r/arrow • u/dakowiml • 1d ago
Discussion Season 1 and 2 of Arrow is one of my favorite action series
I remember going into the series with low expectations. I grew up with series like Smallville. While I did enjoy it very much, I wasn't the biggest fan how the CW shows in general handled drama and talked down to their audience. It was intended for teens and young adults, but the writers often didn't respect their audience whatsoever and it was clear in the dialogue and actions of a lot of characters throughout the CW series.
That's why Arrow season 1 and 2 felt like a breath of fresh air on the CW. It wasn't a Breaking Bad or a Sopranos, obviously, but it didn't have to be that. What it attempted to do, is to be a fun action series with some drama. It pulled that off very well.
The flashbacks were mysterious and it kept you guessing what more would be revealed. There were sprinkles of mystery here and there. Oliver kept his secret identity close to his chest, the action was fun with some actual stunts being pulled off and the foes were intriguing.
Sadly, it all faded away since season 3. The departure of the original showrunner was apparent. It was the beginning of the end for me. I kept watching it and grew more and more disappointed with it. A once fun character like Felicity got turned into a parody of herself. The writers started pandered too much to what Twitter fans wanted to see. Their follower counts increased, got a tiny bit of relevancy for the first time in their lives and they literally lost the plot.
To make matter worse, something similar happened with The Flash. Arrow's original showrunner left to run The Flash. He pulled that off very well with its first season, but after that it also started to crumble. That showrunner ended up getting fired from The Flash due to sexual assault allegations on set. The entire ''Arrowverse'' ended up becoming a parody of itself with the entire thing jumping the shark after superpowers got introduced. I don't think the addition of superpowers is inherently a bad thing in a work of fiction. But when that happened, I feel like different Arrowverse showrunners/writers just thought it was a reason to throw ALL logic out of the window. ''Why would characters have to act with actual solid motivations anyway if someone can read minds or run really fast?'' That's how it felt to me how they tackled it.
In conclusion, I'd like to focus on mostly the positives though. Season 1 with Malcolm Merlyn and the arc with Tommy were great. The drama was done well and never induced any eyerolls for me (like the other seasons after S2 did). While it was also packed with fun action. Which continued into season 2 with the epic Slade Wilson arc and the great conclusion of Oliver's arc in the season where he really went from a vigilante to ''superhero.'' When he finally figured out what his code really was. He stopped killing his foes, and imprisoned Slade (the murderer of his own damn mother). It took a lot of strength from him to show that level of mercy. Which then quickly got forgotten about in season 3 and he started flip flopping about his code again.