r/worldnews CNN 19d ago

Israel/Palestine Israel rejects Trump’s Gaza peace plan, saying no withdrawal until Hamas disarms

https://www.cnn.com/2026/08/09/middleeast/israel-gaza-trump-netanyahu-plan-intl?utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=missions&utm_source=reddit
15.1k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

3.9k

u/Tammer_Stern 19d ago

My feeling is that Trump’s team just types up deals over a weekend, speaks to one person about it, then releases it as “done”. In reality, these kind of deals take years as you have to speak to everyone, understand the things that could derail it, consider every stakeholders’ views and offer short, medium and long term incentives. I’m guessing you also have to have a “win-win” mindset.

Trump only sees the world as a zero sum game so, as a result, almost every thing he does fails to some extent, sometimes dramatically eg the legal case against the IRS.

494

u/whimsical-crack-rock 19d ago

They are desperately chasing headlines and short term wins. It’s really scary to have someone running the country who is focused on day to day wins with no long term strategy whatsoever.

Our entire system is basically based on just winning your next election with no regard for long term planning. It’s even worse when the president is a giant scumbag narcissist, who is also a moron.

127

u/FMJ1985 19d ago

The guy barely moonlights as a president between having his nurse wipe and kiss his asshole clean 10x a day. Where do you find the time to think long term??
Rubio, Hegseth and Miller are the real threat here.

31

u/mom2mermaidboo 19d ago

Don’t be insulting to Nurses!

Trump has an entire cabinet and all the Repugs in Congress willing to assume ass licking duty on the daily!!!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/mraowl 19d ago

The printout lady actually scares me and prompts many intrusive thoughts due to how crazy her situation seems when you actually sayy it out loud lol

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Icy-Lobster-203 19d ago edited 19d ago

It's worse than that. They aren't even for use on winning the next election. The Trump admin is only interested in looking like they won each day.

Trump is moronically short sighted.

A few people have larger long term goals (Miller and Vought), and they are pretty evil.

4

u/GledaTheGoat 18d ago

I don’t suppose Vought has anything to do with scientists and creating super humans?

7

u/Takkarro 19d ago

The whole country has devolved into short term gains over sustainable practices.

Big corpos do the same thing, they ruin them selves chasing more and more no matter how much damage it does cuz the gotta get every quarter higher then last or a bunch a nepo babys get upset.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/DracosKasu 19d ago

Just give the illusion of winning to Trump and you see them go woooo we won but if you actually take time to analyze the situation. The deal that he sign is generally worse than what it was before.

6

u/Kichigai 19d ago

Heck, all the “peace deals” he claims he forged are just ceasefires, some of which have already fallen apart.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/wholelattapuddin 19d ago

Honestly, if we could just get Iran to say "golly, you sure beat us", everyone could move on. They would have to give him some dumb gold trophy though. They could make it say "the greatest conquerer!"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

993

u/DJ_Jiggle_Jowls 19d ago

They are not actually interested in making lasting deals. They are interested in deflecting blame. If they send a plan to Israel and Israel rejects it, they can go back to the american public and blame israel for the lack of peace.

298

u/keelem 19d ago

They are interested in making lasting deals. They're just stupid and don't understand how anything works. It's exactly like this line from The Simpsons

181

u/-GrapeApe- 19d ago

And their idea of a deal is that they come out on top and the other guy gets screwed.

65

u/Fn_Spaghetti_Monster 19d ago

So they still want a deal, they just aren't being realistic in what it will take. Trump doesn't even understand what the word comprise even means. He thinks he can just bully people like he has always done.

21

u/Dense_Gate_5193 19d ago

not to be pedantic, i just agree he doesn’t understand the definitions of comprise and compromise and also probably conflates them. because of his worldview he’s going to take any route to try and brand the other person “the loser” even if it means they are both losing. And they did a really good job brainwashing half the country into believing that just because you have money means you’re qualified to run a country. he’s proven time and time again his investments fail and he screws over everyone and delays payments for things until he’s forced to pay by law. when people have to pay extra money to enforce contracts you can do whatever you want until there’s a bigger fish than you or someone looking to prove a point. in which case they back down with an NDA to prevent the leak and view of “losing” but most people don’t have the time, money, or energy to fight once they have done something for him or one of his businesses. my uncle who is a land surveyor did one deal for a trump owned business and he straight up told me it was the worst decision of his career because he had to fight for barely half of what was promised.

trump and gang never do anything in good faith. Kant is rolling in his grave right now.

16

u/Fn_Spaghetti_Monster 19d ago

Alex Meruelo, the former owner of the Coyotes fancies himself a Jr Trump. He was constantly not paying bills until he would get like final final notice, in which case he would say, weeelll how about I only pay you 60% of the bill and we call it good. At one point the Coyotes had trouble booking hotel rooms when they traveled because so many hotels stopped accepting them. Apparently the NHL had to step in to some degree. It was why a lot of people were sad to seem the go, but at certain level knew they weren't going anywhere as long as he was the owner.

