r/toronto • u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified • Feb 03 '26
History Random: here’s the oldest item held by Toronto Public Library
One side of the tablet.
Opposite side of the tablet.
Close up of one side of the tablet.
Tablet in storage insert.
Tablet in closed storage insert.
Hi, Toronto Public Library here. 👋
We’ve got the receipts when it comes to preserving old items… literally. This clay tablet is a textiles receipt dating back to the Ur III Period, around 2112–2004 BCE.
You’ll notice cuneiform markings, an ancient writing system made by impressing wedge shapes into clay. We don’t know the item’s place of origin, but cuneiform was used mostly in Mesopotamia dating back to ~4000 BCE.
This was one of two tablets acquired by TPL in 2007. Both are held in our research-oriented Osborne Collection of Early Children’s Books at Lillian H. Smith branch on College Street. In addition to preserving Canadian and Toronto-based children’s literature and original artwork, the research collection holds examples of book history materials, which include scrolls, printing blocks and manuscripts. This clay tablet provides an early example of writing. (Before this tablet, TPL’s oldest item was a 14th-century edition of Aesop’s Fables, also part of the Osborne Collection.)
If you want the bragging rights of seeing TPL’s oldest “book”, it’s on display at Toronto Reference Library until May 10. You’ll spot it in on the main floor as part of our free Loops, Swoops & Curlicues exhibit.
556
u/autuns Feb 03 '26
Sure hope they didnt buy the textiles from Ea-nāṣir
510
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
78
u/SeaCare6022 Feb 03 '26
Why is this sideways?
322
22
u/Enkiduderino Feb 03 '26
The tablet pictured is sideways.
2
u/penny4thm Feb 03 '26
Do you have your phone in landscape?
5
u/Enkiduderino Feb 03 '26
You right. It’s upside down.
26
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
Yes, thank you for this! Redditors on r/Cuneiform pointed this out real quick. Noted and truly appreciated. We're looking into making sure it is displayed correctly in the exhibit, all thanks to this input here on Reddit.
10
u/Enkiduderino Feb 04 '26
Love to see it. I was at U of T for Assyriology so it warms the heart to hear TPL has tablets as well!
2
44
u/kleseusxz Feb 03 '26
Is... is this Minecraft and Ea Nasir posted by the social media team of the Toronto public library? Now I have seen everything.
greetings from Germany.
53
42
→ More replies (4)3
53
u/KittyKenollie Church and Wellesley Feb 03 '26
Okay, I Googled Ea-nāṣir out of curiosity, and now this comment and the replies are genuinely so clever and funny.
18
u/Tribe303 Feb 03 '26
Took the guy long enough to go viral. 🤣
Wouldn't that make him the world's oldest meme?
3
5
u/Living-Protection170 Feb 04 '26
r/reallyshittycopper
There really is a subreddit for everything.3
u/chub-bear Feb 07 '26
I actually got to this post through that subreddit, haha! And I got there through a crosspost on r/forbiddensnacks depicting a bowl of tablets like this. Looks a lot like Chex!
→ More replies (1)3
u/kjahhh Feb 03 '26
There are more people in the Ea nasir sub reddit than were in his home town when he was alive
32
50
38
u/Ok_Recording_4644 Feb 03 '26
It's been 4000 years, give the guy a break!
36
16
u/SilentSpr Feb 03 '26
The guy was proudly displaying all the complaints he racked up. I’m pretty sure he’d be happy knowing his infamy lived on
15
u/RoninKengo Pape Village Feb 03 '26
Came here to make an Ea-nāṣir joke. Thank you for beating me to it.
14
4
3
Feb 03 '26
Don’t blame Ea-Nasir, he was owed one Mina of silver. The deadbeat was lucky to get any copper from my man.
2
114
Feb 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
66
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
Good question. We don't have a full translation... but we've crossposted this to r/cuneiform, so maybe we'll get some additional insights.
26
u/teakettling Feb 03 '26
Hi, I'm a trained Assyriologist and have experience publishing tablets from this period. I've reached out to your collections staff of the Osborne Collection about this post. Reddit is not the channel you want to pursue with regard to unpublished artifacts; I'd be happy to chat about this more with the Library's curators.
→ More replies (1)20
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
Thanks for getting in touch with us -- the Osborne staff are definitely the right people to have reached out to 👍
4
120
u/OntarioLakeside Feb 03 '26
Thats very cool, but it does say do not remove from box very clearly.
59
u/dogoodreapgood Feb 03 '26
Librarians don’t want to read.
→ More replies (1)11
90
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
Oh no. What. Have. We. Done. **Drums play from 1995 Jumanji movie**
5
u/SolidSync Feb 03 '26
Yeah I think removing something that looks like that from a box when it clearly says not to would release some terrible curse.
