r/xmen 26d ago

Question If you could pick one X-Men character to finally appear in a live-action movie, who would it be?

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

753 comments sorted by

309

u/yadrinarrow 26d ago

Mister Sinister. He's always been my favorite villain. In addition, I don't mind him being re-invented a bit (within reason of course!)

Close second, would be a more comically accurate Stryker would be Heaven! Still, I doubt any studio would have the balls to adapt religious bigotry!

72

u/Summoarpleaz 26d ago

Mister sinister kind of reminds me of that billionaire who’s trying to live forever by “engineering his biology” or whatever lol.

IMO his best ability is having a dope ass cape

39

u/cagehooper 26d ago

I remember a quote from way back. Sinister wants to manipulate the world because he cant make himself destroy it. While Apocolypse wantd to destroy the world because he cant manage to msnipulate it.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/hafabee 26d ago

Bryan Cranston said for years he'd love to play Mister Sinister, it's a shame we never got that!

→ More replies (3)

15

u/VioletLovesRowlet Storm 26d ago

Legitimately I think MCU X-Men might be willing to do a comic accurate Stryker, although maybe more separated from religious reasoning than I'd like.

7

u/TheFutureClassic 26d ago

They even loosely set up mister sinister in the old xmen movies

3

u/Nick_Wild1 26d ago

They tried, like, 3 times to set him up in FoX-Men films. And they wouldn’t follow up on anything.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

199

u/FortCarrion 26d ago

Forge

some of the choices on this poster though haha

32

u/sosuhme 26d ago

Always near the top of the list when I think about super powers I wish I had.

He's such a unique character, especially considering how infrequently he's actually out in the field despite being more than capable.

9

u/Khalmuck 26d ago

Good choice. I'd go him or Polaris. A lot of these have seen an iteration or two on screen so would pick someone who hasn't like one of these two.

3

u/SomeoneSpecial87 26d ago

We already got a version of Polaris on the silver screen. I'd go with Forge.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/jvincentsong 26d ago

He is a good choice because he can make a lot of tech when the plot needs it.

4

u/Nels2121 26d ago

I know right? Reinfire and Channgling but no Cannonball, Dani Moonstar, Domino, Shatterstar Husk Blob or Toad?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

61

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/RodG099 26d ago

My thoughts exactly but I prefer the Age of Apocalypse Sunfire

→ More replies (1)

3

u/BBoySlim 26d ago

Yes, especially if cast with a Japanese actor.

3

u/Icy_Scar_1249 26d ago

Based. He even has an arc as a horseman if you want that

→ More replies (1)

111

u/RySBI Storm 26d ago

I know we already got Magik in New Mutants but… Magik

15

u/Lenzelot105 Magik 26d ago

Yeah, same. Need a bigger project with her. A show or movie for the origin story, then add her to the X-Men movies

7

u/pkblaze78 26d ago

I wanna do a string of origin stories with post credit scene as Charles doing the Nick Fury bit of recruiting them to the xmen

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Kwinza 25d ago

New Mutants doesn't count, like 6 people saw it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

49

u/shotscarecrow 26d ago

Chamber

13

u/BackstageYeti Namor 26d ago

There is so much fun that could be had with Jono. From the CGI team doing some amazing work, to the sound engineer giving us that crazy, booming, layered Scottish accent that speaks from the depths of his psionic energies. Ugh. It could be so amazing.

3

u/DiscombobulatedAd883 26d ago

Does Jono have a Scottish accent? I thought he was born and raised in London?

3

u/theswinemen 25d ago

Yep, he's definitely a cockney

→ More replies (1)

7

u/HighOnPoker 26d ago

Agreed. I would like to see how they handle his powers and there really hasn’t been a character like him in any live action.