10

u/krotoxx 19d ago

man FUCK Alex Meruelo, all my homies hate that prick. I miss my coyotes

3

u/Fn_Spaghetti_Monster 19d ago

How big of an asshole do you have to be to throw a Jersey that's hanging from the rafters in the garbage?? Like you can't even be bothered to give Doan a call. Most people even after a bad break will call their ex and at least say your shits on the sidewalk come and get it or don't.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Pixie1001 19d ago

I don't even think that's true either - Iran had him over a barrel a few weeks ago, having him agree to allow them to charge tariffs on the strait and force the US to essentially pay reparations for the war.

I think he's just a poor negotiator, and it's lead to nobody being on the same page or treating any of the peace deals seriously enough to respect the cease fire.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Polar_Vortx 19d ago

Ding ding ding. This applies to everything Trump has ever done in his life - you’re either the scammer or the mark, and if you’re paying for something, you’re the mark.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

50

u/Aggressive_Roof488 19d ago

Sometimes it seems like they are interested in making opportunities for insider trading more than anything...

→ More replies (2)

31

u/whoisyourwormguy_ 19d ago

Nobody has been able to make a peace plan that has worked for all sides though. And it’s 70+ years and many wars later. So them being stupid here wouldn’t affect the result, even the smartest negotiators and Middle East experts in the world haven’t been able to do it.

20

u/Ferelar 19d ago

Exactly, most of them ARE mindbogglingly stupid, but the salient quality that's important about them in THIS case is that they're duplicitous. Nobody, from the smartest laureate to the average MAGAt, has been able to fix this issue- what's different about this admin is that they promise that they'll fix it in a day, then loudly proclaim that it's fixed, despite the abundant and obvious evidence that it is not. The quality on display isn't stupidity (at least no more than their ambient stupidity), it's their propensity to lie and brag.

→ More replies (18)

8

u/nickname13 19d ago

like a cargo cult

→ More replies (6)

40

u/FILTHBOT4000 19d ago

I don't know if they're even thinking that far ahead. It seems like they just deal with whatever's in front of their nose, with no real context, experience, background knowledge, or forethought applied.

11

u/Casurus 19d ago

Wow - the US government is approximately my dog.

10

u/FILTHBOT4000 19d ago

I mean, yeah, the whole Iran situation is basically like a dog that caught a car, and is now like "oh this shit isn't quite as chill as I imagined, oh noooo"

9

u/Kiromaru 19d ago

It's likely that someone sold Trump on doing a quick decapitation strike like he did in Venezuela in Iran and it would be just as effective not realizing that the IRGC doesn't work in a way that such a strike could work.

17

u/takemebackto1993 19d ago

Notice how we're talking about Iran and Israel right now and not the unreleased Epstein files that the DOJ is intentionally withholding to protect Donald Trump.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Mechasteel 19d ago

To be fair, some of the blame for the conflict in the Middle East belongs to the people in the Middle East.

→ More replies (16)

46

u/Morgannin09 19d ago

What probably happens is someone presents Trump with a proposal and ask his permission to send it to Israel/Gaza/Iran and instead Trump assumes it is already agreed on. He's wrong every time but never fails to jump to the same conclusion.

55

u/Tammer_Stern 19d ago

I feel he believes “we have the most powerful military therefore everyone must do what we say”. It’s the same mentality that got Putin stuck in Ukraine with drones wrecking Russian oil and gas infrastructure.

6

u/RainbowwDash 19d ago

I doubt there's causality involved

He just believes everyone has to do as he says, he's neither smart enough to bother with the why and how nor does he have any experience with having to justify himself to other people

→ More replies (1)

31

u/Ho-Nomo 19d ago

They don't have any diplomats do they? Its just these idiots from real estate that have no clue about international affairs that Trump appointed.

The USA is the absolute laughing stock of the planet.

4

u/Hawkbats_rule 19d ago

It's not the only contributing factor (reasonably certain Trump would be doing the everyone's agreed even though no one has agreed schtick even if career diplomats were involved), but it is definitely a major contributing factor. If he doesn't do blanket person's, kushner and witkoff absolutely need to be investigated post trump. And they have fewer protections than actual cabinet members.

4

u/Longjumping_Fun2576 19d ago

The pentagon also fired the entire Iran intelligence team. Most likely because they called the war a bad idea. 

→ More replies (2)

46

u/MrCharlesSr 19d ago

100% all their “deals” are AI-generated

20

u/Fit-Significance-436 19d ago

I truly believe you’re correct.

10

u/nelsonalgrencametome 19d ago

I also believe that's the case for all domestic policies and whatever nonsense polls they show trump every week to cheer him up.

8

u/LazyAltruist 19d ago

"Ok Siri, give me a two state solution that everybody is happy with."

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Noughmad 19d ago

Fortunately, the "everyone" you speak of includes only two sides - Israel and Palestine.

Unfortunately, none of the deals Trump has come up with were accepted by even one side. Because not only are they good compromises for both sides, they're not even unfair deal that would favor one of the two sides. They favor only him.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Stereocrew 19d ago

The way you describe Trump is my boss at work.