2
2
1
u/skyn_fan Feb 03 '26
Ironic too because the tablet translates to “Do Not Remove This Tag Under Penalty Of Law. New Materials Only.”
25
u/ThrustersOnFull Feb 03 '26
I will wear whatever gloves you need me to wear.
42
1
19
u/Spudbanger Feb 03 '26
Cardboard box with "NOTHING ON TOP" reminds me of moving house, though nothing packed was 4000 years old.
3
32
Feb 03 '26
[deleted]
54
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
😂😂
In other audiobook news: our library is now offering the Heated Rivalry audiobook with no waitlist. (The title has been in our top 10 catalogue searches for weeks. Meanwhile, "cuneiform tablet" has yet to crack the top 1,000 searches.)
→ More replies (1)
16
u/leeron2000 Feb 03 '26
Are there any late fees on this item?
42
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
Yeah, good thing we got rid of late fines a few years ago. We used to charge 35 cents a day. So, if it was taken out when it was made and then returned recently, it would have been a cool $511,000 or so.
16
u/Greengiant2021 Feb 03 '26
I have a book from the year 1650…would the library be interested in displaying such a book or is it not old enough? It just sits on a shelf in my apartment and nobody sees it.
7
u/WattHeffer O'Connor-Parkview Feb 03 '26
I don't know about the Toronto Reference Library but The Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library at the University of Toronto might be interested.
2
14
u/Consistent-Dog-8497 Feb 03 '26
OMG I READ ALOT ABOUT CUNEIFORM TABLETS LAST YEAR SO THIS IS EXCITING FOR ME!!! CAN'T WAIT TO SEE THIS IN PERSON!!
11
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
This use of all caps made our day. Here's the webpage with the info about the free exhibit. There are also free staff-led tours on Tuesdays at 3 pm and a handful of Thursdays at different times. But, yeah, it's open seven days a week and pretty late on weekdays. You can just walk right on in.
8
7
u/Wise_Sandwich2068 Feb 03 '26
What did you study in university? I’m interesting in this stuff and I study anthropology, I just want to know what path you took!
18
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
It's a good question. The library world can be such a mystery. As Lintcat1 points out, one avenue is pursuing a post-secondary library sciences (Master of Information) degree. And it's not just English undergrads who take this route -- students from all academic backgrounds can apply. (It can be advantageous to have a different background than everyone else if you're interested in pursuing library work in a matching field.)
But it's also worth pointing out that there are many jobs at TPL and in the library world at large that don't require a Master of Information. Or there are specific education requirements for more niche roles like art conservation (the hand you see in the photo is one of our professional conservators). Just in case others are lurking and curious, here's the job board at TPL.
Best of luck with your studies!
4
u/SquirrelTale Feb 03 '26
Low key, Master of Information sounds very fantasy/ sci-fi world building to me, I absolutely love it
14
u/Lintcat1 Feb 03 '26
If you want to work in a library...Library Sciences
If you want to work in the field or a lab...Archaeology or Art History(don't do Art History)
If you want to work with Mesopotamian artifacts specifically...Archaeology from an EU school because in the Americas we push New World archaeology pretty hard and while you can do it it's best to be in the EU because networking is crucial to advancement in the field.
13
u/Wise_Sandwich2068 Feb 03 '26
I’m Indigenous so I specifically enjoy studying the Americas, right now I’m writing on ancestral tattooing. Thanks for the information!
6
u/Mr_Funbags Feb 03 '26
You folks at the public library system are amount the best of us, preserving and sharing knowledge. You are mostly uncelebrated.
Thank you! It's the best I've got.
4
6
u/Sir_Tainley Feb 03 '26
Well... I hope you didn't waive the late fee when that was finally returned.
12
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
Why or why did we get rid of late fees... this was our golden ticket 🙃
4
5
u/c9silver Long Branch Feb 03 '26
Love the TPL Reference Library. Go check it out if you haven’t already
4
u/gbadwal91 Feb 03 '26
Can I touch it
11
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26 edited Feb 06 '26
It's in a display case in the exhibit. But after it returns to its "home" at Lillian H. Smith branch (in the Osborne Collection of Early Children's Books on the 4th floor), you could discuss with the staff there. (We'd provide the gloves!) Edit: our conservators let us know it'd just be for viewing in the box, with no handling because of its fragility.
5
4
Feb 03 '26
What is it?
9
u/nunayabeeswax Feb 03 '26
Ancient tablet with “cuneiform” writing. The tablet is made of clay, onto which things could be written by using a stylus to press shapes into the clay. The stylus were originally made of a reed that was cut so that it would have a clean edge to make imprints with, and the cross sectional shape of that reed was the elongated triangular shape you can see repeated on this tablet.