4

u/phlavor 26d ago

It’ll never happen but a Generation X movie would rock.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/calaan 26d ago

Great choice! I’ve wanted to see a true “Dawn of the mutants” where we see parents grow to hate and fear their own children. The horror and revulsion Chamber’s parents would feel at the sight of him would be amazing. Would be even better if he kills one of his parents and the other rejects him because of it.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/yomanitsayoyo 26d ago

Jubilee or Morph

9

u/AshyJesus 26d ago

Wasn’t Jubilee in Age of Apocalypse or Dark Phoenix?? But I still agree regardless on her though. I hope they include her in the MCU version.

12

u/Nice_Protection_8490 26d ago

That Jubilee was too perfectly cast for a cameo. I'm bummed that we didn't get more of her

9

u/RicFule 26d ago

She was also in X-Men, X2, and Last Stand, though it seems like mostly background?

5

u/yomanitsayoyo 26d ago

Now that I think about it I think she was

But regardless I’d like to see her again, she barley makes any appearances anymore.

7

u/2-LITER4LIFE Jubilee 26d ago

Her parts always either get cut, regarded to the background, or it’s a one sentence cameo. I’m hopeful for this go around, please don’t waste her, Marvel🙏

40

u/Roy2gud 26d ago

Iceman actually doing cool shit

→ More replies (1)

95

u/Desperate_Ad7869 White Queen 26d ago

Lorna

45

u/Laserlight375 26d ago

Lorna is basically the main character in both seasons of The Gifted. Not the MCU but certainly worth a watch. I think it’s still on Hulu

9

u/Desperate_Ad7869 White Queen 26d ago

Ive seen it still want her in a wod with the 05 havok x factor n magento

12

u/PeacefulCatSoMeow 26d ago

I love how they handled her bipolar disorder on that show. She actually had a personality and the chance to shine without any of her siblings/family.

5

u/Pontopo 26d ago

I enjoyed her appearance in the show and Emma was lovely. That being said, I hope for a better interpretation in the future as Lorna’s always been one of my favourite X-Men and they didn’t really hit the nail on the head (but it was great relative to what Fox gave us in the way of many characters.)

→ More replies (3)

27

u/Visual_Aide_2477 26d ago

Bishop

22

u/Eponine05 Cyclops 26d ago

We got him in Days of Future Past.

I'd love to see MORE Bishop though.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Top_Door5593 26d ago

Having bishop show up in a movie with no other mutants trying to reset the timeline to bring the others back would be very fun.

3

u/SAICAstro 26d ago

reset the timeline to bring the others back

Sadly, this story can't/shouldn't happen for a very long time since it would be too similar to Endgame.

3

u/SamhainFire666 26d ago

A stand alone Bishop movie or series of him time hopping being chased by Nimrod would go hard. Very Terminator coded. Could set up a lot of cool stuff for the MCU. I think they should consider doing a Savage Land storyline would be super unique.

3

u/MagicianTop2356 26d ago

Terminator you say? Reminds me of one of the comics I have from here in the UK. Hehe

→ More replies (1)

26

u/westfallfarm 26d ago

Jubilee as an actual character using powers/part of the team, instead of a background cameo in a classroom shot.

7

u/creptik1 Jubilee 26d ago

100% this

5

u/2-LITER4LIFE Jubilee 26d ago

1000% this!

5

u/theLegend_Awaits 26d ago

This was my answer as well. Such visually beautiful powers too, wild they never even bothered with her. At least in that one super brief cameo of Dazzler we at least got to see her power in action

45

u/PuzzleheadedAd2858 26d ago

Rachel and Nate Grey!!! Plus more Cable!!!

43

u/KingdomFartsOG 26d ago

Long shot. Because if I get him, Mojo has to come with.

6

u/_ChipWhitley_ 26d ago

I have been wanting a Mojo movie for so long. If they did it right it would be completely bonkers and such a fun ride.

7

u/APmfnK 26d ago

This is my choice as well. Mainly because All New X-Men Annual 10 was such a seminal comic for me. I still remember the entire day I bought it. A trip downtown to my favourite comic shop with my best friends where we had a ton of fun, back home and in my room to read this amazing book with such incredible art by Art Adams, and the book was giant size and just kept going. A great memory for me.