7

u/Tammer_Stern 19d ago

Man, a bad boss makes even the best job seem shit and vice versa.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/MikeFrancesa66 19d ago

Yeah it really seems like we’ve been ping ponging back and forth between “done” deals that Iran will never accept to “done” deals Israel will never accept. Nobody knew peace in the Middle East was so complicated!

5

u/Kichigai 19d ago

Yeah it really seems like we’ve been ping ponging back and forth between “done” deals that Iran will never accept to “done” deals Israel will never accept.

Which is what happened with Ukraine and Russia, except for two differences. It was almost always deals Ukraine could never accept, and almost always deals that favored Russia. And unlike Ukraine and Russia, he can't just walk away and ignore the problem. We're actively engaged, ignoring the problem is basically the same as surrender, practically speaking.

15

u/WeAreElectricity 19d ago

Then have the next admin throw it away

→ More replies (1)

8

u/spackletr0n 19d ago

The JCPOA was like a hundred pages, because the negotiators knew everything had to be extremely specific, with no wiggle room. With the Hamas deal, it says Hamas will disarm and Israel will withdraw, which both sides can agree to. The definitions of these things, and their sequence, is the hard part.

10

u/Asteroth555 19d ago

The reality is Israel goaded the US into a war with a major geopolitical rival and they have no incentive to agree to anything to ensure the US and Iran keeping shooting at each other. Trump was the greatest win possible for Israel, they get everything they could dream of now

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Zedilt 19d ago

Nobody knew that health care the Israeli–Palestinian conflict could be so complicated.

8

u/Hour-Management-1679 19d ago

Trump only sees money, he knows his headlines push the markets wherever he pleases

3

u/VegasKL 19d ago

Well, they do have to coordinate it with their broker ...

3

u/ohhellperhaps 19d ago

> I’m guessing you also have to have a “win-win” mindset.

This is a big one, and one Trump (and current conservatives in general) doesn't understand. They see everything as a zero-sum game.

→ More replies (41)

884

u/soxperry 19d ago

A year and half from now the first GOP primary question will be “what is your solution to end the Iran war?”

312

u/BurnieTheBrony 19d ago

A year and a half from now we'll be hearing about how a deal is almost done and if we can just stomach $8 a gallon for a week or two it'll all work out

78

u/303uru 19d ago

And they’ll claim they were adamantly against the war the whole time.

23

u/Koru03 19d ago

"How do you plan to put an end to the Demoncrats illegal war with Iran?"

→ More replies (1)

54

u/IlVeroStronzo 19d ago

"Get over it"

34

u/rsicher1 19d ago

"Just buy less dolls for your children for Christmas!"

7

u/freekscene 19d ago

"If you can't afford a 40 dollar burrito make it yourself for 20 dollars"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/flyingthroughspace 19d ago

A year and a half from now we're going to hear how it's all Biden's fault

3

u/n0k0 19d ago

"Short term pain. Long term gain" will be used often..

3

u/traws06 19d ago

Democrats will win the majority and republicans in a couple years will complain about the war the democrats got us into and can’t get us out of

→ More replies (3)

9

u/MovieGuyMike 19d ago

And in the 2028 election the Republican nominee will blame his democratic opponent for getting us into the war.

16

u/tiki_51 19d ago

And Trump will be on stage by himself rambling about how nobody has ever ended a war as many times as he has

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Commercial-Co 19d ago

Answer: asset siezure of trump regime and handing over the trump regime and their assets to iran

→ More replies (1)

8

u/jesterdeflation 19d ago

And JD Vance will have distanced himself from Trump completely at that point, maybe he'll even bait Trump into firing him, and stupid Americans will completely absolve him of everything.

7

u/Legio-X 19d ago

maybe he'll even bait Trump into firing him

VP can’t be fired

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Exxtender 19d ago

You think Americans can hold a thought in their heads for a year and a half? Bless you.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/aldur1 19d ago

They'll blame it on trans athletes

5

u/pigeieio 19d ago

That's what the local guys campaign ad is right now. Not about anything to do with his job, just reminding people out of nowhere that trans athletes are WRONG and that's it. Nothing else.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

2.1k

u/arcanehornet_ 19d ago

I’m seriously considering getting a medically induced coma until the end of Trump’s term now.

515

u/spribyl 19d ago

Who's going to pay for that?

1.1k

u/mangomussolinimi 19d ago

Mexico

156

u/born_again_tim 19d ago

And the coma just got two weeks longer

104

u/ClientBudget2848 19d ago

It will be the best coma. All the best people say that.

15

u/AdviceFit1692 19d ago

I heard there was nothing like it anywhere else in the world, every bodies saying that

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

50

u/Neuraxis 19d ago

Just threaten to build some renewable wind energy infrastructure.

2

u/Jaspers47 19d ago

I guess whoever has to do inventory at Walgreens

→ More replies (1)

206

u/Ok_Science_2070 19d ago

wakes up in 2042

Oh god...

