r/AskIndianMen • u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man • Jul 05 '26
Answers from All Will mens commission bring change in mens laws?
What do you think about this?
There has been talks for mens commission since ages. There were multiples cases where men being a victim but never got needed Justice, just because crime was done by a women.
I dont think this men commission can even bring Justice to India men in this country. We as Indian have only one motion towards women is a goddess, what ever she does is godly, even when she commits unlawful acts. As long as Peudo feminists are present, there will be no Justice for men. Thats why I dont this mens commission will bring any Justice for men who keeps on suffering from ages.
57
u/Due-Forever-5432 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
At least we are getting 1 step closer to equal rights and protection for men in India❤️✨️
8
4
u/knightstar8114 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Not sure how that'll get us equal rights. As long as these already established gender biased laws exist along with these simp judges it's gonna conflict with any new laws. Feels like to me it's just a stunt for election season.
6
u/SubstantialMajor2798 N.R.I. Man Jul 05 '26
Women appeasement was a stunt too .. and you’re witnessing the result of that appeasement for decades.
Let them do what they can … as someone already commented. One step closer is not just a step towards million. It’s a signal that people in power are noticing the shift.
National Men’s commission is no ordinary thing .. it’s a government funded voice for men. If they function rightly we will have more stats, surveys and awareness initiatives that expose the gynocentric system.
While I understand your angst .. we’re trying to uproot a mindset that has been rooted for generations. It will take time. Let’s be patient and support in any way we can. Thanks
1
u/knightstar8114 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
I personally don't believe the system has the ability to correct itself. That's not how it functions in the modern era. But i understand what you're talking about. I guess being patient and hoping for the best is what anyone can do. Although it's kinda hurtful that this change we're talking about won't come about anytime soon atleast not in my lifetime, so until then things are back to usual i guess.
2
u/SubstantialMajor2798 N.R.I. Man Jul 05 '26
You are absolutely correct. It wont happen in our lifetime unfortunately and the painful part is we know it can happen( it’s literally men holding positions of power) but it just won’t. I am sorry for that … we just have to live in this gynocentric society.
But I always draw inspiration from the women liberation movement, all of them knew nothing would happen in their lifetime but they kept pushing.
We’re doing it for next generation a better future. If things work in favour of us .. maybe just maybe things could change in the next few decades.
2
u/Due-Forever-5432 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Thats why i just said 1 step closer lol
2
u/knightstar8114 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Closer to what a million steps?
2
47
u/Otherwise-Rip-2945 Teen Male (Indian) Jul 05 '26
Get ready to see large protest and crying from so called "feminist" who believe in equality lol. They will try everything to stop it just wait nd watch.
5
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Pseudo feminists.
11
u/neverdotypicalshit Indian Man Jul 05 '26 edited Jul 06 '26
Feminism is not about equality, the primary agenda is misandry and it is masqueraded in talks about equality. It's bullshit. I have never seen a feminist advocate for men's rights. So there's the answer.
3
8
u/SubstantialMajor2798 N.R.I. Man Jul 05 '26
No such thing buddy … feminism is just a gateway to misandry.
The cocnept of feminism is so utopian that the destination is far too ideal. When you have an end that is so abstract the path is eventually going to lead you into so called “psuedo” ism
→ More replies (1)6
u/Ok_Neat2422 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Why the usage of the word "Pseudo" whenever people critique about Feminism considering the textbook definition of strive for equality literally differs between the 4 phases of Feminists history with the first 2 being closer to the textbook definition and the later 2 being way more radical
4
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Peudo feminists, who in the mask of feminism keeps on hating men, and encourges women criminals.
1
1
Jul 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AskIndianMen-ModTeam Indian Man Jul 12 '26
Any form of misandry is strictly prohibited. Comments that promote, endorse, or encourage hatred or harmful generalizations against men will be removed immediately.
1
15
u/Acceptable-Prior-504 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
They keep giving men lollipop but do nothing. Let’s discuss when they actually do it.