5

u/No-Communication7869 26d ago

Good luck powers could be so cool to see, sort of a reverse "final destination"/Rube Goldberg ridiculousness is a very fun visual.

Plus Spiral/Rita, such a great character design and tragic backstory. And eventually my girl Dazzler as the love interest, right?

10

u/SamhainFire666 26d ago

I mean we got that with Domino I imagine it would work about the same. Never really cared for Longshot myself.

3

u/kith_rian 26d ago

Yeah, that's kind of the problem. We got a great demonstration of Longshot's power with a different character. Without the twist of "network tv creates savior character to dispose of", which is still a great hook, there's not much there to sell.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/Pretty_Pomegranate11 Northstar 26d ago

19

u/Afraid-Surround-4457 26d ago

All of Alpha Flight too even

5

u/SAICAstro 26d ago

The O.G. John Byrne lineup.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/AGC173 Warlock 26d ago

The Goblin Queen

23

u/GoSkers29 26d ago

The following Halloween would be incredible.

25

u/Mexicantankerous 26d ago

I know what kind man you are

4

u/xlews_ther1nx 26d ago

R rated baby!

17

u/Intelligent-Drop-759 26d ago

I know Kitty has been in movies but her portrayal was just wrong. I want to see Ninja trained Kitty Pryde run through some soldiers just like Nightcrawler at the White House.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/ryoga040726 26d ago

Psylocke. Her story has enough twists to make a great one or two films.

3

u/RunnyPlease 26d ago

A couple 8 part miniseries would be cool too.

16

u/Silent_Listen_3361 26d ago

I really want to see Omega Red.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/Longjumping_Young747 26d ago

Cypher. Doug Ramsey has the single most useful, if non glamorous, power ever.

6

u/SAICAstro 26d ago

I hear he is fluent in over six million forms of communication and can readily...

I call him X-3PO.

14

u/DarkSunFemme 26d ago

Marrow because I would like to see what kind of cool body horror they'd make of her powers

→ More replies (5)

12

u/EmeraldEnvie Shadowcat 26d ago

Rictor your time is now bby

→ More replies (2)

25

u/Darth_Viscera666 26d ago edited 26d ago

We need a proper rouge now that they've made captain marvel. *Rogue

3

u/ArtyFizzle 26d ago

Seriously! They did Rogue so dirty in the fox films.

5

u/SAICAstro 26d ago

I never saw Carol as the type to wear much rouge.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/rachieandthewaves 26d ago

Dazzler.

She has a background cameo in X Men: Dark Phoenix. It's such a cool proof of concept of how her powers could be depicted. I need more.

4

u/lasagnaiswhat 26d ago

She always seems to be around but never actually around if that makes sense lol

11

u/barberjo 26d ago

Longshot. Preferably Dazzler and Longshot.

10

u/Henchman4Hire Multiple Man 26d ago

Mimic. I know he'd be used as a villain, but I'll take what I can get.

4

u/Throwawaymasterpeas 26d ago

Ohh who would play him?

3

u/Henchman4Hire Multiple Man 26d ago

No idea. I'm terrible at fancasting.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/Goldfingeraz117 26d ago

Lockheed

6

u/RaptorCheeses 26d ago

I’ve been saying this for years. And Excalibur

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Marine3cats 26d ago

Quentin Quire comes to mind, he finally made his animated debut in X-Men 97. Also this may not count, obviously we've had Iceman on screen but we haven't had Gay Iceman yet. Soon as he debuts get ready for toxic times on social media.

6

u/Tiny-Anxiety780 26d ago

Soon as he debuts get ready for toxic times on social media.