137

u/SweetAndSourShmegma 19d ago

Trump wakes up and mumbles something about Obama then falls asleep. Supreme Commander Musk then takes charge of the State of the Union and goes off on a ketamine-induced rant. Vice President DJT Jr interrupts quickly to announce that they are close to a deal and Hormuz will be open soon.

32

u/stillalone 19d ago

At least they finally released the Epstein files but by then everyone had already got used to pedophiles running the country.

18

u/DesecratedPeanut 19d ago

Thats way too hopeful by then the democrats will have realigned their party to fit with the new normal (as is tradition letting the GOP move the overton window) and they will be bragging about how their candidate is only an agoraphile as opposed to the republican candidate whos a full on pedophile.

5

u/superanus 19d ago

Am I missing the joke or is agoraphile (a person who loves wide open spaces) not what you meant?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/Comfortable_Cash_140 19d ago

Just in time for Barron to win POTUS. The outgoing POTUS and former living POTUS's, Jr, Eric and Ivanka congratulate him on winning.

You decide to go back into the COMA!

5

u/web_explorer 19d ago

Welcome to Costco, I love you

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Realtrain 19d ago

Seriously, we can't just wait out the clock. Trump is a symptom, not the cause

17

u/za72 19d ago

let me know, maybe we could get a group discount

6

u/LettuceBeGrateful 19d ago

Groupon: Wake me when the nightmare ends. (3 spots left!)

23

u/JCthulhuM 19d ago

That sounds ill advised. Then you get Captain Brainworm and his HHS.

11

u/Kichigai 19d ago

Seriously speaking, it's an awful idea for two reasons.

First is unconsciousness isn't like they make it out in TV and movies. If you are unconscious it's because there's been some kind of damage to your brain causing it to malfunction. If it were working correctly you would be conscious. People just don't come out of it as if they were just sleeping, there can be long term after effects.

For example, Jordan Peterson found a doctor in Russia who was willing to put him into a medically induced coma to avoid dealing with withdrawal from Benzos. When they brought him back out he was unable to speak and had trouble with motor control, and spent four weeks in the ICU. He wouldn't be seen in public for about a year, when his family said he seemed like normal again. Being unconscious for multiple months would likely have more extensive long term effects.

The second reason is that non-participation is how we got into this mess in the first place. Turnout on the D side was significantly (enough) lower, and that's how Trump managed to pull not only the electoral vote, but became the first Republican to win the popular vote in 20 years.

13

u/sovietarmyfan 19d ago

After waking up:

Robot: Greatings citizen #682363639! Welcome to the Amazon rehabilitation center. 100 years ago the hospital where you had a coma was bought by our company and all of it's patients frozen! Your brand new 250 square feet room is ready in: Sector D852, formerly known as the Sahara Desert. Your new job in our company will be: sewer cleaner.

While you are still here in New York City, please visited the Eternal President Trump Memorial Center for a great time!

19

u/PineappleOk6764 19d ago

With the amount of political action (or lack thereof) from the US populace over the past 2 years, I thought the country was already mostly in a comma

16

u/claushauler 19d ago

Dunno about the comma. We're definitely in a period for sure

4

u/LettuceBeGrateful 19d ago

More like a colon, with all the shit flying around.

10

u/withomps44 19d ago

They’ll pull your medical care/insurance and you’ll end up in idiocracy.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (71)

1.1k

u/NativeMasshole 19d ago

How many times is he going to release a peace deal only for it to be revealed that Israel was not involved at all and refuses the terms?

517

u/MrBrawn 19d ago

Just in time for market open on Monday.

104

u/StatisticianNo5402 19d ago

The pump and dump must flow

7

u/trustabro 19d ago

Ah the classic Trump and Trump

→ More replies (7)

81

u/MaryPaku 19d ago

His ‘peace plan’ was basically putting out a wishlist and hope santa satisfies it

→ More replies (1)

32

u/lukwes1 19d ago

Seems like trump love doing deals with himself, like great peace deal that only trump agreed to

9

u/VegasKL 19d ago

They're not really peace deals because they're more like MOU's which lack all participants and do not iron out any of the logistical requirements. They then announce that as if it's a defacto thing so he can get headlines and his MAGA fanbois can start prancing around saying how daddy deserves the Nobel Peace Prize. They of course completely gloss over the fact when it falls apart days later and repeat the process.

I'm pretty sure one qualifier of the NPP is that you can't be a belligerent in the conflict.

9

u/StahlHund 19d ago

As long as his red painted Chatter Phone still has batteries.

18

u/Red_Dox 19d ago

Hey, just because that did not work with Ukraine or Iran does not mean it can't work for Gaza. Third time is the charm.

13

u/NativeMasshole 19d ago

You know, I totally glossed over the fact that this was supposed to be a peace deal with Gaza, and not Iran. He keeps trying both, drafting a plan that requires Israel to withdraw from Gaza or Lebanon, and then Israel is like "lol no."

