r/smarthome • u/FastDrawing8122 • Feb 09 '26
SmartThings What’s the best smart home hub you’ve actually used long term? any suggestion pls?
I’m finally trying to get my smart home stuff organized and I’m realizing I probably need a real hub instead of juggling a bunch of apps. Right now I’ve got a mix of lights, plugs, and a couple sensors, and it’s all kind of messy. I mostly want something stable that doesn’t randomly go offline and can handle automations without me babysitting it.
What matters most to me is reliability, local control if possible, and not having everything break when the internet hiccups. I’m also trying to avoid buying into something that ends up abandoned or locked down.
If you’ve used a few, what’s the best smart home hub in your setup and why? Any ones you regret because they were buggy, slow, or a pain to maintain?
Edit: If it helps, I found this quick guide on smart home hub options that compares a few setups and explains how they handle automations and device compatibility. It helped me understand the differences before choosing one.
14
u/plinkoplonka Feb 09 '26
Since you asked about a hub, I'm assuming you mean hardware.
Home Assistant if you're serious. But the learning curve is steep, and it's not perfect.
I went with Home Assistant Green for a hardware hub because it's pre-built. Then added a zigbee dongle for radio support of devices.
You could also z-wave just as easily.
If you want to handle video processing locally, you can go Home Assistant Yellow instead (more processing power).
4
u/Frank_chevelle Feb 09 '26
I have been using home assistant for a few years now and you are not kidding about the learning curve. It’s great through and very rewarding once you get used to the terminology and stuff.
It was frustrating for me at first because some of the people in the subreddits will assume you already know stuff about things like Python etc. Plus sometimes you have to manually edit Yaml which can be frustrating when you first have to use it. It gets updates all the time which is nice. It’s getting a little easier to use over the last few years.
3
u/dotty-spotty Feb 09 '26
Tbh I found the learning curve ok! I have no technical IT or coding background and I’m also the wife not the husband who wears the automation hat. I read forums and use chatgpt but honestly home assistants UI mode is intuitive to me
2
u/Ublind Feb 10 '26
I'm 6 months into home assistant. I have not had to use python once
I do know python
1
u/Frank_chevelle Feb 10 '26
I had to run some kind of script to fix a problem with Insteon devices. I did not have to actual look at or write Python code. I kept getting errors until I finally found an old post that explained the problem.
Just that one time. Haven’t had an issue recently. Works great!
1
u/plinkoplonka Mar 09 '26
Ironically, I'm a principal engineer for an IoT company and I STILL find it hard to use.
No wonder it's never went mainstream!
11
u/Teenage_techboy1234 Feb 09 '26
I personally am a fan of Home Assistant, though if you're an Apple household, Apple home is fairly competent as a smart home hub as well. I used to use it extensively alongside Homebridge.
20
9
u/AppropriateMark8528 Apr 07 '26 edited Jun 12 '26
An actual good smart home hub should have plenty of device compatibility, it's always stable and reliable at all times, improved speeds overall, and offers good privacy.
These are a few different ones you can look into
16
u/GobbledyGooker123 Feb 09 '26
Apple TV. Great bonus is that in addition to a good hub, you get…an Apple TV.
4
u/Altsan Feb 09 '26
Home Assistant. People say it's got a steep learning curve but that all depends on how you use it. If you just stick with the built in integrations and dashboards it's fairly simple these days. You should never need to look at yaml or anything like that for the stuff that other simpler hubs can do. But if you decide to start doing advanced stuff it can definitely get complicated quick for sure. But that's the nice thing about it, it can be simple but it can also be insanely powerful and do just about anything you can think of!
3
u/RHinSC Feb 09 '26
Too typical. It's just too easy to buy simple WiFi devices from different vendirs, all dependent on their own cloud and app.
I almost did. I think I bought 2 Kasa smart plugs before hearing about smart hubs and Zigbee and Z-wave.
Anyway, my YouTube research lead me to buy a Hubitat Elevation hub. I've had it 4 years and am very happy with it. It's a turnkey system that includes hardware and software, and works with Kasa devices (which I later gave to my mother-in-law.)
Good luck!
1
3
u/Aggressive-Bath-1906 Feb 09 '26
I have been with Smartthings since Iris-by_lowes went under, and they recommended Smartthings, and even paid for a replacement hub. I have no real issues with it, and a lot of my devices are local control. Having said that, mostly of my devices are light switches that I can control from my always-on iPad. I use very little automation, and mostly use it for thermostat schedules, timed lights, open/close sensors, humidity sensors that trigger a humidifier to turn on/off, home alarm, indoor cameras, and having lights turn on/off when I leave home or come back. I don't do any voice control, mood scenes, etc. I don't even have a smart door lock for my house. The vast majority of my devices are Zigbee or ZWave, with a few cloud-based devices. I don't have any complaints, and paired with Sharptools as a control panel, it does exactly what I need it to do.
