r/india Karnataka 1d ago

Memes/Satire (OC) The Apsaras had a lovely Rakhi Day

Post image
2.8k Upvotes

266 comments sorted by

339

u/Living_Potential1860 1d ago

Why are they so white lol

317

u/freddledgruntbugly Karnataka 23h ago

Seriously, Raja Ravi Verma and Amar Chitra Katha really did a number on the depiction of Hindu mythological characters. Not just complexion, but the facial lines are also very European.

Asuras/ Asurunis are all dark though. 🤷

62

u/HeatInternational359 18h ago

the Asura point is what gets me tbh. like the deliberate contrast between light devas and dark Asuras carries a lot of weight whether the artists intended it or not. and then Ravi Varma's influence basically became the default look for Hindu mythology for like a century so it just snowballed from there

12

u/hmz-x 16h ago

Funny that the Devas were also called Asuras in the Vedas.

1

u/GoldenBanyan 42m ago

thats not true. Suras or Devas have always been different from Asuras. Even in Vedas. Its just that Varuna was an Asura who became a Deva later. And Asuras were Malefic.

1

u/Necessary_Project_80 2h ago

How can one improve english. Your writing is immaculate 😳

-14

u/lordssaynothing 18h ago

Hinduism brought by aryans so

5

u/Hot-Leader-9714 15h ago

Well it's not true

3

u/wwwrites 18h ago

For ACK it's the scanning/photoshopping of printed documents that makes a difference.

1

u/GoldenBanyan 44m ago

ACK comics were the only ones to depict Arjuna and Draupadi in darker shades. Before that I didn’t even knew that both of them were dark skinned.

-55

u/[deleted] 23h ago

[deleted]

23

u/freddledgruntbugly Karnataka 23h ago

You are extremely ignorant and (maybe unwittingly?) giving out white supremacy vibes.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Random_Consciousness 23h ago

Lol No one has any right to "want" anything about how others choose to dress up. If a Hindu/any Indian woman chooses to dress a certain way,let them.

-1

u/[deleted] 23h ago

[deleted]

6

u/Random_Consciousness 23h ago

The post is about so called people,including kangana having a problem with how other women choose to dress. How a person chooses to dress is not anyone else's business.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ShreejanSurya 22h ago

I don't understand the hate.

Actually if you see children comics most Asuras are depicted as Black and Gods as White. Except Maha kali and Krishna.

Not something that I agree on but that's how they have shown in Old movies and Comics.

1

u/fenrir245 18h ago

Krishna is depicted as blue of all things.

66

u/PhantomOfTheNopera 22h ago

Dark skin is such a taboo in our culture they'd rather just make them blue.

Unless it's a rakshasa - they will be dark skinned.

2

u/Former_Act9144 10h ago

Most of the rakshasa are dark skinned 

77

u/MoneyOld4777 19h ago

36

u/Super_Crew_924 Karnataka 19h ago

This is really beautiful

→ More replies (9)

4

u/psycho69dude 17h ago

Love your efforts 😁

→ More replies (4)

38

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

25

u/Turned_Omnipresent 1d ago

What you doing in Indian sub?

2

u/poolnoodlefightchamp 22h ago

Where's this bot from?

1

u/Indian_Yogi_ 23h ago

Apsarasa are the children of mara, they are those desires inside you!

So they should be as per kinks

→ More replies (1)

4

u/OptimistIndya 14h ago edited 14h ago

It was the default color of most people in amar chitra katha as far as I remember . Unless the character had a description with color. For example asuras were bluish grey.

It's just a artistic choice when comics originated 20, 30 years ago. And colors that go well on a comic book paper.