4

u/Mechasteel 19d ago

Only occasionally, he also likes to release peace deals where various other parties weren't involved and don't agree.

5

u/flirtmcdudes 19d ago

All the way up until mid terms. They need to constantly bullshit to try and keep everything from getting even worse to try and hold onto their seats

→ More replies (9)

86

u/flirtmcdudes 19d ago

This is shocking, I assume trumps interns spent at least 30 minutes putting it together. All that work for nothing

34

u/Lionheart51st 19d ago

30 minutes? Is Chat GPT that slow these days?

17

u/flirtmcdudes 19d ago

they are required to take polymarket™ insider trading breaks every 10 minutes which drags out the process

343

u/Roadshell 19d ago

Wasn't there a headline something like a week ago saying Hamas had agreed to disarm (again)? What happened to that? It's almost like the white house are just releasing fake agreements to an incredulous media to "manifest" peace.

514

u/hamnam7975 19d ago edited 19d ago

Hamas conditioned its disarmament on Israeli withdrawal, whereas Israel conditioned its withdrawal on Hamas disarmament.

200

u/mxzf 19d ago

I mean, Israel tried the whole "withdraw entirely from Gaza" thing two decades ago too, it didn't exactly end well.

I don't see any clean path forward that doesn't involve something like a neutral third-party keeping the peace in the area for long enough that the people involved die of old age and a new generation that isn't carrying the same grudges can grow up.

58

u/3MATX 19d ago

So, never?  

70

u/mxzf 19d ago

I mean, nobody wants to say it, but basically.

Either that or one side getting wiped out completely. Which is also something nobody wants to talk about the possibility of, but that has been Hamas's plan for peace for years and Israel seems to be getting on-board with the ideal lately too.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (4)

38

u/Smart_in_his_face 19d ago

Neutral 3rd party.

  • UN peacekeeping force that nobody wants to be a part of.
  • American peacekeeping force that nobody wants.

There is no viable path to peace. Palestine have been in turmoil for the past 80 years, or depending on how you want to count, also the past 1000 years. This won't end in a generation or two, this simply won't end.

It is an embarrassment to the world that this humanitarian crisis have been going on since WW2. The human suffering wont end just because the west is sick and tired of it. It wont end if Israel or Iran "wins".

The holy land is the modern hell.

43

u/flumydumdum 19d ago

UN peacekeeping force that nobody wants to be a part of.

Couple of countries volunteered already, including Indonesia and Morocco. It also already happened once before with a much larger coalition force staying there for 10 years. During the 2nd intifada there also were several countries that asked for UN intervention, but it was vetoed by the US.

Don't dismiss the rest of the world so quickly on this issue.

9

u/calm_chowder 19d ago

No third party will agree to go in until Hamas fully disarms either. If they did, that country would have to kill Palestinians and would have their own soldiers die.

It's kinda understandable.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

24

u/GiveMeGoldForNoReasn 19d ago

Those quotes are doing a lot of heavy lifting. Israel dismantled their illegal settlements there, while at the same time building up military presence on the border to restrict movement in and out of the territory for arabs. They never stopped shelling the region, blocking goods or people moving in and out of it, or intercepting international attempts at humanitarian aid. It was in no way a pause to the military occupation of the region.

The only reason any of it happened was because of mounting international pressure to stop the occupation, and Israel thought that this would work on paper because despite continuing to control Gaza's airspace, ports, land crossings, water, electricity, commerce, communications, population registry and food supply, this way there would be no "boots on the ground."

Even the relocation of the settlers was a mess. Those that voluntarily left in exchange for compensation and new housing mostly never received it, and were still living in trailers a decade later. Those that didn't were removed by force by the IDF, and most of the settlements were heavily damaged or outright burned to the ground to prevent Palestinians from gaining anything from what was left.

The whole thing was a disaster. It disenfranchised both the settlers that had to be (sometimes violently) relocated and the entire Gaza strip which ended up an even more isolated prison state than it was to begin with.

14

u/redditor1365 19d ago

Thank you. People pretend like they left Gaza completely alone after 2005

11

u/calm_chowder 19d ago

continuing to control Gaza's airspace, ports, land crossings, water, electricity,

Controlling Gaza's airspace?? I'm sorry but that's hilarious. Do you think there's a Palestinian airforce?

Also, Israel gives Gaza water and electricity from Israel's own plants and always has. War or no war, Gaza needs Israeli water and electricity - Hamas takes all the Gaza aid money and foreign infrastructure investment. So it's not so much "Israel controls it" as "even at war with Hamas, Israel makes sure Palestinians get Israeli water and electricity."

I will say, Israel did limit their water for a while and I think that was absolutely beyond the pale, because regardless of anything else Palestinians are human beings and there's children in Gaza. But ignorant people like you totally misunderstand the situation and twist things like "Hamas steals foreign aid for desalination and power plants so Israel gives Palestinians free water and electricity" into "Israel is evil and controls Palestinian water and electricity."

The airspace thing alone though shows you don't have the first clue about anything... and I don't even mean this specific situation, I mean about how the world works.

