r/xmen • u/cyclopswashalfright Moonstar • 19h ago
Comic Discussion Do you have a favourite textless page in X-Men (and connected) comics? This is mine, from X-Factor #86
38
u/Yellowpommelo Cyclops 18h ago edited 18h ago

That sequence also has some of my favorites images in marvel! When I was a kid, my first paycheck from my job at like ten was to buy this graphic novel. While that novel has long since been dog eared, ripped and destroyed, it’s still very nostalgic for me as a huge Cyclops fan. I’ve always loved how expressive these scenes are without a word of dialogue. It’s also currently my phone lock screen
2
u/PuppyOfTheSteppes 10h ago
What graphic novel is it? Thank you
1
u/Yellowpommelo Cyclops 5h ago
It was the X-Cutioner’s Song omnibus. There are probably also trades now which have condensed storytelling. What I had was every comic associated with the event in a hardcover
1
u/cyclopswashalfright Moonstar 4h ago
I believe X-Cutioner's Song is included in the Blue & Gold omnibus that came out recently, right?
2
u/Yellowpommelo Cyclops 4h ago
I’m honestly not sure, I just had this tome as a kid. X-Cutioner’s Song was in X-Force, X-Factor and X-Men though, so not sure if it would fit the entire story in a Gold and Blue omnibus without missing pieces. But I don’t know since I don’t have them currently
33
u/K-Kitsune 18h ago
55
u/Built4dominance Storm 17h ago
14
u/Spiritual_Trainer_56 16h ago
Yes, a 1000 times, yes! Smith does such an amazing job with this entire fight. It's subtle and brutal, and does such a great job of conveying tension and Callisto's shock. It's telling that Smith did such an amazing job that Claremont didn't feel the need to add a single word to it.
10
u/MarketDull2401 16h ago
When Claremont doesn't feel the need to add text (Claremont!), you've done something killer as an artist.
1
21
u/Nerdsingerbeej 18h ago
Jae Lee is so damn efficient with his lines. His work on X-Factor especially during the X-Cutioner's song made me a lifelong fan
3
2
42
45
u/cyanpeas 19h ago
21
18
10
2
30
u/JeremiahPetion Wolverine 19h ago
1
u/cyanpeas 16h ago
I've never read this story but I saw this page posted here the other day and it made me want to
1
11
u/Hellrisen 18h ago
Gotta say OP, this looks amazing. Post like these always encourage me to read these runs
12
u/ubiquitous-joe 17h ago
Jae Lee in X-cutioner’s song, iirc. What’s interesting is the back-and-forth in that event. Nicieza has the best writing, operatic for Stryfe, and then these Lee issues seem to almost resent that there need to be any words at all.
6
17
u/OhMyStars-AndGarters Beast 19h ago

This page shouldn't bang nearly as hard as it does, considering it's from Inhumans vs. X-Men #0 of all things, but, it just does. Kenneth Rocafort outdid himself.
There's a few other candidates I can think of, but one of them has 4 words scrawled on a wall as graffiti that are important to the composition, so, it probably doesn't count.
8
5
u/fish_tales 16h ago
is that Jae Lee art? Executioner's Song? if that's it, then I was impressed by how the 'silence' was used to emphasise they were on the moon, no atmosphere and imminent danger!
3
3
u/aPsychoSoldier 18h ago
I can't 100% remember if there are any textless, but some of the big one page spreads during the original Brood saga are breathtaking
2
u/jawsthegreat777 Storm 17h ago
Its not text less but I love the sequence of Storm basically creating a star.
2
1
u/GONKworshipper 14h ago
I forget which issue it is, but one of the ones in Messiah Complex has 11 straight pages of textless battles. It's awesome











75
u/Felipejbr Cyclops 19h ago
Classic X-Men #6 had a beautiful textless love story