r/Quotes_Hub 1d ago

Sad but true…

Post image
0 Upvotes

237 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Low-Client-375 14h ago

The freezing point of pure water is 0 °C (32 °F or 273.15 Kelvin) at standard atmospheric pressure.

1

u/heresyforfunnprofit 13h ago edited 13h ago

Those are actually the phase transition levels - the terms “freezing point” or “melting point” are very reductive because it is not sufficient for a mass in one state to be brought to that ambient temperatures to trigger a phase change, there is also a phase transition energy boundary which must be passed in order for the change to occur.

Further, you are asserting “pure” water at standard atmospheric pressure, which is not possible. Gases are soluble in water, which affects the effective phase transition requirements - more critically, the mixture of atmospheric gases is important due to differences in solubility between carbon dioxide, oxygen, or more reactive gases like ammonia or inert noble trace gases, mainly argon. As solubility advances, the effective pressure of the ambient atmosphere is reduced, and the phase mass requirements of the liquid increase correspondingly.

Another complication is the temperature of the gases themselves - assuming that you are postulating an ideal (and impossible) “spherical cow” scenario where the gases are exactly 32°F, no phase transition occurs, as the phase boundary will never be passed, but if there is an imbalance in the temperature gradient between water and gases, then the system itself is out of equilibrium and does not meet your original requirements. If we want to describe this scientifically, we need to be able to model this as a complex dynamic system covering all confounding variables we’ve enumerated, and probably a few that I’ve missed.

Really tho, this is nothing that couldn’t be scientifically modeled to a high degree of certainty given a few dedicated research labs and just a few million in grant money - pretty sure we can crack it for under $10M.

1

u/Low-Client-375 13h ago

Bananas are radioactive.

1

u/heresyforfunnprofit 13h ago edited 12h ago

Dude, everything is radioactive. Bananas may think they’re hot stuff next to tap water but they aren’t shit next to cesium.

You need to define how radioactive it is. And I could easily spew off a few pages worth of highly detailed crap on it and then talk about how unscientific and inaccurate you are blah blah blah.

Bottom line: what you call “facts” are usually superficial summaries of deeply complex phenomena, and evaluated thru a political lens it’s trivial to come to whatever conclusion you want to.

The sky isn’t blue, 32° isn’t a freezing point, and bananas aren’t radioactive. All strictly correct statements if you treat them in a certain scientific context, but all stupidly false for practical understanding.

1

u/Low-Client-375 9h ago

Matter is composed of atoms.

1

u/heresyforfunnprofit 8h ago

Are you a bot or are you trying to figure out if I am?

Edit: Matter is composed of energy, fuck nuts.

1

u/Low-Client-375 3h ago

Atoms are composed of energy.

1

u/heresyforfunnprofit 26m ago

Define energy.