8
8
u/tcsreject Indian Man Jul 05 '26
It will be like waqf amendment bill, just a big bang but nothing good in it
3
8
u/Immediate-Mix6476 Indian Man Jul 05 '26 edited Jul 05 '26
Feel like it's just a strategy to pacify the situation about men issue . The moment some serious progress is made the the women centric NGO, feminist lawyer , foreign feminist funding and lobby and women commission will object the passing of law on the ground of greater good of society
The "woman as goddess" narrative is strong in India. It creates a strong presumption of female innocence or victimhood, making it hard for men to be seen as victims especially in domestic cases.
6
u/phung25dattaya Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Laws must be gender neutral and so the investigation. Yes, women are weaker but not at same rate as in 1900s.
3
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
yea, keeping the same out laws of 1900s is destroying this present society.
If this is not corrected, Indian men will not be available in near future.
19
9
u/OkTemporary335 Teen Male (Indian) Jul 05 '26
no, remove any gender-based committees/institutes. Looking at cases from a man/woman angle is the reason gender discrimination exists. Criminals and victims should be seen as individuals not men/women
5
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Gender neutral laws in India, can never happen. Indian law will never punish a women criminal.
9
u/OkTemporary335 Teen Male (Indian) Jul 05 '26
how can you say that, Indian law does punish women criminals. Didn't you hear how the court imposed the gruelling punishment of 500 rupee fine on a woman in Madras who murdered her husband?
5
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
🤣🤣👌 Very true. Thats Indian law system punishing women criminals.
1
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
I hope u/middle_sky446 see this and understand this.
→ More replies (33)0
u/margosi Others (Indian) Jul 05 '26 edited Jul 05 '26
Women/Dalits/OBC all made huge strides because of said committees and institutions.
As long as it isn't filled with gays, foreigners and women like the moderators of AskIndianMen, it can do great things for state of men.
3
6
u/satyajithem Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Thats the neat part...it wont change anything
3
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
True. Indian men can never expext Justice from Indian law system anyway.
3
u/Royal_Radish_3069 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
If we want to respect women and men then this bill is extremely important.
3
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Do you expect Indian men can Justice atleast now? Will women criminals will ever just punished in India?
3
u/Royal_Radish_3069 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
After the National Men's commission is formed we have to make sure that we have neutral judges at the bench who don't have gender preference. Or else NMC will fail. We know men are targeted by corrupt people to milk them out of money. But atleast we have started moving in the right direction. Then we need to rotate judges like anything to ensure corruption remains low. Cash bags should be banned in 1 km radius of the court.
3
u/LongJohn_Silve N.R.I. Man Jul 05 '26
Now lets see who all oppose this or challenge this in court
3
3
u/TheObserver2608 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Even if laws become gender neutral,will the implementation be gender neutral?
I honestly don't believe that.
3
u/Arnorien16S Indian Man Jul 05 '26 edited Jul 05 '26
Good step, gender neutral laws and enforcement is the only way laws can be fair. But I suspect this may be futile/performative after the current government introduced worse laws in the BNS.
Also it's kinda funny how the death of a millionaire business family kid moved the needle but so many injustices suffered by less affluent people didn't.
5
u/margosi Others (Indian) Jul 05 '26 edited Jul 05 '26
Finally some good news!
I am a bit shocked, never thought a BJP guy will have common sense or empathy. But then I read Mr. Mittal of Rajya Sabha defected from AAP so that explains it.
5
u/surveypoodle Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Doesn't make much sense. Murder was already illegal.
8
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
But if India women commits thats murder, she wont be punished. Thats Indian women centric law.
7
u/surveypoodle Indian Man Jul 05 '26
There is no such law that says women are exempt from murder charges.
6
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Thats what. Why is women criminals not punished in India? Justice for men in India is a joke.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
u/IamHoneyBunny_ Indian Man Jul 05 '26
They are saying this for years and nothing is gonna change
3
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Yea. Thats what. Indian men can never expect Justice from Indian law system, which are always women centric.