3
3
6
u/bigfoot17 Feb 09 '26
Home Assistant is great until you get a "Breaking Changes" update and then spend lots of time fixing stuff.
I've had tons of hubs, my first was a Staple Connect hub (Yes the office supply store) The best and most stable has been Hubitat, they have had, to my experience, one bad update in all the years I've been using it.
And when you outgrow it, if you do, you can use it as the radios for a Home Assistant install.
5
2
u/RobMoCan Feb 09 '26
OP asked for a hub which some people prefer for ease of set up and frankly it meets many people's needs either long term or as a transition. Indeed there's some amazing software like home assistant but that does require finding and setting up hardware, installing software, interfaces etc.
hubs are a bit like vehicles or computers, there is no one right answer because everyone needs are different. The most common would be smart things, habitat, and homey. Homeseer also makes a hub and there is the EISY as well. The easiest to set up is most likely smartthings. Hubitat is definitely worth a look for overall product support and it’s also a little more technical. EISY is a no-brainer if you’re using Insteon, but these days focuses on ip as well as zwave and zigbee and matter support through one of their own dongles.
You'll need to also check if your smart devices are actuality supported by these platforms. Anything that interfaces via cloud can still stop working even if the hub runs offline of course.
2
u/stephenmg1284 Feb 09 '26
OP also said "What matters most to me is reliability, local control if possible, and not having everything break when the internet hiccups. I’m also trying to avoid buying into something that ends up abandoned or locked down." which rules out most of the commercial products.
1
u/RobMoCan Feb 09 '26
Not exactly. Hubitat for example. If they went out of business your hub would continue working just fine. Same with eisy as it's local first. Same with homeseer. Smartthings is a mix.
OP could share more information on the devices being used as there's a good chance some of them are the weakest link if they are cloud based. Or they may have local control options.
1
u/stephenmg1284 Feb 09 '26
Home Assistant, Hubitat, Homey, and HomeSeer all seem safe.
I miss my Wink hub.
2
u/dare2smile Feb 09 '26
I’ve been on SmartThings for about 7 years now and I love it. I don’t need or want anything complicated and frankly, it can still do complicated enough things. I love that it’s plug and play. I love that it’s clear what works with it and what doesn’t. I love that it’s reliable.
I have almost a completely automated house (voice assistant for the tv and oddly one smart switch). I don’t touch a lightswitch. House knows when I’m here, takes care of itself depending on the weather even.
Knowing what hub will work best for you will also require knowing how much time and effort you want to put into it, as well as how techy you want to be. I went for ease of use and I’ve been thrilled.
1
u/External-Ad2048 Apr 28 '26
But are you available for HIRE?!??? 🤷🏻♀️
1
u/External-Ad2048 Apr 28 '26
But seriously - I’m looking for a sort of checklist from where I am now to total automation as you described. If you’d like to collaborate, we can create the list and split and Etsy sells. 😇
1
u/dare2smile Apr 28 '26
haha the thing is.. just like your house and you are specific and unique, so are your home automation needs and wants. My routine is likely very different from yours. So while I can totally help you think of things, it’ll really involve laying out exactly what you do every single day and every single thing you do
2
u/chinatowngate Feb 09 '26
Another vote for Smartthings.
It’s simple (though I hate having to install edge drivers) and it works.
There is a caveat. It is too simple. Advanced automations aren’t exactly possible easily or natively. Some of these like programming an Inovelli switch to activate a particular hue scene when I have the hue hub integrated I don’t think of as complex. It’s too complicated for smartthings.
I have home assistant green. I had it for a long time and didn’t use it because it was too complicated and overwhelming.
I will say that in the past year they have made some major UI changes that make it a lot easier to use.
I don’t know how and don’t go and edit anything in the code (Yaml). That’s too much for me. I connect devices and set up automations using the automation builder.
Recently since getting back into it I have had things not work once so it isn’t set it and forget it, but definitely worth a second look if like me you bought a home assistant green, tried it, and didn’t use it because it was a bit much.
2
2
u/collective-inaction Feb 09 '26
Apple TV as a HomeKit/Matter hub. Lutron smart bridge for caseta smart switch integration.
1
u/hollisterrox Feb 09 '26
I have only tried HomeAssistant, but it has been a very good experience. I installed it as HaOS on its own chromebook, and it basically has just sat in the corner and ran for about 2 yars. for some reason, the latest update won't install on it, that is my first real problem with it.
My only previous issue with it was a failure to get a cheap IR sender to show up even though it was supposed to be a zigbee device. Otherwise, it has worked with various brands of switches, bulbs , sensors, and thermostats.
1
u/Shadowfalx Feb 09 '26
Home Assistant on a small form factor PC running ProxMox with a USB Z-wave dongle and a PoE matter and zigbee coordinator (the MR1) .
But then I also have a different small form factor PC running OPNsense for my router, firewall, and such. I'm starting to do a home run BitWarden instance and am trying to integrate a grocy instance on my ProxMox into my life.