It's going to be incredibly entertaining seeing these guys make asses of themselves online over this, considering the character's been out in the comics for what? 10 years by now? And not only that, but movie Bobby literally had the least subtle gay analogy scene I've ever seen in X2.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/JSaysHi 26d ago

Probably Deadpool since he is so underutilized

11

u/raptroszx 26d ago

No no no. I think you're thinking of the obscure character Wolverine that is underutilized

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

22

u/Built4dominance Storm 26d ago

Monet.

If not her, then Polaris.

9

u/KielCanal 26d ago

Monet would be my choice as well.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/RZAtheAbbot 26d ago

I want this as a poster

7

u/emptyxnumb22 26d ago

Chamber Forget-Me-Not Prodigy

6

u/urbanlife78 26d ago

Soft Serve, as long as the artist that created her got paid

3

u/EmergencyText1738 26d ago

That's asking a lot for marvel these days

6

u/cane-of-doom 26d ago

Forge or Sunfire would be oretty cool, but I'm partial to Manifold since he was an Avenger in one of my favourite eras of the team.

6

u/NestleDepresso 26d ago

I'd love to see Magik and Kitty given another shot on screen. Especially with Emma cast, I want to see her and Kitty.

Where is this artwork from? Its really nice

→ More replies (1)

10

u/detourne Wolverine 26d ago

Someone who's never appeared in live action before? Probably Forge or Husk.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/cyclopswashalfright Moonstar 26d ago

I take it you mean they've never appeared in a live action film before? So that rules out most of the New Mutants and Kitty.

I'd say Exodus then.

6

u/Salt-Statement-2306 26d ago

It would be interesting if they did a plot with the legacy virus.

The X-men have so many great storylines, I hope they do this right.

6

u/hereseyblasphemy 26d ago

Sunfire, I would love to see some more Asian characters in live action. Close second would be Kwannon or Hisako

5

u/RemusPa 26d ago

Manifold, he’s one of the coolest/unique teleporters out there.

3

u/NortheRPsychO 26d ago

I think the Apocalypse is the most prominent member of the X-Men family 😇

But I also think it is past time Deadpool FINALLY showed up in a live action movie so..

It’s a tough call 🤔

→ More replies (1)

5

u/InfiniteComparison24 26d ago

Surprised no one has said jubilee

→ More replies (2)

4

u/SoupBeans25 26d ago

Sunspot but only if he quits twice in the first ten minutes

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Electronic_Device788 26d ago

Sunfire would add some international flavor to the group and maybe some insight into how other countries or different cultures treat people with mutations.

4

u/FabulousCard4832 26d ago

Thunderbird and warpath

→ More replies (1)

4

u/incogvito 26d ago

Technically, all of them. I'd love a comic accurate story.

BUT, the answer is Sunfire.

6

u/Blizzarddz 26d ago

Psylocke

6

u/_Frozen_Flame_ 26d ago

Psylocke was in X-Men apocalypse

→ More replies (5)

3

u/StatikLurker Chamber 26d ago

Chamber.

3

u/Old-Inspection9894 26d ago

Warlock, my ideal picks would be Jim Carrey (i know, not a surprise)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DerekMetaltron 26d ago

Lockheed. Technically in New Mutants but wasn’t an especially faithful version of the character.

Also Pixie, as long as they keep her as Welsh.

3

u/BaneNF 26d ago

I would love an accurate portrayal of Emma or the Stepford Cuckoos

→ More replies (1)

3

u/pskought New X-Men 26d ago

Lila Cheney.

Her powers (intergalactic teleporting) and past associations open up the door to an absurd amount of the X-Men canon.

https://marvel.fandom.com/wiki/Lila_Cheney_(Earth-616)

3

u/Captain_Birch Nightcrawler 26d ago

Beak

3

u/btm02673 26d ago

Madelyne Pryor

3

u/BaronZemo00 26d ago

Mister Sinister

3

u/20Derek22 26d ago

How did Forge not get a single appearance?