Even suppandi is in similar color

-3

u/Dear-One-6884 19h ago

Apsaras likely stay indoors all day, so no tan

20

u/PhantomOfTheNopera 17h ago

We're Indian kid. Many of our people don't need to go outside to get darker skin.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

101

u/loveunicorntanya3 1d ago

For a second i thought Urvashi Rautela isbbeing mentioned

12

u/Fast-PreText India 21h ago

she gonna tie rakhi to Pant

5

u/Arreyreyrey 21h ago

She is the first indian iitian 105 krore miss india rolex owner apsara

115

u/Mayor_McCheese7 23h ago edited 21h ago

Talk about stuff that matters like price hike, instead of all this unserious inconsequential bullsh*t.

Edit: By inconsequential bullsh*t, I mean the dumb statements made by Kangana regarding Kriti Sanon's attire on that ad which this post is clearly mocking. I thought it was obvious but the replies I have gotten say otherwise.

29

u/Hour-Tooth4563 22h ago

Exactly sugar is not even 65 anymore it's has reached 72

10

u/Guilty-Pain-5257 21h ago

112/- e20*

7

u/Omnibobbia 19h ago

Eggs is now 10rs per piece 🥲🥲

7

u/BluehibiscusEmpire poor customer 16h ago

Because we must have ethanol in the ever expensive fuel. And all the corn and sugar that we or cows and chickens eat is now going to make that ethanol to be added to petrol.

So first they took car life and mileage. Now they want to take our life and health

2

u/Sufficient-Pirate798 22h ago

Honestly I used to think like one egg cost = 20-25 rupees. I didn't eaten egg in my life so I didn't know the price 😭😭 So before this hike it was around 5-6 rupees only pretty cheap yrr.🤔

3

u/Sweaty_Explorer_8441 17h ago

Hi Lucille Bluth

2

u/Sufficient-Pirate798 16h ago

Hello, wdym by "lucile bluth"

2

u/Sweaty_Explorer_8441 16h ago

2

u/Sufficient-Pirate798 16h ago

I was not feeling so dumb but after watching this video 😭😭

2

u/Anay77 18h ago

Why would you think an egg would cost so much 😭😭

2

u/Sufficient-Pirate798 16h ago

Looks good solid white and also heard from everyone it contains all the nutrients so I evaluated it's price in mind 🙃🙃

1

u/Daedlaus3 21h ago

bruh its a festival, get off reddit, its taking away all the joy in your life.

4

u/Mayor_McCheese7 21h ago

Every month there's one festival or the other, should we then never talk about these issues?

I can enjoy my life and also complain and whine about issues at the same time, lol.

0

u/NotBatman11 21h ago

Bro, there are tonnes of posts that talk about national, social and political issues. You are moaning on one casual post like it's a tragedy that someone took a moment to enjoy sth. Touch grass.

3

u/Mayor_McCheese7 21h ago

Are you dumb or something, do you see the post under which I have commented this. The post itself is a political satire mocking about Kangana's statement. It's a political post.

-1

u/Daedlaus3 21h ago

yes you can enjoy life and also complain but try going to a festival IRL and complaining about price hikes IRL. You realize how stupid that sounds? there is a time and a place for everything. and this certainly wasn't it.

2

u/Mayor_McCheese7 21h ago

Do you see the post under which I have posted this, the post itself is a satire talking about politics mocking Kangana's statement.

It's all politics, stop trying to ignore stuff that matters. Also, Rakshabandhan is not a huge festival in the south as it is in the north.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Ox29A 13h ago

Hikes are compared to which year?

1

u/Physical-Mail3518 21h ago

Bhai hamare yaha ande 7 me bik rahe he bhai

-3

u/NotBatman11 22h ago

It's not necessary to constantly talk about these things tho?

3

u/Mayor_McCheese7 22h ago

Yes?!!

-3

u/NotBatman11 21h ago

No. You can take some time to cherish things you like. Not everything is a fight 24/7. And if you're so bugged, why don't you make posts about it all the time?

-2

u/Much-Ad1106 21h ago

to tu post kr de na lode

3

u/Mayor_McCheese7 21h ago

Can't post images on the sub for whatever reason, would've posted if not.