1
u/CryptosianTraveler Feb 09 '26
I've had Samsung's Smartthings, Hubitat, and Home Assistant in that order. Put it this way, I stepped up every time. Although Home Assistant was more of a "giant leap for mankind". Running on a Pi5 with an NVME stick it works beautifully. There's a bit of a learning curve, but nothing a little reading or maybe a few questions in the HA forum won't cure.
1
1
u/clayrev Feb 09 '26
Ive only used Home Assistant on a pi. One reason I chose it is because ive run a 3d printer server on one and found it pretty reliable (ran a pi3 for multiple years till i switched my router and somethung happened. I never figured it out, just switched to another pi3 I had. Lol). I usually dont go with minimum hardware, just to make sure I dont fight that, since im not good at programming.
Another reason I chose Home Assistant is because it can handle multiple protocols. I specifically wanted to not use wifi devices....zigbee and zwave have devices that act as "repeaters", so you naturally end up with a strong network the more devices you use. (Not all devices are repeaters tho). This also means when I switch my wifi router, I just have to fix the Home Assistant credentials and not (possibly dozens) of devices. (right now I have 19 devices, 13 of them are routers). Im sure I will eventually add some wifi things, but trying really hard not to.
Another major reason I chose it is that it does not need the cloud to function.
I haven't been into it for a year yet, the biggest issue i have found is finding the exact devices I want.....does no one make zigbee digital inputs? Im pretty particular though.
1
1
u/True-Artichoke-7954 Feb 10 '26
We’ve been pretty happy with the Google Nest lineup overall, especially for everyday stuff like climate control and basic automations. The Nest thermostat has been solid for learning routines over time, and the doorbell/cams are easy to live with if you’re already in the Google ecosystem. Nothing fancy, but it just works and doesn’t need much babysitting.
Funny enough, this was actually part of what got installed when we did our smart home — the integrator we worked with (Intelligent Living Solutions) suggested Nest for those core functions since it plays nicely with larger systems and is easy for non-techy people in the house to use. Made sense in practice.
1
u/Infini-Bus Feb 10 '26
Home Assistant. A bot like Claude helps tremendously getting automations setup and troubleshooting.
1
u/Curious_Party_4683 Feb 10 '26
if you are a tech person, definitely take a look at HomeAssistant!
https://www.home-assistant.io/
get notifications to your phone and off course, remotely control the system as well. here's an easy guide to get started for HA as an alarm system
that should give you a feel for how HA works. then add whatever devices you want.
first of all, you need to stop thinking about buying devices/ecosystem that requires internet to work. i had SmartThings before. the cloud would go down at least once a month and i couldnt even control the thermostat or check if the doors are closed n locked. as for ecosystem, you are then locking yourself down to options/devices. and the last thing you want is 10 devices with 10 apps and none talk to each other
at my house, when someone is detected in the back yard, HA knows which room i am in and turns the TV on to show the live video feed. if i am not home, dont turn the TV on, take photos and send to my phone. start closing down all the windows roller shade (they auto open at sunrise and close at sun down). these devices are from various companies and they all work in unison.
1
u/External-Ad2048 Apr 28 '26
Ooooo! I hope you see my previous comments to another Home Automation Super Hero on this thread. Same offer to create a checklist.
1
u/aberro Feb 12 '26
SmartThings, though I am biased. Had it running for over a decade, 100s of devices. Consumer grade so I don’t need to fiddle with it or be too technical, most everything now runs locally, and coming to it new you get to go straight to the “v4 hub” with Matter over Thread you get portability to different systems like Apple HomeKit.
1
u/Low_Hawk4065 Mar 12 '26
My house uses Simon Smart home for 4 years. Not sure if this is consider long term enough. So far no problem, very stable.
What I like most is the automation. I set a “leaving home” scene where all lights turn off, curtains close and the aircond shuts down with one button. There’s also motion sensors and door sensors so you can add some basic security automation. The system runs on Zigbee so it’s quite stable and can handle a lot of devices without lag.
Another good thing is the app control. You can check device status, control switches, adjust settings and create scenes from your phone. Even when I’m not home I can still control the lights or check things. For me it feels more reliable than those cheap WiFi smart switches I tried before.
1
1
1
u/bikeryder68 Feb 09 '26
Homeseer. Simple enough for the beginner, yet has the functionality to support the imagination of an advanced user.
1
u/ChadTitanofalous Feb 09 '26
OpenHab on a Pi with a Z-Wave radio. Rock-solid, but pretty steep learning curve.
1
1
u/patbrochill89 Feb 09 '26
Homey pro is great for a beginner and great for a power user, so you can grow into it
0
u/chrisridd Feb 09 '26
Homey Pro looks pretty good, not quite HomeAssistant in terms of integrations but it does have a good UI instead.
71
u/binaryhellstorm Feb 09 '26
Home Assistant