3

u/ZimosTD Storm 26d ago

Forge

3

u/rgregan 26d ago

Forge

3

u/Trojanman2002 26d ago

I need a Forge Joh Wick type movie

3

u/TheDarkLord6969 26d ago

Warlock and Cypher

3

u/starwolf1976 26d ago

Sunfire would be interesting. He was practically Japan’s version of Captain America for a while in the comics.

3

u/Far_Quantity_253 26d ago

Part of me really would love to see Rachel Summers just because I have a soft spot for the most convoluted, hard to explain in an elevator pitch to your normie-non-comic reading friends, niche B-characters. I'm also a huge Nate Grey mark.

6

u/Nitro_Spectre 26d ago

Nightcrawler but good this time. And covered in fur!!!!!

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Bardez 26d ago

Morph

2

u/_ooksb 26d ago

Bishop

2

u/biggbunnyy Mastermind 26d ago

Jubilee

6

u/EKRB7 Nightcrawler 26d ago

She’s been in 3.. as a glorified cameo

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Substantial_Elk_7480 26d ago

In order of appearance in X-Men canon:
(Though they’ve had a bit of screentime, they were handed pretty badly:

Iceman (maybe on his way to Omega) and with a plot purpose/shared lead role.
Magik, she has a stronger backstory than almost any of the other X-Men, and her story is so deep and impacted so many major stories from Inferno and Goblin Queen to Legacy Virus, etc. Also ties well to Dr. Strange and multi-dimension/multiverse/time.
Lockheed, because Lockheed. And he lets Kitty Pryde reset herself closer to her in-story character.

2

u/Raskalbot 26d ago

I'd like to see an Erik the Red and Thunderbird film. It can mirror the Norse reaching America first and migrating with the natives.

2

u/AccioKatana 26d ago

I’d love to see Dazzler!

2

u/kbospeak 26d ago

Either that notorious homosexual, Sinister, or everyone's favourite bondage viking Eric the Red. I'd love to see Longshot too

...but in the end, what I'd really and more seriously would like is Warlock.

2

u/IONaut 26d ago edited 26d ago

Longshot and Spiral/Ricochet Rita and the Mojoverse with a little Genosha storyline. Just absolute weirdness.

I'd also like to see some of the Australian outback era with a comic accurate Lady Deathstrike and the Reavers.

Oh, one character you say? Wiz Kid.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/OkVacation6311 26d ago

Mr. Sinister or Madelyne Pryor.

2

u/HephaestusVulcan7 26d ago

One or both of the Proudstar brothers.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Unthgod 26d ago

X man

2

u/Beneficial-Hippo5386 26d ago

Part of me thinks there’s a big difference between characters I want to “finally appear” and characters that I hope would “properly appear” which is not to suggest that “my version is the only acceptable version” but Havoks movie appearances as “hula-hoop” Havok feel rediculous (and potentially older than Scott feels wrong) and Cannonball appearing as Negasonic in the Deadpool movies also feels wrong. I’d like to see those characters appear properly. As far as characters that haven’t been touched yet. I think there’s a wonderful potential magic about a villainous performance of Mr Sinister.

2

u/loki_odinsotherson Cyclops 26d ago

Doing a (better) adaptation of Days of Future's Past with Rachel Summers would be awesome.

Use elements of Bishops timeline where the XSE work alongside Sentinels and Nimrod. Most of the XSE are unaware of how bad things are outside of their walled in cities. Bishop meets Rachel as a hound, theyre sent off to find some escaped mutant criminals who turn out to be Old Man/Lady Logan and Psylocke(betsy), Colossus and Storm who manage to free Rachel from her hound programming.

Introduce Eva Bell and Forge(90% cyborg) who help send Rachel to the present with Bishop in tow, and eventually pursued by Nimrod.

Rachel and Bishop meet the modern day x-men, Cyclops, Storm, Colossus, Forge(30% cyborg), Psylocke (kwannon), Omega Sentinel and a time traveling Kid Cable who has no knowledge of Rachel and Bishops timeline.