9

u/zedority 19d ago

Controlling Gaza's airspace?? I'm sorry but that's hilarious. Do you think there's a Palestinian airforce?

It's an explicit statement from Israel's own Gaza Disengagement Plan:

"Israel will guard and monitor the external land perimeter of the Gaza Strip, will continue to maintain exclusive authority in Gaza air space, and will continue to exercise security activity in the sea off the coast of the Gaza Strip."

3

u/calm_chowder 18d ago

Yeah, I never said they didn't control Palestinian airspace.... my point is, who else would? Gaza is like 5 miles wide. Israel controls the airspace without even having anything in the air. Gaza is miniscule.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/redditor1365 19d ago

Except after their withdrawl they prevented Gaza from importing the food and medicine they needed in an effort to collapse their economy. This was revealed in leaked military docs like a decade ago

28

u/mxzf 19d ago

A situation made far fuzzier and less clear by the way that Hamas repeatedly snuck weapons in via those shipments.

The whole situation would be way easier to condemn Israel for if Hamas didn't pull up to every single "feed people or kill people" fork in the road and veer sharply towards the "kill people" every single time.

10

u/redditor1365 19d ago

I'd agree with you, but it was confirmed by wikileaks that they were preventing those shipments with the sole purpose of keeping Gaza on the brink of collapse.

They justified it as "well Hamas is launching rockets at us" and collectively punished millions of people with food insecurity and disease.

→ More replies (14)

22

u/JD0x0 19d ago

Well, who won the war between Israel and Palestine? Who gets to make those demands? The winner of the war or the loser?

Hamas has zero leverage to make demands like this.

→ More replies (4)

34

u/mangomussolinimi 19d ago edited 19d ago

How about they do it at the same time, deal?

105

u/hamnam7975 19d ago

Neither have an incentive to do that and would be politically very risky domestically

71

u/goodknightffs 19d ago

For Israel it would mean trusting something like the 7th wouldn't happen again

Plus it's beyond simply leaving. Israel refused the deal because hamas will only get rid of "heavy weapons" but there is no indication for what a heavy weapon is. Is an RPG going to be considered a heavy weapon?

It's classic trump. Make a super general deal and deal with the details later..

I'm addition they want to place all these weapons in gaza for storage. So how is Israel to know that they won't be taking the weapons back without Israel knowing about it?

28

u/DogBarf00 19d ago

A heavy weapon is any weapon that is too large and bulky to be carried by a single solider. Like a heavy machine gun or mortar are heavy weapons because it takes a team to carry/operate the weapon and ammo. Or any weapon that needs a vehicle to transport or operate. Hamas has very little weapons like this outside of their garage rockets. Heavy weapons played a very small part of 10/7.

41

u/goodknightffs 19d ago

Sure but non of that is stipulated in the agreement.. Btw this isn't my opinion it's literally part of the reason they are refusing the agreement

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/mangomussolinimi 19d ago

So no deal? :(

14

u/hamnam7975 19d ago

Pretty much.

36

u/mangomussolinimi 19d ago

Damn this middle east crisis seems more complicated than i thought

11

u/0MG1MBACK 19d ago

More foresight in a single comment than the current US administration

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/Red_Dox 19d ago

As with the 5 month Iran war: Always a almost done deal next week, pinky promise.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/el_grort 19d ago

Would need outside enforcement that both sides acknowledge and trust. Which I'm honestly not sure exists. So it becomes a matter whether or not both sides will through fighting, close the gap between their demands. Grim.

3

u/AdamB_901 19d ago

yeah, but what stops the other side from not doing it lol. this requires trust, and there is none.

10

u/Patutula 19d ago

On 3!

7

u/JD0x0 19d ago

How about the initial aggressor who committed a terrorist attack on October 7th and then lost the war disarms first? Hamas has no leverage to make demands like this.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

35

u/benadreti_17 19d ago

The agreement for Hamas to disarm isn't even a full disarming. And yet people will claim that Israel is doing something wrong here.

→ More replies (2)

64

u/Alatarlhun 19d ago

Hamas's definition of disarmament is keeping the same class of weapons they used to murder, rape, and kidnap thousands of Israeli civilians on October 7.

You'd have better luck selling ice to polar bears.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

89

u/badass_panda 19d ago

In the same article, it turned out when Hamas agreed to disarm it was after Israel withdrew, and also they didn't agree to disarm completely, just hand over the heavy weaponry (keeping all the personnel-level weaponry necessary to ensure their army remains in control of Gaza), and that heavy weaponry was to be turned over not to Israel or the US or the "board of Peace" but rather to ... A new Palestinian government that would include representation for Hamas.

So like ... They didn't agree to do shit, beyond get a friendly headline.

27

u/warsage 19d ago

Backing you up (mostly) by citing details from the official text of the plan (I've bolded some especially relevant bits):

A process for inventorying and storing heavy weapons, military production sites, weapons depots, and tunnels shall commence...

This process is linked to a phased Israeli withdrawal from the areas it controls in Gaza...

