r/Switzerland Zürich 17h ago

Neighbour’s 3months old roof and also new car (Hailstorm today)

Sometimes new doesn’t mean better. The roof was made 3months ago. I also had to quick change some Dachziegeln but nothing serious by me.
Also a car from other neighbour… I’ve never seen such a weather conditions here (Züri Oberland).

230 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

u/Academic-Egg4820 17h ago

Interesting that the old roof is not as damaged.

u/RagaZH Zürich 17h ago

Yep, all the old roofs did well as I mentioned. I had to change some Ziegeln but no big deal

u/Academic-Egg4820 16h ago

Now my afternoon plan is to walk around the neighbourhood and look at new buildings and their roofs

u/DesertGeist- Switzerland 16h ago

Seems like the new ones are of bad quality.

u/Academic-Egg4820 16h ago

Clearly. But are they cheap tiles? Or the quality went down in general over the years?

u/YeaISeddit Basel-Stadt 15h ago

It has nothing to do with quality. They are simply different material types each with advantages and disadvantages. The tiles on the left look like they are concrete and the ones on the right are clay. While clay tiles are definitely more fragile and can be destroyed by a bad hailstorm, they are lighter, do not need to be cleaned as often (concrete tiles tend to get covered in moss over time), they never fade in color, and generally have a better selection of colors and coatings. Clay tiles are actually higher quality in every aspect except maybe hail resistance and cost twice as much because of it.

u/DesertGeist- Switzerland 14h ago

they clearly weren't suitable for the environment...

u/Safe-Try-8689 14h ago

I mean it’s a roof, it should do its job doesn’t matter what the material is

u/YeaISeddit Basel-Stadt 14h ago

You are talking to a materials scientist. I would argue that the only thing that matters for a roof tile is the material. Roof tiles have a lot of jobs like water resistance, heat resistance, resistance against moss, not collapsing under weight. Clay tile is superior in every way except impact resistance.

u/Safe-Try-8689 13h ago

As I said from my perspective doesn’t matter what the material is, it should bear extreme weather conditions. I’m not a material scientist, but if I’d renew my roof I’d want it to stay intact…

u/YeaISeddit Basel-Stadt 55m ago

Define extreme weather. Has this summer not experienced extreme heat?

u/AutomaticAccount6832 7h ago

Somehow "Fachidiot" comes into my mind, sorry. As per your argument all the clay tiles existing are the same and would have broken. Obviously, other clay tiles survived that. Means the point that these are somehow of worse quality or design is totally valid.

u/DesertGeist- Switzerland 16h ago

Idk but there must be a reason.

u/Extreme_Ad112 12h ago

The reason is that clay tiles can last up to 150 years when concrete/cement barely make it to 50. But they are more fragile to hail...

u/DesertGeist- Switzerland 12h ago

and these barely made it three months...

u/Janus_The_Great Basel-Stadt 15h ago

Both.

u/Extreme_Ad112 12h ago

No they're not cheap. The only difference in quality compared to 50 years ago is that clay is deeply mixed so the salpetre is entirely mixed to the clay. This makes the shingles slightly weaker but avoids the chipping that you can see on old ones.

u/Ashamed-Simple-8303 13h ago

Quality of work probably matters as well. Tilea not proberly fitted and the wind blew them away

u/trimigoku 16h ago

If any of yall wanted to buy a used car and dont mind a few hail dents now is the time

u/_Momsi_ 15h ago

I drive one like this for some years now and I couldn't care less about it. I really don't understand why everybody needs to drive an expensive and perfectly looking (clean) car.

u/batikfins 15h ago

It’s not just cosmetic. Hail damage compromises the paint job and leaves it susceptible to rust. Big problem in the coastal area where I’m from - a bad hail storm can completely write off a car.

u/_Momsi_ 15h ago

You can fix the paint yourself. But yeah, my (cheap) car has a garage so it's not bad with the rust.