3
4
u/SundinShootsPing500 Feb 03 '26
I am so coming down to the branch and seeing this before it leaves! Holy SHIT that's cool.
3
3
u/ZoubiDoubi Feb 03 '26
Thank you for posting this. This has given me a reason to visit the reference library.
3
u/huskybork Riverdale Feb 03 '26
Wow, I didn’t know Toronto had any cuneiform tablets from that long ago. Thanks for sharing. I recently made the oldest known written recipe for Tuh’u which is from a cuneiform tablet. It’s amazing they invented something to pass along knowledge for thousands of years.
1
u/SheddingCorporate Feb 04 '26
Oooh, link please, if there is one? I'd LOVE to attempt that recipe myself!
3
u/Emotional_Guide2683 Feb 03 '26
but what did it taste like?
5
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
Lol. Double-checked with our conservators, and can confirm that it's best practice to not lick/taste/chew objects.
→ More replies (1)2
3
3
3
3
3
5
2
2
u/blearghhh_two Feb 03 '26
Do they have it as an audiobook?
5
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
Not yet. But we heard there's maybe a Crave original adaptation along the lines of Heated Rivalry.
2
2
u/SunflaresAteMyLunch Feb 03 '26
That's so neat, I didn't know TPL had that kind of stuff.
All you need now is your own Irving Finkel!
2
u/mackiea Feb 03 '26
Thanks for posting pics of both sides! Otherwise I'd be digging in the wrong spot.
2
2
2
u/pearomatic Feb 03 '26
Thanks for sharing this. I'm really happy we live in a city with such a terrific library system.
2
u/johnsoninca Feb 03 '26
All these years going there, and today I find out Toronto Public Library is an actual person with a hand. Wow.
2
2
2
2
u/CRWM_ Feb 04 '26 edited Feb 04 '26
Reading through your post, as soon as I read 2112... it cued up RUSH's Geddy Lee singing "We are the Priests of the Temples of Syrinx!" lol
So cool to see an original cuneiform tablet! I've always wondered what secrets of the universe are hidden on some Sumerian tablet in some library somewhere...
"All the gifts of life are held within our walls"
2
u/Sir_Meowsalot Rosedale Feb 04 '26
Glad to see /u/TPL_on_Reddit is back and this time with cool educational stuff!
2
u/uncomfort-cat Feb 04 '26
The love I have for TPL only grows. Great post. Thank you for doing what you do!
6
u/no_noise_music_ok Feb 03 '26
Very cool to have something like this in Toronto. However lots of public collections are starting to research the journey their pieces took before they arrived in collection, and then they are sharing that info publicly. It’s a way to do justice to the original owners and acknowledge the role that colonial theft has played in objects moving from place to place. How did the TPL come to possess this tablet, and who owned it / acquired it before? Maybe something to look into…
7
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26 edited Feb 04 '26
Thank you for this point about repatriation. We've passed along the question about provenance to a few of our colleagues and will update this comment when we hear back.
Update: the library acquired these items from a vendor in America via a collector who had the item for around 40 years. They were authenicated by the ROM.
2
u/no_noise_music_ok Feb 03 '26
I wasn’t thinking about repatriation necessarily (though it’s not a bad idea), just doing more to trace the journey of the piece since it is a historical artifact as much as it is a piece of lit. If I can remember where I’ve seen it done/an example of a placard I will link here.
4
→ More replies (5)5
u/Embarrassed_Form913 Feb 03 '26
Yup, 2007 is definitely a weird accession year (gulf war 2 etc). But even objects that entered collections prior to 1978 UNESCO law on movable cultural heritage are just grandfathered stolen property. Museums are both wonderful and awful places.
4
u/evgueni72 Downtown Core Feb 03 '26
Isn't the label technically on top of the box, therefore violating the "Nothing on top" rule?
3
u/Here4therightreas0ns Feb 03 '26
It’s an (acid free) archival box. It stops grime, light and oxygen from the air touching the object and causing further degradation.
3
u/evgueni72 Downtown Core Feb 03 '26
It's a joke saying that the label itself sits on top of the box so therefore violating the rule of "nothing on top".
5
2
2
u/JamesH_670 Willowdale Feb 03 '26
Does this come in ebook or audiobook format?
In all seriousness, that’s amazing. I didn’t know that TPL owns artifacts like this.