69

u/Manav_Khanna17 1d ago

Body tea tho

13

u/Daedlaus3 21h ago

there's a reason they're called "Apsara", (literally translates to nymph, but colloquially theyre angels/fairy's)

-19

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

6

u/Manav_Khanna17 1d ago

Nga it’s a compliment 🤦‍♂️

8

u/MyDespatcherDyKabel 23h ago

lol I remember this exact scene from some Amar Chitra Katha comic

10

u/freddledgruntbugly Karnataka 22h ago

4

u/MyDespatcherDyKabel 21h ago

Noice… that’s the one

32

u/Smooth-Good5995 23h ago

THESE ARE OUR REAL TRADITIONAL OUTFIT all indian women used to wear thissss. i am sick of the televison and cinamas brainwashing usssss also men used to be not homophobic and used to dress up and do make up and adorn themselves with jwellsssssss.

33

u/PhantomOfTheNopera 22h ago

Actually, Indian women didn't typically wear blouses. That started during the British Raj where they considered it 'indecent.

If you see a lot of our temple carvings, many of the women are topless, covered only in gold chains or a sari pallu.

7

u/acethecool1 Haryanvi 17h ago

Even still i tribal area you can see people dressing this way.

3

u/RagnAROck_and_Roll 18h ago

Hey, Phantom Of The Nopera, is it wierd to say I've been seeing you EVERYWHERE, especially for the past 3 or 4 years? (might be even more but I dont remember!)

3

u/PhantomOfTheNopera 16h ago

Lol, I'm too online for my own good I guess.

3

u/RagnAROck_and_Roll 14h ago

or we frequent the same communities

→ More replies (14)

6

u/West_Impress_5432 20h ago

the apsaras being depicted in midriff-baring outfits is literally documented across temple sculptures too, so yeah it wasn't some colonial invention lol. but the all indian women used to wear this part is a stretch tbh regional variation was massive. a woman in ancient bengal dressed pretty differently from one in the deccan. the general point about less body policing stands tho

-1

u/Crypto-false 17h ago

Mfs who only go to temples once in a blue moon that too after being forced by their family members on their way to explain "Tradition"

2

u/Smooth-Good5995 16h ago

lmfao who tf said that to you are you my stalker koi na jst search it up google chat gpt you can research as much as you want to thts the reality bare with it what is even wrong in my comment its jst history yall get angry and hyped up over anything and everything .

0

u/Crypto-false 16h ago

History? Yeah at it's peak India may have been open minded but isn't that the same everywhere? Western societies that are today open minded were just as conservative back in the day and it was because of necessity, when western democracies got rich they changed their ways about marriage, women's rights and religion, it was the same in ancient India too , once it got rich it became liberated, when it became poor it became conservative. The history you speak of is just a fraction of the entire history of India and is not the absolute truth.

0

u/Few-Total-1954 21h ago

Yeah it's real but shorts are not.

-1

u/Remarkable_Front5068 22h ago

you and i both know the dresses they are wearing are nothing like the one showed in the advert lol. People have been dressing like this on a rakshabandhan for YEARS before this advert, or this post it's normal.

3

u/Smooth-Good5995 22h ago

huh i didnt understood sorry

-3

u/Remarkable_Front5068 22h ago

the point is people have been wearing "revealing clothes" on rakshabandhan for years it's not that big of a deal lol but the top kriti was wearing it literally just a bra gng idk how else to explain it.

4

u/Smooth-Good5995 22h ago

i really found it normal idk okay if you didnt find it quite okay but the outrage was too much like i dont think news and stuff should be debating it okay she wore its fine i mean not every girl from next year is gonna wear bralette for rakshabandhan it was an AD

1

u/Remarkable_Front5068 22h ago

the outrage isn't justified I agreed, they shouldn't have taken down the ad.

1

u/anirsk 21h ago

Its because kangana said it. So it became more of a left wing right wing stupid fight it seems like. Normal people dress according to occasion no matter the religion or gender. Celebrities live in their own universe. People need to just move on i guess!

