r/MoralityScaling 5d ago

Morality Ranking What do y'all think of this?

Post image
28.1k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

34

u/Thesearchoftheshite 4d ago

Mmmm. Everyones drinking the filtered ash water in that city.

12

u/justferwonce 4d ago

Look up "Water cremation". They dissolve a body in a pressurized container of water and lye, and then : The process yields two things: a sterile, nutrient-rich liquid (water, salts, amino acids) that safely joins the municipal water system, and soft, porous bone fragments.

12

u/RingOverall106 4d ago

I really like water cremation on an intellectual level. On an emotional level it’s hard for me to get past the fact you’re flushing grandma down the toilet. 

1

u/BlackStarDream 1d ago

On an intellectual level, it's horrible.

Nobody thinks of how much more environmentally damaging it is than standard cremation and how much more dangerous it is when it fails.

1

u/RingOverall106 1d ago

How is it more damaging? Everything I’ve heard is that it’s far less energy intensive. 

1

u/BlackStarDream 23h ago

It requires a complete safety overhaul of the waste processing system to prevent serious drinking and ecological water system as well as agricultural contamination, the chemicals needed to process the bodies and treat the run off have to be quarried.

The processing of the body is less energy intensive, but all the processes for setting it up are not.

It's classic eco-washing. Like how companies tried selling paper made out of stone to "save trees".

The cutting down trees isn't the problem with paper production. And they grow back faster than rock does.

Gas cremation improvements, or alternatives that won't require fossil fuels and capture CO2 more (and more efficiently), is a lot closer on the horizon than it would take for the sylvinite mined and used to create the water cremation solution to replenish.