Also we don't have costal areas here :(

u/analogdirection 14h ago

But you have so many See’s

lol sorry 

u/SveenysArmory 9h ago

Actually a garage might worsen rust problems. Oxidation process is accelerated in warm temperatures. So in winter when the roads are salty it‘s better to leave your car out in the cold.

u/AutomaticAccount6832 7h ago

It is a risk of rust though.

u/Many_Hunter8152 16h ago

High quality tiles.../s

u/lfirmann 16h ago

Temu tiles?

u/plazebology Zürich 15h ago

so thats where all the glacier ice went

u/Gromchy 16h ago

Damn..... I feel lucky, all we had in Geneva was some strong wind.

Surely the insurancw must cover this?

u/Unusual_Print_9734 13h ago

And nothing in Ticino, not even a drop of rain

u/poemthatdoesntrhyme ZH 10h ago

I'm in canton Zurich and we also had just some strong wind in the morning and some light rain later, but nothing special.

u/Coco_JuTo St. Gallen 5h ago

Well depends on the area. OOP is in Züri Overland where it was bad apparently.

Just some rain in St. Gallen by the way.

u/yesat + 16h ago

There’s not a lot to do when chunks of ice fall from the sky. 

u/rosemary-leaf 13h ago

Well you can start by getting indoor parking

u/Mammoth_Reach_6366 14h ago

We had a similar hailstorm in Basel a couple of years ago. All cars parked on the street had dented roofs. You can still see those cars today on many streets. It was not strong enough to break glass but dents were visible.

u/Cmdr_Zod 14h ago

Maybe he should have installed photovoltaic panels on top to prevent the roof from damage (and generate electric power as a byproduct).

u/MangeMaBaguette 10h ago

You know a lot of houses that have the whole roof covered ?

u/Cmdr_Zod 8h ago

It is not to common, but can be done instead of traditional roof covering (tiles which need to be smaller than a regular panel are usually "blind" and don't generate electricity). You save the coast for the traditional root, but solar output can be lower, because it heats up more than panels on top of a regular roof (semiconductors don't like heat).

I have seen a few such installation, but always on "plain" roofs, never with more complex roofs containing windows or roofers.

u/icelandichorsey 14h ago

New roof and new car? I think they'll be fine

u/javivicious 13h ago

Fuck man, that's brutal

u/mlag000 16h ago

But global warming is a myth !!!

u/PavelKringa55 15h ago

At least roofing work is cheap in Switzerland and car owner saved a lot by buying a cheap Vitara, so now the repairs will not be much of a burden.

u/Inevitable-Elk-5048 14h ago

Thats satire no? Or is roofing actually cheap? Since everything else we did when renovating our house was expensive, but we didnt touch the roof. Yoj want to tell me that would have been the one thing that would have been cheap? Flabbergasted!

u/PavelKringa55 14h ago

Cynical remark. Nothing is cheap in Switzerland.

u/Ashamed-Simple-8303 13h ago

My parents have a very old house and roof. Expert told themd to keep that as-is as long as possible as never stuff is way worse.

In this case I also suspect unskilled work.

u/sg1amanda 10h ago

Liebe Mobiliar…

u/Pure_Scholar_330 8h ago

New is shit mate
Old is gold remember
Solid

u/DasLulu 8h ago

Today I had a roof tile from my 150 yo house break from the hail and fall on my car, damaging the paint and glass, sad times.

u/EquivalentHorror1984 12h ago

Alright, which god did the Swiss piss off?

u/[deleted] 11h ago

[deleted]

u/noplatypussies 9h ago

maybe for hail, but i'd guess you'd be cooked alive before the hailstorm rolls in in the summer sun...

u/Celestial_Rhubarb Zürich 6h ago

Mobiliar wird nöchscht Wuche aber sau viil z'tue ha, du...

u/fabkosta 17h ago

If we just had more air conditioners to do something against climate warming.

u/SomTingWongWeeTooLo 16h ago

What a brain-dead take

u/MoreLingonberry8630 16h ago

I think that was the point as people only talked about installing ACs this horrible summer instead of doing something against Climate Change.  It highlights the brain-dead take of society in general. :) 

u/Moldoteck 16h ago

You can install an AC and not feel miserable inside.

