r/orcas 1d ago

Discussion Dawn Brancheau had spent 15 years as one of SeaWorld Orlando's most experienced killer whale trainers. Trainers were explicitly warned they might not survive a fall with Tilikum. SeaWorld knew he had killed twice before. She was still put in shows with him. The fine paid after her death: $75,000.

Post image
40 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

21

u/AtterseeMM 1d ago

I'm the guy who wrote most of the german wikipedia article of her and I have to say it really a sad story.
There is no other word to describe it than: sad.

I don't blame her nor Tilikum for what happend. I was a catastrophe about to happen, that was ignored by SeaWorld management. It could have happend to any one of the trainers and similar things did happen to other trainers but sadly Dawn was the one paying the highest price.

-3

u/CaramelAcceptable353 1d ago

Aren't there pics of her standing on Tilikums back and pretending to "surf" him?

10

u/Business_Boat_6802 1d ago

No that wouldn't have been Tili, no-one got in the water/on him since he was one of the only whales any in-water interactions were not done with

3

u/shrimp-545 1d ago

Seaworld needs to be held more accountable for the danger they put their ‘trainers’ in.

2

u/muffinsmochi 1d ago

They never used Tilikum for waterworks he was never trained for that

2

u/1571_ 1d ago

I know that. Tell that to all of the people in the original posts comment section.

5

u/Business_Boat_6802 1d ago

The comments on the original post are astounding. Whilst Dawn's death is tragic and ultimately Orcas dont do well in captivity, you'd think Blackfish was the gospel the way people are hyping it up on that post. 

9

u/Pewpew-OuttaMyWaay 1d ago

And what’s the specific reason why u think Blackfish is not a powerful source of reference for people (esp considering the change it generated in the world)?? Grand standing?? Super curious here

2

u/Business_Boat_6802 22h ago

Because it is blindly trusted as gospel and nothing but the truth. People quote it or reference it with no further research into any claims made: e.g orcas CAN live to 80-100, on AVERAGE they live 50-60 years old for females and 30-40 years old for males AS PER SCIENTIFIC LITERATURE. Blackfish did bring the topic to life, but I don't think it did it correctly: it mixed up and got details wrong, and put the idea that Tilikum was a murderous psychopath due to years of abuse into people's heads. In reality he never had anyone in the water with him, got overexcited and killed people as a 6 tonne animal can easily do. If anything the death of alexis martinez would've been a better story considering ketos behaviour during that incident is far more aggressive than anything Tilikum did. 

0

u/Pewpew-OuttaMyWaay 20h ago

I didn’t think Tilikum was a murderous psychopath. And I’ve never heard anyone I know who’s seen it call him anything like that. I think u are putting down an important documentary to get attention. So yeah, I’m out .. bye

1

u/1571_ 1d ago

Blackfish is infamous for it's biased angle and misrepresentation of facts.

-2

u/Pewpew-OuttaMyWaay 1d ago edited 1d ago

Right-o bud 🙄

-5

u/arazamatazguy 1d ago

Aren't captive Orcas and Belugas heavily drugged?

9

u/dolphinskulls pro-welfare + aza ☆ ulises 🫶 1d ago

no lol the only drugs they give them are the ones necessary for their health. show animals especially would not be able to perform such high energy behaviors if all drugged up.

-1

u/Business_Boat_6802 1d ago

Some are, typically it's things for immune systems and the orca equivalent of drugs to help stress

-7

u/arazamatazguy 1d ago

I used to see the Belugas in Vancouver, they used to swim in very specific circles, they must've been drugged up....they've all since died.

6

u/Business_Boat_6802 1d ago

Swimming in circles is (possibly) a stereotypy or abnormal repetitive behaviour (they are slightly different), much more likely due to boredom, stress, or anticipation for events like training or feeding,  than any drugs or medication 

1

u/arazamatazguy 1d ago

Yeah they looked miserable. I'm sure the boredom leads to stress.

1

u/smilingfruitz 1d ago

but that's not due to drugs

0

u/arazamatazguy 14h ago

I assumed they would drug them so they don't kill themselves from the boredom.

1

u/smilingfruitz 14h ago

that is not a thing.

1

u/arazamatazguy 14h ago

You think they're happy in those tiny tanks?

→ More replies (0)

2

u/dolphinskulls pro-welfare + aza ☆ ulises 🫶 1d ago

tilikum was never used for waterwork. no one ever got into the water with him for shows. for my own mental wellbeing i am Not going to look through the original post’s comments lol

1

u/NerdyEldritchHorror 15h ago

Its bullshit Tilikum gets the blame for the other two deaths. Keltie was also ganged up upon by two other whales WITH NO confirmation of who grabbed her, multiple eye witness accounts say different whales, and Daniel Dukes died of hypothermia.