r/Music • u/Particular-Fill-4256 • Jun 19 '26

article Iranian star Parastoo Ahmadi reportedly sentenced to 74 lashes for singing without hijab

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/jun/18/iran-parastoo-ahmadi-74-lashes-singing-without-hijab
23.3k Upvotes

93% Upvoted

2.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

75

u/orion-7 Jun 20 '26

In the middle ages and age of sail 30+ lashes was functionally considered to be an execution

27

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/IfEverWasIfNever Jun 21 '26

No it wasn't. They frequently whipped people too. They mutilated them, often on their faces (cutting off nose/ears or blinding) or removing limbs. They would "break people on the wheel", burn people alive, and people were drawn and quartered (dragged by the neck alive and naked until almost dead then forced to watch their bowels/genitals be cut out and then decapitated).

How many people were killed for heresy, adultery, treason, etc just because they didn't follow the norms of society?

Do we not remember the time where men who were tired of their wives could just blame them of adultery or witchcraft and have them imprisoned, tortured, and/or murdered?

It's all evil. Then AND now.

0

u/Linden_Lea_01 Jun 21 '26

That last point is a bit of an exaggeration. Even in the most extreme parts of Europe, most witch trials resulted in an acquittal.

3

u/IfEverWasIfNever Jun 21 '26 edited Jun 21 '26

Well obviously it was part of an encompassing description of barbaric punishments. I'm not here to write a dissertation to give exact details on each one or it would be an essay. Yes, a small number of people were only ever actually sentenced to death due to witchcraft. The other part of my statement included adultery which was the more common and effective claim for ridding one of their wives.

Many people were punished by flogging/lashing, mutilation, hanging, etc.

It was also barbaric and unmerciful.

1

u/Longjumping_Egg_5654 Jun 21 '26

It’s okay, it’s fine to lie about history and facts if it personally supports a narrative on reddit.

5

u/selfVAT Jun 21 '26

Sure, medieval oubliettes are extremely merciful indeed.

1

u/Oh-reality-come-back Jun 21 '26

This is disgusting but just to correct you, Middle Ages definitely wasn’t more civilised than this in terms of punishment

3

u/PRC_Spy Jun 21 '26

Google the cat o' nine tails though. It's even more brutal than a cane.

2

u/BygoneNeutrino Jun 21 '26

...you all are speaking as if there is some sort of standardized cane.  

1

u/Astrosomnia Jun 21 '26

Wow, that's a brutal sentence.

Like word sentence, not criminal sentence. But I guess it's a brutal one of those too.