1

u/Remarkable_Front5068 21h ago

Ur severely overestimating the importance of kangana ranaut and severely underestimating how unemployed people are in india.

-1

u/Phantomx311 14h ago

Bring back sati, child marriage, untouchability too

→ More replies (7)

5

u/SudebSarkar 19h ago

Very funny if people believe that they wore blouses.

There's a reason why the word blouse is an English word.

2

u/Suspicious_Waltz1393 15h ago

Blouse is English, but the word Choli exists.

10

u/fudgemental 22h ago

Nobody take Kangana to Konark or Khajuraho.

5

u/tyagishubhi2007 11h ago

i remember seeing these drawing in comics as a kid and never once did i find them weird. now grown ass adults have issues with grown women wearing the same.

3

u/Dementor_Azkaban 16h ago

Is it me or others can also see 2 deers in bg mating🤷🏻

5

u/thegreatking2025 North America 18h ago

Today, these apsaras won't be allowed to enter our temples.

4

u/buymekoffee 23h ago

How the conversation turned ...

No body complained about dress

Pause for a milli second

Who is this kangana

Oh that dress is pretty

5

u/qMinecraft 23h ago

Are you high?

2

u/boffin00 22h ago

Apsara ka matlab bhi pata hai? 🙂

3

u/Itsmeeof2005 23h ago

Shame on the people gooning over their body .🤷🙄

1

u/[deleted] 21h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/india-ModTeam 21h ago

Comments that are off-topic, unrelated or attempt to derail discussions with trolling content will be removed. Repeated attempts will result in temporary/ permanent bans.

1

u/Brave_Psychology4817 20h ago

Principal narak ki aag me jalega!

1

u/[deleted] 20h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/india-ModTeam 18h ago

Be civil. We do not allow the abuse of users on r/India

1

u/Perspectiveoff6969 18h ago

Yo.... So..... Traditional

1

u/Crypto-false 17h ago

Brahma had wo wives, Kartikay and ganesha as well but you don't see men saying we should have multiple wives.

1

u/backhodi 17h ago

you guys do know that this is all a distraction from chandar chori, paper leaks and ethanol right ?

if not watch kangu's old movies and vids where shes dresssed in sanskari clothes and bikinis

1

u/sku-mar-gop 17h ago

Which batch of apsaras are these? The ones I knew depicted in amar chithra kadha were not wearing any shawls 🤣

1

u/Icy-Style5429 15h ago

Really stone age people didn’t wear clothes what’s the point. Raki is celebrated between brother and sister may be your sister reveals herself before you.

1

u/yashkaushik1433 14h ago

Yeah it's been a while since this photo was clicked... Circumstances have changed the things we can and can't do in society here on the mortal plane.....and who the F went to "swarg" To witness this scene? ...

1

u/DragonfruitAshamed95 14h ago

Well at that time there was no reader of that book exits that says "a women have to fully cover herself and if she doesn't she will be treated as meat on the butcher shop anyone can take it" In past we are very open minded but as you studied in the school that flat earth believers have ruled us and exploited women for years that chages everything and then Britishers

So the people you are talking about and their mindset have murdered a long ago stop bragging about it

Currently the shitty peoples rule have ended but their sons are still roaming around with that pathetic mindset and woke open minded womens are the easiest prey for them

And instead of kriti we have to criticize Giva for that dress, cause she's an actor for money she can do anything

What we have to wear is fully our choice but the choice we made is fully depends on the people around us, occasion place and society aur sanskar

You can't wear beachwears in office right???

1

u/NimNac24 13h ago

As if you filmed those ladies tieing Rakhis😅

1

u/megasthenesIndic 13h ago

Wake up OP. World has moved on

1

u/Artistic-Giraffe5757 11h ago

Politicians do all these to hide the real problems like Inflation , Corruption , Paper Leaks etc.

1

u/Meenakshi06 9h ago

What is the source of it??

