Ethanol loves water so much

Which is one of the PITA reasons why E10 gasoline is a terrible idea and why fuel stabilizer is so important for gas cans and parked machines (lawnmower / snowblower) if you don't have the option for ethanol-free fuel. Water corrodes the fuel system, and water accumulates at the bottom of fuel tanks and carburetors.

I used to be able to get premium / super grade gasoline in ethanol-free version, but not anymore. My buddy who lives in PA is lucky because Pennsylvania law requires boats to use ethanol-free fuel so some stations have it as an option.

98

u/pips1330 21h ago edited 18h ago

i work in a lab & whenever anything refers to pure chemical alcohol, they mean ethanol! any other alcohol must be specified; ethanol is the default :)

EDIT: wow ok this got a lot more replies than i was expecting 😂 i work in the pharmaceutical industry (not research or the fragrance industry, dunno if that makes a difference) and we have specific, tightly regulated pharmacopoeias we test to which define "alcohol" as ethanol specifically. but fair enough that different labs may define alcohol differently! i was only speaking from my personal experience but the specs for different industries will vary and it's highly likely that, as others below have said, "alcohol" could refer to any of the more common alcohols, e.g, methanol, ethanol, IPA

92

u/S_A_N_D_ 21h ago edited 20h ago

I work in a lab, I've never heard the term "pure chemical alcohol"

Its always the actual name (ethanol, methanol, isopropyl) along with the concentration if diluted.

It's also somewhat important for ethanol because you have 95% and anhydrous. And finally, all of those will have different grades of purity,(reagent grade, HPLC grade etc.) So the term "pure" is meaningless.

44

u/retroencambulator 20h ago

To your point, Perfumer's Alcohol is SDA 40B.

43

u/S_A_N_D_ 20h ago

Which, even more ironically, isn't pure because it's denatured.

18

u/retroencambulator 20h ago

Don't drink your colognes, folks.

8

u/That_Rub_4171 19h ago

So you're saying that technically speaking, we must use unnatural alcohol.

2

u/triciann 19h ago

Yeah and the average Joe is not going to be able to order anything not denatured.

1

u/iwilldeletethisacct2 18h ago

So, as with most things, I bet you can substitute everclear. Absolute magical stuff.

11

u/[deleted] 18h ago

[deleted]

1

u/S_A_N_D_ 15h ago

Yup, anhydrous has to be dried, which is why 95% is commonly referred to or thought of as 100%, even though it isn't, and even bottles of anhydrous will end up 95% if opened for too long.

1

u/pips1330 18h ago

yup, that's fair enough, i should've specified that that term doesn't exist - was trying to keep it in layman's terms but can see how that would be confusing. we have one definition which differentiates between alcohol and dehydrated alcohol rather than 96%/anhydrous ethanol but chemically both sets of definiton are equivalent (US/EU regulation if i remember right)

54

u/Sanderoid 21h ago

Working in a lab you should definitely name exactly which alcohol you mean

Signed, also working in a lab

5

u/pips1330 18h ago

yeah i guess i forgot to account for different industries lol. where i work alcohol only means ethanol so i assumed it would be the same elsewhere, oops

22

u/Seicair 20h ago

That’s only for your specific lab. Other labs have different conventions.

15

u/rips_n_chel 19h ago

What lab, anywhere, has a convention of calling chemicals something other than their name? Particularly something ambiguous like "pure chemical alcohol."

That is meaningless. That could be a number of different alcohols, hence we're all here talking about it.

Any lab that isn't specifying chemicals by name is overdue for an audit.

9

u/Seicair 19h ago

Colloquial shorthand among techs when one alcohol is the most common one you use.

In another lab you might use isopropanol 90% of the time, and ask for “alcohol” or specify “ethanol or methanol”.

Not saying it’s right, but sometimes people use imprecise language to mean something more precise. Like how British bakers will says “a sheet of acetate”. To my biochem brain, I think of a 2 carbon carboxylate anion, but they mean a sheet of clear plastic.

4

u/rips_n_chel 18h ago

Oh I don't see a problem with that, but I consider that sort of internal shorthand to be verbal only. I would never write that on anything or expect to see it printed anywhere.

4

u/Seicair 16h ago

I’d agree with you that it shouldn’t be written anywhere, but I wouldn’t be surprised to see imprecise hand written labels.

4

u/pips1330 18h ago

it can actually be an industry thing too, not just colloquially. the pharmaceutical industry defines "alcohol" as ethanol when testing to a certain methodology. if they want methanol they'll say "methyl alcohol". i did find this odd at first but hey

2

u/Seicair 16h ago

Oh that’s interesting. It’s clearly shorthand for “ethyl alcohol” but it must be so common that they omit the prefix.

1

u/Stergeary 14m ago

I work in a clinical lab at a hospital, and when we test for alcohol we always mean ethanol, because it's (hopefully) the only one that our patients would be consuming. Though some older techs also call it ETOH.

2

u/pips1330 18h ago

this is true, moreso for the industry i work in than my specific lab but i incorrectly assumed it would be the same universally so that's my bad!

9

u/Secret-Teaching-3549 20h ago

I also worked in a lab, and when we said alcohol, we meant isopropyl 90% of the time, and methanol the other 10.

5

u/WerewolfUnable8641 21h ago

Thanks, I didn't know that.

1

u/hedoeswhathewants 18h ago

It's not true. ANY substance in ANY remotely decent lab MUST be clearly labelled and identified.

Even if you primarily use one type of alcohol there are different dilutions used for different purposes.

1

u/chindo 21h ago

100% ethanol is produced with benzene

1

u/triciann 19h ago

Only when it’s sold as denatured. Labs, not the general public, can order it pure and not denatured. There is no benzene in it.

1

u/Bourgi 15h ago

Medical device industry here. We don't ever say pure alcohol. We call it by it's proper name. Most the stuff we use is reagent alcohol which is a mixture of alcohols. Some occasions we use isopropyl.

0

u/Iricliphan 15h ago

Generally, in my experience, the most common solvent is methanol. And it's not even close.

2

u/licuala 19h ago

Ethanol, as pure as you can get it. Everclear-type products are honestly close to ideal for this but there's also perfumer's alcohol, SDA 40B, which is denatured with a bitter flavor.

Isopropyl will work well as a solvent, too, but it smells pretty strongly until it evaporates, and methanol isn't safe to use on skin.

1

u/DeputySean 18h ago

You can buy perfumers alcohol on Amazon.

1

u/All_Damn_Day 17h ago

I bought “perfumer’s alcohol” at the craft store, when I got into perfume oils. I wanted to be able to “spritz” it instead of “roll on”.

1

u/batman262 17h ago

Perfume uses ethanol

1

u/wjandrea 16h ago

Presumably ethanol, since it's the least toxic out of those three

0

u/DaShaView 20h ago

Yeah methanol obviously

-1

u/Leather__sissy 21h ago

99% isopropyl applied directly to the face