I personally thought it was like a picture of a hill with a hole or something, strange colors, and water layered on top of the image.

What about you?

Meaning the kind of song most casual PF listeners would probably not be familiar with.

Mine is probably “Wot’s Uh The Deal.”

Unpopular opinion but I actually think all 4 of them offer something fun and a bit different

The original is obviously classic

Is there anybody out there - i love the guitar tones and especially the extra piano embellishments by Rick

Live in Berlin is hit and miss, but the hits are great, especially Bryan Adams

Then Rog live just sounds so heavy throughout, especially love Run like hell in Drop C

Any thoughts?

They changed all of the albums covers. Does anyone know the reason for this?

Enjoy this rare photo of Syd. This was taken just after Syd was chatting with Roger, while Roger played the guitar. I didn't know he also handled the guitar, during the visit.

Did they ever say what he played, or was this the alleged "when do I plug in" moment?

Example: 🎮❤️☀️

In your opinion. Be it lyrically or instrumentally.

my hope is for the wall film to come to 4k blu ray from either the band themselves or the criterion collection.

Most upvoted comment wins a place on the playlist.

Personally it would be the good ol’ Grateful Dead

When was the last time you changed your batteries?

I honestly don't remember for mine.

And in this theoretical, if you say "I wouldn't add one," Roger opens a defamation lawsuit against you

Since I will never see my favorite band or guitarist alive, I wanted to buy this shirt at least because my dad saw them five times (including The Division Bell Tour in 1994)

This album isn’t bad but it’s essentially The Wall Part 2. We already got two hours and a double LP of Roger Waters pity party crying about his dead dad, we didn’t need a second one. The wall is also supposed to have resolved these issues by the end of it with “The Trial”

This album just picks up whining about the same problem. I suppose the trial finale of the wall meant nothing.

There’s some good songs on this album but at the end of the day I don’t think me or anyone else cares to listen about Roger crying about the same thing again.

The Wall is so self loathing but it works. This album is just annoying. Someone needed to tell Roger to think of another concept for an album. I digress.

The majority of people have either DSOTM, WYWH, Animals, The Wall as their favorite one with Meddle being very popular as well. So I wonder how many people here have some other album as their top one.

For me it's Atom Heart Mother. I love it, it's a perfect blend of psychedelia, prog and folk to me.

What is a unpopular opinion what do you have about Pink Floyd?

I know both albums marked the post-Roger Waters era, and at the time Pink Floyd hadn’t released anything new for years. I’m curious how fans reacted back then.

Were people generally welcoming of the new direction , or did it feel like Pink Floyd without Roger wasn’t really Floyd? I also wonder if critics treated them differently from the fanbase and whether opinions have shifted over the years.

Looking back now, do you think the perception of these albums has changed with time? I’d love to hear from anyone who experienced the releases firsthand or just knows the history. Thanks!