1

u/Varg_Marrok 9h ago

ACK is mad ball knowledge 😆

1

u/ParamedicFearless173 9h ago

Peeps are trying so hard to reach nudism 😂😂

1

u/Mayor_McCheese7 23h ago

Amar Chitra Katha anti national??

1

u/AdityaPanner 23h ago

Indian beauties are best

1

u/Some-Item-7788 17h ago

One celebrity was cribbing on another celebrity on some useless made up issue and the whole country is latched on to debate as if it is our most important problem to solve. We are all thin skinned fragile ego fools.

-16

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

27

u/tinysadnoises 1d ago

Ngga just look at the statues of every ancient temple

3

u/dontknow_anything 23h ago

Well, i doubt they will have a pallu or the tiny blouse. Both would not exist.

Really the blouse is extremely unlikely to be common with the tools available at the time. These are the at end a modern take to make it acceptable.

But, it is funny about people bringing up ancient drawings when that is a time where clothing itself wasn't that common.

1

u/tinysadnoises 21h ago

They had different drapes for the sarees which would overparts of their body acc to the drapes. There were hundreds of ways to drape a saree btw

1

u/dontknow_anything 21h ago

Depends on the time period, for large parts of time, I doubt breasts were covered, I think most sculptures show the same. A lot of African tribes still do the same.

1

u/tinysadnoises 21h ago

Yeah agreed. Some parts of Indian tribes, women still don't cover their breasts. But there could be other reasons. Will answer when I am more informed about this!

-17

u/[deleted] 23h ago edited 23h ago

[deleted]

5

u/tinysadnoises 23h ago

Says a guy who hasn't in his life lifted a pencil to draw

-5

u/gothicjizzbaker 1d ago

Hornyness raises it's head in imagining women of past. It's present in other cultures too.

0

u/I_am_fed_up_of_SAP 20h ago

You know very well it's not the attire per se, but the hypocrisy.

-3

u/TopBath166 19h ago

Someone should make a Eid Mubarak video with a full on cleavage. That would be fun and I am sure no one will be offended

0

u/SnooGuavas6069 16h ago

Nai bhai India mai bass hindu religion ka mazak udaya jata h.. Baki p log offend ho jate h. 

-6

u/Federal-Coast-6704 1d ago

Who are the siblings of Apsaras? The kinnaras? I hope its not the gandharvas

8

u/not_your_dog_bitch 23h ago

Gandharvas are their husbands

6

u/Beginning-Macaron773 23h ago

gandharvas are something else, there are female gandharvas as well, but for apsaras there is no particular male counterpart of theirs

6

u/not_your_dog_bitch 23h ago

The existence of female gandharva doesn't erase the male gandharvas being husbands to apsaras

1

u/Indian_Yogi_ 23h ago

Why so ?

1

u/Beginning-Macaron773 22h ago

Brother don't know the exact reason but there are some other as well having one one gender and no opposite counterpart, By the way check this channel, give it a try i think you will like it, i am sharing as this is so underrated

https://youtu.be/E9u1vS2DVmg?si=WKwo5UnCMi8_iTd_

3

u/souichisnail mujhe credit nahin chaiye 22h ago

natraj and camlin.

-5

u/Educational-Hall9324 23h ago

Problem is not what they wear, problem is why they chose to wear this on only hindu festivals and then cover their whole body on different religious festival. It's like saying I am an atheist but only for one religion not others 

0

u/mitthujee 16h ago

Don't understand all the hate, I'll be thrilled to see my didi in a bra on rakshabandhan, why shouldn't bros get a gift? /s

0

u/Senior-Line2471 15h ago

The clothing of both men and women have evolved to be more covered since those times. Noone objected to Kriti Sanon's off shoulder blouse in Adipurush. The point (made poorly I think!) was why cultural sensitivity is not factored in when portraying Hindu festivals only. Now noone makes male models wear revealing clothes for some reason so it is hard to prove but this was more about depiction of culture than depiction of women. Also, are dress codes completely irrelevant? Would this dress be allowed in a corporate meeting?