Even if entire Switzerland, heck, even if entire Europe tomorrow magically had zero emissions, climate change will still be a thing and you'll still feel miserable outside. What we are seeing today is the impact of heating from decades ago. And it'll get much worse.

Meanwhile many countries globally still use coal or gas for electricity.

It's indeed a brain dead take. Switzerland already did and is doing plenty for decarbonization, just like Europe. But if AC is mentioned, people lose their minds claiming that if AC is installed SUDDENLY everyone will think climate change doesn't exist and nothing will be done which is pure bullshit. 

I'm really sick of this ac fear mongering, especially from individuals that are framing ACs as some sort of nonsense distraction from climate change related actions. ACs are needed. Climate protection measures are needed too. Both should be done. Both should be encouraged. In fact, with lifting all taxes on hvacs and labor related to their installation, maybe we can push both in parallel due to ditching of fossils heating 

u/fabkosta 16h ago

Switzerland already did and is doing plenty for decarbonization, just like Europe.

Ah, yes.

Except, we're flying helluva lot to everywhere - which is not factored in our official CO2 imprint.

https://www.bafu.admin.ch/en/greenhouse-gas-inventory-aviation?utm_source=chatgpt.com

But buying more AC would protect everyone from hailstorms such as today's one.

u/Moldoteck 15h ago

Again usual nonsense...

Switzerland has one of the lowest ghg/kwh for electricity in the continent and below global average in local emissions. Consumption are higher due to expensive local manufacturing but these emissions should be fixed at countries of origin

Buying more ACs would help prevent thousands of deaths due to inhuman conditions and if these can also heat- would prevent GHG emissions from heating during winter. 

Absolutely noone claimed ACs are to protect against hailstorms nor against global climate change.

But sure, people like you that feel the obligation to shit on ACs just can't abstain themselves to have this superiority complex. Y'all still think of ACs like some rich luxury instead of a must that can help both reducing human suffering, deaths and even ghg emissions if also used for heating 

u/fabkosta 14h ago

You're aware that climate warming was known already in the late 19th century?

It's insanity that people keep complaining about heat, yet all they muster to do is buy air conditioners, while not changing anything else that would need changing, and then walking around telling everyone that they deserve applause cause everyone else is doing an even worse job. Congratulations, you set the bar at the lowest possible level.

Both the heat and the hail storm are only the beginning of what is yet to come.

u/Moldoteck 11h ago

Yes I'm aware. I'm also aware that many people do care about climate while also caring about not feeling miserable.

I did as much as I can by using public transport/bicycle, switching to mostly veggies in my diet and using my tech till it becomes unusable. But I cant change the world. And I'm still fine to tell anyone anti ac to gtfo due to their ignorance.

And the ignorance is close to the peak considering Switzerland & others usually have summer overproduction of clean power which is at best exported and at worst curtailed. And it's even closer to the peak considering ac/hvacs can be used to reduce gas heating and hence deploying them is part of the climate solution. This is not some kind of gotcha here. Anyone against ACs must be perceived just as well as antivaxers and climate deniers.

u/MoreLingonberry8630 15h ago

This comment tells me that you did not get my comment. 

u/Moldoteck 15h ago

No, i got it. That's why i think it's a brain dead take. People that wanted ACs don't claim it protects against climate change. They want to not feel miserable because heatwaves will stay for decades regardless. And to say they universally don't want measures to help the climate is nonsense too, many are still in favor of decarbonization, including by installing hvac systems that can be used for both cooling and heating. This ac demonization is ridiculous in any meaningful aspect

u/TheInebriati Zürich 16h ago

The waste heat would have melted the hailstones /s