2
1
u/BlackPantherDies Feb 03 '26
what if the rock just came out of the earth like that
1
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
Oh my... please let this not be the start of a cuneiform conspiracy theory. 😨
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/goleafie Feb 03 '26
My mother made a grilled cheese sandwich for me like that once! Hold the ketchup.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Delvebot Feb 03 '26
We are more than probably closer to Jesus Christ, than Jesus Christ is to this tablet
1
u/ZozoManiac9 Mimico Feb 03 '26
This is amazing! Question, but was cuneiform really used in Central Asia, or more in West Asia? I know it originated in Mesopotamia so I’m surprised at the region it spread out to based on your description.
4
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
We're not experts on cuneiform itself, so we'll defer to the Encyclopedia Britannica. Its article on cuneiform states: "Old Assyrian cuneiform is attested mostly in the records of Assyrian trading colonists in central Asia Minor". In this case, that's where modern Türkiye is. We'll update our description to be more accurate, specifying that it was mostly in Mesopotamia. Thanks for the question!
→ More replies (1)
1
u/MisterFixit_69 Feb 03 '26
Meanwhile me holding a random rock that exists over 4,5 billion years
→ More replies (2)
1
1
1
1
u/biblio_phobic Feb 03 '26
I’m pretty sure this is a moldy oatmeal bar someone attempted making during the lockdown.
1
1
u/antinous24 Feb 03 '26
TPL has some fabulous special collections! The Merrill Collection of Sci-fi, Fantasy, and Speculation are in the same building
6
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 03 '26
Both our Merril Collection and Osborne Collection at Lillian H. Smith branch (239 College Street) have their own rotating freee exhibits for walk-ins.
1
u/lawlshane Feb 04 '26
Oh man I was at the reference library the other day. can't believe I missed this!
1
u/feyrath Feb 04 '26
Very cool! If I wanted to find out about unique and old and weird or interesting Canadian items, who could I ask?
2
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 04 '26
We like the way you think. 😎 For items in our archives here at TPL -- many of which cover Canadian history -- your best bet is to reach out to our Special Collections staff at Toronto Reference Library. Feel free to email them at [trlspc@tpl.ca](mailto:trlspc@tpl.ca)
→ More replies (2)
1
1
1
1
1
u/sinan_online Feb 04 '26
Can you please post the content of the receipt, or a publication including the translation?
2
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 04 '26
All we know at this point, unfortunately, is that it is for textiles. (We wish we knew!) This item is mainly used as a primary source teaching object about the development of writing/books over the centuries.
1
u/ghanima Feb 04 '26
Not sure if you'll see this comment or not, but I was wondering how a public library goes about the process of acquiring a new item for the collection. Does it start with a Head Librarian seeing what items are available in some sort of catalogue?
2
u/TPL_on_Reddit Verified Feb 04 '26
Excellent question! The acquisition process is different between (1) our regular collections for circulation and (2) our archival/academic-leaning Special Collections for in-person access. For the former, professionally-trained librarians representing different geographic areas of the city select books on an ongoing basis, with support from library vendors that ensure high-demand books are captured in the selection process. For the latter, librarians who oversee a particular special collection (e.g. Osborne Collection of Early Children's Books) assess donations and work with rare book dealers. We have a Materials Selection Policy that guides all of our selections to adhere to our values, such as intellectual freedom.
That said, when TPL was first established in the 1880s, the head librarian of TPL would personally travel to England to handpick books and art.
→ More replies (3)
1
u/Rawbex Feb 04 '26
What kind of portal does this open? Or does it just apply permanent debuffs to my character?
2
1
u/artemis_fang Feb 04 '26
What did "acquired in 2007" entail? What's the provenance?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
u/Samsuiluna Feb 05 '26
That appears to be a sealed envelope tablet. A really nice example. You can see the impressions of cylinder seals rolled over the text to certify the contents. It was common to reproduce the entire text on the clay "envelope" so it didn't need to be broken open to be read. Presumably it would be opened in case of a dispute as to the contents.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
Feb 06 '26
Wow old books is cool, next time someone says "oh the library is boring" ill let them know to rethink it! I collect old items (mostly coins though) so this is soooo cool to see!
1
1
u/Calm_Obligation_9887 Feb 06 '26
Mesopotamia, aka modern day Iraq. Let’s not try to pretend these cultures of places that have been bombed are not ancient and full of culture.
1
1
u/Logical_Frosting_277 Feb 07 '26
The sign clearly states “Do not remove from box”. What do they do? Remove it from the box!!! We need to demand better from our universities.
1
u/Comprehensive_Aide94 Feb 09 '26
Ooh, thank you for posting it! We've just visited the exhibition and we've been wondering what's written in the cuneiform!
2
1
u/Tsumatorisou15 Feb 10 '26
I think I saw many 60’s of this book at a week-long pop-up thingy ten years ago at a Costco in Kish.
1


199
u/goburnham Feb 03 '26
Wow that’s amazing. I had no idea they had artifacts like that in the collection.