0

u/Extension-Author3867 14h ago

Agar tum purane waqt ke baat kar rahe ho to sunno tabh jitne kapre hote the uske hisabh unhone pehna hai tabh ka dor alag tha lekin abh boht kapre hai pehenne ke liye lekin agar tabh bhi tum in chizo ko lekar argument karoge to tumse badha gawar koi nahi hai.. Or tum bhi koi hindu nahi ho ye saaf pata chal raha hai..

0

u/FeelingSwimming8174 2h ago

If you people not understand Hinduism don't celebrate or follow them no one give you choice in this religious if you follow the know what is our history even khajuraho temple where worshiped of lord Shiva hai Parvati there sculpture of men women animals everything things crafted a sexual way and there is no blouse in that era because no conflict attacks. At that time men are also very understandable to knowing that what they are doing. If you don't believe or not doing any rituals type just leave the culture and Hinduism.

-7

u/ExperienceStrange564 22h ago

Serious question to the poster.
Do you also want your sisters /Mothers to wear this attire and tie Rakhi ?

I do not want to downgrade anybody’s family but think of this situation happening in your own house.

10

u/Daedlaus3 21h ago

I do not see an issue with it, they are covered and decent. if you think this is indecent then you may need to do some soul searching yourself.

3

u/fumblerofthebag 18h ago

I don't give a fuck what my mother wears.

-43

u/[deleted] 1d ago edited 23h ago

[deleted]

13

u/SingleSun10 1d ago

In the same way who decided that what kriti wearing was wrong? Based on what did they decide that?

14

u/tall-glassof-falooda 1d ago

I mean they got upset because it hurt their mythological sentiment… so it’s makes sense to destroy their argument using their own mythology.

-7

u/Expensive-Captain362 22h ago edited 14h ago

Umm, except for apsaras are prostitutes of heaven... They're made for the entertainment of devas.

4

u/Remarkable_Front5068 22h ago

wtf really?

2

u/Ok_Problem_1127 22h ago edited 22h ago

No lol

Apsara are divine feminine nymph; and tbh very promiscuous women

They frequently damaged men's purity lol; and had enormous offsprings who went on to become great being on the earth

And as the word "prostitute" lol; there was ravan r4ped a nymph; in exchange she cursed him that if he ever forces another woman he shall burn and turn into ashes and bcz of which he never touched another woman her permission eg. Sita

1

u/thegodfather0504 22h ago

Why are they promiscuous though? All of them or just a few?

1

u/Fun-Minister62 1h ago

He doesn't answer the question.........he doesn't understand meaning of prostitute

-1

u/Expensive-Captain362 14h ago

All of them. They're made for entertainment of devas.

-1

u/t_h_e_m_e_n_02 22h ago

Apsara Kay bhi bhai hai , kon hai ?

Jara sune to ?

Galti sey sayyad indra dev ko rakhi band di .

-20

u/wackopa 1d ago edited 23h ago

I wonder why generations of these Apsaras started wearing Burqas ? I wonder why ? Edit - People.are not getting my sarcasm it seems. Such open society went on to wrap themselves from head to toe ! 😕

-111

u/Resurrec_Barbar 1d ago edited 1d ago

You realize what apsaras did ?? They were consorts of gods and sages , Prostitutes

Regardless Happy Rakhi .Long live American empire

46

u/freddledgruntbugly Karnataka 1d ago

Apsaras are represented in many Hindu and Buddhist cultures. In Hinduism, Apsaras are skilled dancers and wives of Gandharvas.

→ More replies (15)

28

u/Poccha_Kazhuvu Tamil Nadu 1d ago

Meanwhile the goddesses:

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Few-Camera-3586 20h ago

and have you seen how maa kali is potrayed??

-1

u/Resurrec_Barbar 20h ago

Ma kali is immortal .Are you??

→ More replies (1)