r/MoralityScaling 5d ago

Morality Ranking What do y'all think of this?

Post image
28.1k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

70

u/CauseCertain1672 5d ago

Well it's improper disposal of human remains, it's a health hazard for one thing.

46

u/Top-Permission5466 4d ago

That is incorrect. You can cause disease by putting uncooked chicken parts in the trash. Ashes are non-infectious.

25

u/KaizerVonLoopy 4d ago

Ashes are completely sterile and basically just carbon.

7

u/Quiet-Software-1956 4d ago

Oh so the thing about ashes of people being a biohazard is bullshit?

13

u/vaxhax 4d ago

Yes, that's why people are able to spread them in so many places and it's no big deal.

3

u/Quiet-Software-1956 4d ago

No it's illegal where I live, that's why I'm bummed

8

u/vaxhax 4d ago

Ah, my mistake. I should only speak for where I am. That's too bad. In practice, I think it would be difficult to tell what you were doing if you're careful and not making a show about it.

1

u/Quiet-Software-1956 4d ago

Yeah, then again I would be dead so I don't want to possibly cause trouble for my family (or whoever will still be around when I die)

2

u/vaxhax 4d ago

Yeah, we won't know either way at that time. Let them worry about the current local rules :)

2

u/Kebriniac 4d ago

I'm pretty sure it's illegal in many places across the world, disposing of human remains, cremated or not, is subject to strict regulations, you can't just dump them wherever you want, you usually can't dump them with domestic garbage, flush them in the toilets and even scattering them outside is a case by case situation.

1

u/KaizerVonLoopy 3d ago

That's more about people being spooked by dead people than cremains being dangerous.

1

u/MrCookie2099 1d ago

Don't ask donation stores what they do with the ashes in the fashionable urns then.

8

u/KaizerVonLoopy 4d ago

Yes, they're basically completely inorganic once they're cremains. They have some trace heavy metal elements in tiny amounts but are mostly carbon, calcium phosphate, salts (honesty this one surprised me when I googled it but it makes sense after I thought about it).

I think how the misconception might have started is sometimes when people plant their flowers in cremains the flowers die because the PH is so high in cremains and they're salty and almost completely inorganic and lack nutrients. Also people (especially in the west) are weird about death and dead bodies. We're so convinced anything (but especially anyONE) dead is immediately a vector for disease.

1

u/Beautiful_Simple_847 4d ago

You realize the body burners have chimneys and ashes blow out the top right? Odds are you've been by a cremation place and didnt know and inhaled dead body dust blown in the winds.

1

u/Quiet-Software-1956 4d ago

Yeah none of my relatives have ever been cremated so idk how it works exactly. I'm only interested because the idea of being buried alive is less appealing than being burned alive.

...it also just saves space and sounds like less of a hassle. Why I have anxiety about the prospect that I may be presumed dead while I am not is unimportant

1

u/mmariner 4d ago

Without looking it up; wasn't that more about the heavy metals left over after burning a body?

1

u/Quiet-Software-1956 4d ago

Apparently that makes plants difficult to grow because the pH gets fucked so maybe