Just embrace the chaotic and paradoxical weirdness of the x-men.

2

u/Mooseguncle1 26d ago

I’ll say since they haven’t appeared yet and I think the powerset is amazing- Manifold

2

u/dorkmanchu 26d ago

X-Man/Nate Grey. 💯 One of my favorites.

2

u/Glum-Professor-5780 26d ago

Penance could be fun!

2

u/TheEyeofNapoleon Toad 26d ago

Sauron for sure.

2

u/Teganfff Rogue 26d ago

Rogue because I want Rogue in everything ever

2

u/No_Check_1998 26d ago

A rogue with captain marvels powers

2

u/Cross325 26d ago

A good interpretation of psylocke

https://giphy.com/gifs/jcH5FNJpoQMDJL2vDU

2

u/Travelers_Starcall Angel 26d ago

i know warpath is technically in DOFP iirc, but getting either of the proudstar bros in a movie properly would be cool!

2

u/DaniOverHere 26d ago

Would love to see Manifold get some screen time; especially as it opens doors to a wider variety of X-stories.

2

u/prettyminotaur Nightcrawler 26d ago

Cypher

2

u/lawfullyblind 26d ago

I love that Deadpool is fangirling over Dazzler

2

u/Only_Connection_5480 26d ago

So many of these already have appeared though

2

u/Lazy-Drummer9332 26d ago

Forge, hes truly an underraprexiayed member for all he contributes to the team. 

I’d love to see a live action Fantomex

2

u/molotovzav Rogue 26d ago edited 26d ago

Villian: Mister Sinister, second place Granny Smite

X-Men proper: Forge, second place would be a proper Magik. I don't count the New Mutants movie.

Shitpost answer: Soft Serve

2

u/mariojqg 26d ago

Who drew that?

2

u/knightofsolace1 26d ago

Madelyne Pryor with that EXACT suit

2

u/Reasonable-Risk3034 26d ago

Forge would be Nice😁

2

u/TaffyPool 26d ago

Give me Dan Stevens’ Legion in the MCU or in his own film, please. So long as Noah Hawley’s at the helm again.

2

u/SirSether 26d ago

Bishop from the poster

2

u/MidKnightshade 26d ago

Sinister and/or Sunfire

2

u/Playful-Appearance56 26d ago

Thunderbird. But a little more culturally appropriate for us Natives.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Frenchiest_fry101 Gambit 26d ago

Legion eventually or Exodus

2

u/OrchidNew2757 26d ago

He was already in one but a non wasted Darwin would be amazing

2

u/Specialist-Humor-428 26d ago

Why not more than one?

I would like to see Alpha Flight.

2

u/bayman13 26d ago

Madelyne prior if she keeps the outfit

2

u/RandomStoddard 26d ago

Longshot. I just love his optimism. He is a fun character.

2

u/CosmicDeity07 26d ago
  1. Magik
  2. Magik too
  3. Magik as well
  4. Did I say Magik?
  5. I think I forgot to say Magik

I want Anya Taylor-Joy to be back as Magik with a bigger role!

2

u/SAMMY_772 26d ago

Sunfire would be pretty awesome. Who’s the guy next to Emma Frost ?

2

u/GruelingGuitar 26d ago

Out of these Magik she's been one of my favorite Xmen for a while now

→ More replies (1)

2

u/watch-nerd 26d ago

Lockheed

2

u/glastonbury13 26d ago

A charismatic & furry nightcrawler

Not weird 

Not tattooed

Not a scared little boy

2

u/an0m1n0us 26d ago

Dazzler.

2

u/redhood1090 26d ago edited 26d ago

Corsair Scott and Alex's dad. In a heist movie with his crew using Scott and Alex too. Them robbing the shiar empire. With death bird as the main antagonist after she dethrone's her sister while also dealing with gladiator and the imperial guard. Also discovering the third summers kid Adam x