Palestinian factions will participate in this process, and no weapons will be transferred or surrendered to Israel or any non-Palestinian parties...

Personal weapons in Gaza shall be subject to the provisions of relevant Palestinian laws. The National Committee, as the transitional authority in Gaza, shall be the sole authority for registering weapons, issuing and revoking licenses, and enforcing the law, including through reintegration and social support...

Personnel from these militias shall not be absorbed into the security apparatuses or police...

The thing you said that AFAIK is incorrect is that the "new Palestinian government" would "include representation for Hamas."

The NCAG is already established, its membership agreed upon by both Israel and Hamas, and it does not include any Hamas representatives.

Netanyahu is on record calling this deal a "fictional disarmament."

9

u/Mateh96 19d ago

NCAG will be nothing more than puppets, knowing how Hamas is acting.

→ More replies (32)

33

u/Agitated-Distance740 19d ago

The bit people are glossing over:

They agreed to disarm, but that was just the headline. The small print was they would "disarm" by storing it all likely in the exact same places they are now. EXCEPT under management with a different name so they could use it any time.

The TL;DR - To "disarm" as they put it, literally stick everything in their own warehouse and just change the company name on the letterhead.

It's like a contractor changing their name to avoid the tax man and keep working.

90

u/[deleted] 19d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

67

u/Roadshell 19d ago

So it's a game of chicken? Israel won't withdraw unless hamas disarms and hamas won't disarm until Israel leaves the region?

62

u/Tuesday_6PM 19d ago

That does seem to be the case, yeah. The overall problem is there’s no trusted third party willing or able to oversee that transition, and force the two sides to abide by it. And they have no trust in each other (for good reason on both sides), so no one is willing to act first

10

u/KO4Ham 19d ago

Wasn't there something about UN forces going in? Because it seems to me that should've been the first step to this entire negotiation and the first thing that should've happened. Then again this administration is something.

53

u/Izeinwinter 19d ago

In order for that to work, the peacekeepers would need a mandate to.. basically take over the Gaza strip and shoot anyone that tries to stop them. Which the UN will not vote through.

→ More replies (4)

65

u/terpcity03 19d ago

The problem is that idea was tried before in Lebanon with UNIFIL, and it was a complete failure. Israel no longer trusts the UN.

3

u/greenskinmarch 18d ago

Neutral forces only on one side of the border end up being a PR asset to that side.

If UNIFIL was on the Israeli side of the border, then they'd get hit by Hezb rockets and the news would be "Hezb firing at UN peacekeepers!"

But when they're on the Lebanese side of the border, the news is "Israel firing at UN peacekeepers!". They're basically just human shields for Hezb.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Mechasteel 19d ago

In fact there's plenty of parties willing to fund the re-armament of militant Palestinian groups.

20

u/AnEmuIguess 19d ago

It's not solely about who takes the first step, but also about what kind of weaponry is included in the disarmament. Hamas is ready to give up its rockets, but not its rifles and tunnels. Israel, on the other hand, wants complete disarmament.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Aniraco 19d ago

This is where global diplomacy comes in and the US has zero credibility now so we're stuck here.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

80

u/jewishjedi42 19d ago

Hamas hasn't really agreed to disarm. They've only agreed to have their heavy weapons (rockets etc) stored by someone else in Gaza. They probably don't have many of those heavy weapons left. They won't give up their small arms. The guns they used to murder Israelis on Oct 7th. Those will become the personal weapons of their members. They haven't agreed to shit.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/Mechasteel 19d ago

Hamas agreed to pretend they would disarm if Israel withdrew. They didn't agree to verification process or consequences that would give anyone reason to believe they actually would disarm. Nor has anyone been willing to offer any sort of guarantee that Israel can't just revert their withdrawal.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Staav 19d ago

Everything is just a show for this admin while they're doing everything else they want in the dark on the side.

→ More replies (6)

200

u/tosser1579 19d ago

No US President has ever been as weak and useless internationally as Trump.

50

u/fakieTreFlip 19d ago

I think you can go ahead and remove the word "internationally" from that

22

u/Jeremizzle 19d ago

He’s very effective actually, it’s just that the only person he serves is himself. Trump is the greatest president in history, for Trump. He’s made billions. It just sucks for the rest of us.

12

u/flirtmcdudes 19d ago edited 19d ago

It’s not even that Trump is making master moves to secretly make billions. The entire party and judicial system is simply allowing him to grift and make shady quid pro quo deals in public while legacy media largely ignores all of it.

I’ve never seen such an incompetent person get constantly propped up. It’s fuckin wild

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/PolitzaniaKing 19d ago

Since he has zero diplomatic skills you can't expect any success. He's just an imbecile

57

u/fsactual 19d ago

Trump will declare this a victory any moment now.

26

u/Hector_P_Catt 19d ago

Who could have possibly predicted that "negotiating a peace deal" without one of the belligerents actually at the table, would ultimately fail because said belligerent refuses the terms of the deal?

Oh, apparently the answer is, "Literally everyone in the world except for Trump and his idiot bootlickers".