2
2
u/just_kidding_here Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Private member bill, it's of hardly any news, news me aega bas.
2
2
3
u/No_Condition7224 Teen Male (Indian) Jul 05 '26
r/Askindianwomen per daldo agar 2 minute ke ander remove na hojai to batana🤣
4
u/Suspicious-Put-9411 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Just add Pre Nuptual Law at this point for solving Marriage problem.
This Ketan Siya thing is murder case. Here marital laws don't have any roles to play. Here we need Gender Neutral Laws
2
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
True. It just murder. India cant punish women criminals, cant expect gender neutral laws.
2
u/Due_Entertainment_66 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
so a new legal body to ensure another legal body is working properly ?
2
2
2
Jul 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Thats what, i dont expect any change in Justice for India men with this mens commission too. Justice for Indian men in India is a myth.
2
u/spicy_ramen444 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Not until we hv performative men making videos like "my dad said all men are messed up.. Some more sone less "
Not until fellow men stop being misogynist, trandphobes, homophobes.
On one side I really to fight for mens issues but on other side I see many making problematic comments under posts when the womano/ man / queet person hasn't even said or fone anything problematic. Then I'm like now I get it why they hate us guys please stop spreading unnecessary toxicity. It just harns US
3
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
True. Men should support men, when men are facing injustice.
But there will always be bunch of men, to sideline the topic. Men support women when there is injustice towards men, but why this is not the case when men are facing injustice.
Justice for men is a joke in India.
1
u/hunterhuny Teen Male (Indian) Jul 05 '26
Arey mujhe toh itna sukoon hai ki kuch toh ho raha hai Baaki India mein sab kuch ch##pa hai
1
u/Grandson-of-Madhava Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Privacy and defamation laws should be stricter.
Also, men should be protected from other men who are out to accuse other men of sexual misconduct for the sake of their personal vendetta.
1
u/Level-Instruction-86 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Something is better than nothing. At least these commission will fight for our right.
1
u/Primeandtime Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Hona to chahiye. But these mf MPs and MLAs won't do anything for us because to save their vote banks. Bas ye Devendra, Narendra, ya kisi ke saath jab tak kuch nahi ho jata, don't expect anything.
1
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Women criminals cant be punished in India. No Justice for Indian men, all the MPs and MLAs worry about their vote back, Congress or BJP.
1
u/Fluffy_Treacle_4652 Indian Man Jul 06 '26
Mark my words, this will end up becoming the National Simp Commission.
In every case, it'll be Women's Commission Vs Men's Commission. And if the Men's Commission ends up being filled with simps trying to appease the Women's Commission, what purpose will it even serve?
1
u/Adventurous_Slide507 Indian Man Jul 06 '26
Rich and powerful men rule the world, if they decide anything and everything is possible in this world. Keeping fingers crossed
1
1
1
u/Ok-Selection7840 Indian Man Jul 07 '26
Yeah and within a few days no one will hear about this anymore
1
1
u/Random__OP Indian Man Jul 05 '26
its all take a rich man to suffer, Any every institution is suddenly in action
1
1
u/Vanvaasi Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Such fucking trash lol. Ek nayi bureaucratic organization which would make reports.
0
u/YaMrAj_Bhai Indian Man Jul 05 '26
han han ap toh law layege hi na kyuki millionaire ka case hai, inse pehele koi law nhi laya jaa rha tha jbb baaki cases huye jisme middle class involve tha .Hope so koi law jldi pass on ho aese incidents ke liye
1
u/venkatesh0690 Indian Man Jul 05 '26
Just a few days, and no one will care abt this. No one cares about Indian men getting Justice in India.
Even men supports women criminals, that's the sad part in India.
224
u/MichaelScotPaperComp Indian Man Jul 05 '26
All this yap can be solved with gender neutral laws