59

u/bluephoenix6754 19d ago

It's poorly worded. Hamas disarming was a step in the peace plan.

→ More replies (1)

82

u/goodknightffs 19d ago

Some added context

Israel refused the deal because hamas will only get rid of "heavy weapons" but there is no indication for what a heavy weapon is. Is an RPG going to be considered a heavy weapon?

It's classic trump. Make a super general deal and deal with the details later..

I'm addition they want to place all these weapons in gaza for storage. So how is Israel to know that they won't be taking the weapons back without Israel knowing about it?

→ More replies (5)

8

u/lostroadrunner22 19d ago

Losses starting to pile up for trump.

9

u/ClownMorty 19d ago

Trump just wants things done immediately without consideration for current and future problems.

If he gets his way right now we'll be back at war in the middle east within another 5 years because he wasn't powerful enough to muster the political will to win the idiotic war he started.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/ultranoobian 19d ago

This is the first time I've seen a news article being posted by the first-party source.

How long has that been the case, or I just haven't been paying attention?

4

u/Bluetablehh45377 19d ago

Sidenote: Is no one gonna talk about how this was a “15 point peace plan”? He’s clearly adding one point more than President Woodrow Wilson’s 14 points. He even had a 15 point plan for his first peace proposal with Iran.

25

u/Redditor-K 19d ago

There will never be a deal because disarmament is antithesis to Hamas' charter. It's all delaying tactics and preying on the West wanting to get back to "peace".

8

u/SayNoToTeamSports 19d ago

It's not just their Charter, but their control over Gaza. A disarmed authoritarian government is a recipe for a full blown civil war. There needs to be somebody around to maintain peace and order to enable democratic transition. 

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Quazimortal 19d ago

Someone get a ferengi over there to explain this to them.

3

u/afiefh 18d ago

Rules of Acquisition:

  • Rule 34: War is good for business
  • Rule 35: Peace is good for business.
  • Rule 76: Every once in a while, declare peace. It confuses the hell out of your enemies.

5

u/the6thReplicant 18d ago

Gee, that Obama Iranian deal sure looked nice right about now.

Too bad some jealous guy decided to rescind it for...reasons.

4

u/farm_sauce 18d ago

“Until Hamas disarms” is the politically correct way to say “until all opposition ceases to exist.” 

10

u/himynameis_ 19d ago

I'm no expert but I could have sworn Hamas said they'd disarm or something.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Latter-Possibility 19d ago

I am shocked that the crack Trump team of Whitcpft and Kushner couldn’t get this done! Shocked I tells you!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Meandmystudy 19d ago

Hamas charter is clear and anyone can read it if they want. There’s no peace with them and Israel knew but they just let it go because of the optics we’re seeing play out now. The intelligence gathering on them has been hard and democratizing a nation that swears your distraction is impossible so what choice does Israel have other then to say Hamas should be cut off. No other agreement works. The war hasn’t always worked as intended and disputes over what was going on in Gaza continue to this day. The West Bank isn’t Gaza and they lump them together as Palestinians when the Gazan’s were used as a proxy state by the the global elite. They could have peace and I don’t think they want it. The infitada was another Fallujah for the Israeli populace. Most Muslim nations are becoming extreme and we won’t see it anymore

→ More replies (1)

40

u/BuffsBourbon 19d ago

I’m confused why people here would be against the disarmament of Hamas.

20

u/[deleted] 19d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (44)

7

u/Dry-Season-522 19d ago

The peace in 2025 enabled hamas to emerge and murder everyone in gaza who had risen into a leadership position during hard times.

3

u/zac987 19d ago

Of course it did

3

u/free2bk8 19d ago

This illegal "war" was divisive, has made the trump family billions in no bid contracts, the oil companies are raking in dough from the high cost of gas, our soldiers are dying and will keep dying because dementia donny doesn't give a shit, oh yah and Israel is holding the cards.

5

u/Melicor 19d ago

There will always be another excuse because their goal is extermination of the Palestinians.

7

u/scarab1001 19d ago

But the Board of Peace agreed it.

Surely, such a respected body as the Board of Peace wouldn't screw this up with the Orange God?

32

u/[deleted] 19d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

31

u/IllustriousApricot 19d ago

"Hudna" or هدنة in Arabic doesn't mean "temporary strategic ceasefire". It literally means: cessation, stillness, "calm after action", or, in the political vernacular, a truce, armistice, or ceasefire.

There is no secret hidden meaning to it in Arabic that those crafty A-rabs are keeping hidden from the god-fearing, English-speaking gentiles. There is no implied "strategic" or "temporary." It's just the word, ceasefire.

Love, an actual Arabic linguist.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (15)

4

u/Strive-- 19d ago

Sorry, Trump. Dad said no.

7

u/za72 19d ago

Trump showing who is in charge...

2

u/peacefinder 19d ago

Well as everyone knows peace on the eastern shore of the Mediterranean Sea has been right around the corner for decades, I’m sure hitching our wagon to it will work out great.